ADAMSVILLE

The Adamsville City Council meets at 7:00 p.m. on the third Monday of each month at the Adamsville City Hall.


Adamsville’s mayor is Tommy Morris (632-4443), whose current term expires in 2009.

Adamsville has four commissioners, two of which are up for election every two years.  The current commissioners, with the year they come up for reelection, are:

    Frank Lacey                                     2011

    Dwana Garrison (643-9402)            2011
    Mike Norris (632-0978)                   2009
    Jeff Browder                                     2009

Town Board Meeting

21 July 2008

If you are a big fan of train wrecks, you should have been at the Adamsville city commission meeting July 21.

In two hours of embarrassing spectacle, Mayor Tommy Morris repeatedly and emphatically berated the commissioners for not giving the job of city recorder to Pam Young (who just happens to be his niece by marriage) and stridently (and unsuccessfully) demanded that the commissioners fire City Manager Terry Thrasher.


Morris was himself the recipient of extended scolding by Frank Lacey, the mayor’s one steady ally on the council, after which Morris returned the favor, revealing that he and Lacey, who is seeking the Republican nomination for state representative (hoping to add that office to his current collection, which includes membership on the school board, chairmanship of the school board, Adamsville commissioner, and Adamsville vice-mayor), had discussed dismissing Thrasher from his office, “but you [Lacey] wanted to wait until after the elections.”  Lacey did not dispute Morris’s assertion that the discussion had taken place, but he fell back on the quibble that he hadn’t actually used the words “after the election”—as though “December” does not come “after the [November] elections.”


(It is probably fair to say that the Lacey/Morris honeymoon is over.)


Lacey also demonstrated amazing flexibility regarding the unavoidable conflicts of interest inherent is his holding office as both an Adamsville Commissioner and a member of the McNairy County school board, abstaining from voting on one matter (paving Hughes Street), but not only voting but actually seconding a motion on another (contributing to the school system’s One to One Program).  Should he succeed in his quest for a seat in the state house of representatives, Lacey will be able to teach the old-time pols there a lesson or two …. 


Only one member of the Adamsville Town Board emerged unscathed and untarnished from the July meeting, and that was Commissioner Dwana Garrison, who had the good fortune to be absent.


A caution.  This report is l-o-o-o-n-g.  The raw transcription of what was said at the meeting—and I don’t transcribe every word, only those of note—was forty-two pages long and contained nearly 15,000 words.  The report below contains most of those words, with comments inserted to enable the reader to follow the flow of the meeting.  I have been working on this steadily since Tuesday morning, and it is now Saturday afternoon, and I would not have subjected myself to the agony of living with that two-hour meeting for nearly five days had I not believed that it was important for the people of Adamsville and McNairy County to have a full account of what transpired.  Now, if I can spend all that time and effort preparing this damned thing, the least you can do is read it.


So here is the meeting, in excruciating detail.  Hold on to your hats, because it’s a hell of a rough ride.


* * *


After the minutes of the regular 16 June meeting were approved on a motion by Jeff Browder, seconded by Mike Norris, Mayor Tommy Morris fired the first salvo of the night.  Addressing the minutes of the special called meeting of 30 June, Morris said, “it’s not legal, and I’m just not going to have anything to do with anything that’s not legal.  There’s been nothing advertised saying this was a legal meeting.  And if it was, even, a legal meeting, you discussed other items on it.  Our charter flatly says, nothing, on a so-called, special called city commission meeting, can be discussed except what is on the agenda.  And it was nothing but the budget.  It’s an illegal meeting.  I’ll let Mr., I’ll let our legal department have his say on it.”


“Well,” town attorney Ken Seaton began, “I learned, two or three days ago, in discussion with the mayor about this—June 30th meeting is what we’re talking about, right?  And it was the mayor’s position that there was no public notice for the meeting.  I spoke with Terry [city manager Terry Thrasher], I think Terry and I discussed it very briefly, and Ms Jimmie Ann [city recorder Jimmie Ann Burks], and I learned that in fact by mistake the notice didn’t get to the paper, and I’d have to agree with the mayor, that if there wasn’t proper notice, that any action that was taken at the meeting is ineffective.  I think it can be cured very—  Whatever action was taken, if the commission wants to take the action it intended to take on June 30th, that the problem can be cured by motion and a vote.  Now, this is serious business, and I know everyone involved understands it.  I think an innocent mistake was made, and there’s no reason for me to believe there was any intent on anyone’s part.  There wasn’t any intent to have a secret meeting.  I don’t know if this meeting was discussed at the June meeting.  I don’t think it was—”


“Certainly it was,” Browder said emphatically, and Norris agreed: “It sure was.”


“—and the problem is,” Seaton continued, “there just wasn’t public notice, to satisfy me.”


“Well in that—” Browder began, “I probably wouldn’t have been here.  I thought we got it in the paper.”


“No,” Burks advised, “we didn’t get it in the paper.  Remember, we posted it on the doors here, but it did not get in the paper.”


“I didn’t even realize it was posted on the doors,” Seaton said.


“No,” Mayor Morris asserted.  “I walked all the way around this place.  It was not posted on the doors.”


“Well,” Burks disagreed, “I have a copy of it here, and it come off the door.”


“Well,” Morris insisted, “I don’t care whether you’ve got a copy or not, it was not on them doors, because I walked all the way around it.  Somebody might have, a cat might have moved it or something, but it wasn’t on the door.”


“No,” Burks responded patiently, “a cat didn’t move it.”


Returning to the issue of the minutes of the 30 June meeting, Seaton said, “I think these minutes ought, and they are available, for the public to see, and these minutes summarize what discussions did take place.”


“But I think it ought be null and void,” Morris insisted.  “And if we want to have another meeting of the city commission on a special called meeting on the budget, I say let’s advertise it.  But let’s not start this— Now this has been going on for quite a bit.  I didn’t even have— The mayor, now, wasn’t even notified that you was going to have a meeting.  [Turns to Browder.]  I found it out from your son.”


“I—” Browder began, then he started over.  “We all left the regular stated meeting in June knowing it was coming.  You were there, right?”


“Yeah,” Morris acknowledged, “I was at the— But I’ve got a many a things to do besides.  This is what your people up here is supposed to do.  They’re supposed to remind you of things.”


Seaton observed that “It is in the minutes for the—”


“Oh, yeah,” Morris interrupted, “I know it’s in the minutes.”


“—for the last regular meeting, June 30th,” Seaton concluded, miscalling the actual date.


“But it was not advertised to the citizens,” Morris insisted.  Addressing the board members, he said, “You got a letter; you got a letter; he got a letter; Dwana—  But I didn’t get a letter.”


“I didn’t get a letter,” Browder said.


“Well, I was told everybody got a letter,” Morris replied.


“Nobody got a letter,” Norris asserted.


Turning to Lacey, Morris asked, “Did you get a letter, Frank?”


“No,” Lacey answered, shortly.


“You told me you did,” Morris insisted, showing the first hint of his irritation with his erstwhile ally, which was to rise steadily throughout the long meeting.


“I said I got a phone call,” Lacey insisted.


“We all got a phone call,” Norris said.


“I didn’t get one,” Morris said, in an aggrieved tone.


Browder said, “I came in to pay my water bill, is the way I found out about it.  But I knew about it before time.”


“People has got other jobs to do,” Morris said, returning to his theme.  “This is what you hire people in here to do.  Remind you of these things.  And I’ll still say y’all took action on stuff that wasn’t even supposed to be took action on.”


Seaton then attempted to get the meeting back on track. “There was a voice vote—according to these minutes.  I wasn’t here.  But there was a voice vote on the budget, and I, it’s my recommendation that the council take that back up.  There was a, looks like, a vote on a tax resolution, that action ought to be taken on.”


Browder said, “I think we should be able to take care of whatever’s got to be took care of tonight, can’t we?”


“No,” Morris insisted.  “Got to advertise them.”


Seaton disagreed. “I think you can take care of it tonight.  This meeting [referring to the meeting then underway, the 21 July meeting] was advertised,” and Norris and Browder agreed.


Lacey appeared to believe the budget issue was already resolved.  “I think the budget was taken care of.  Because it’s his budget.  He presented it.  Surely he’d be for it.  And we all agreed with it.”


“Hah!” Morris said.  “I wasn’t even here when they turned it in to y’all a second time, for the reading of it.  I didn’t know nothing about it.”


“This was,” Lacey replied, “it’s the same budget we approved at the June 16th meeting.”


“Yes,” Morris responded, “but I am supposed to report to, to present the budget.”


“I won’t argue that,” Lacey said.


“If I ain’t here,” Morris continued, “how am I going to present the budget?”  When there was no response to that question, Morris returned to his familiar theme.  “I just want you people to quit taking over, and just going to do what you want to do.”


“Maybe I may be confused,” Browder said, returning to the budget question.  “I thought the budget was presented at the first meeting, and what our quote-unquote illegal meeting was the second reading of that budget.  Was it not?”


“When you have an illegal meeting,” Morris said, “everything is null and void at an illegal meeting.  Folks, the Sunshine Law is going to kick in on you.”


“I didn’t use the word illegal,” Seaton pointed out.  “There was some notice to the public.  There was scheduled at the public meeting, at the regular monthly, June, and I, and it’s the personnel’s position here at city hall that it was posted—”


“No,” Morris insisted, “it wasn’t posted.”


“Well,” Seaton continued, “whether it was or it wasn’t, it wasn’t published in the newspaper, and I think it should have been.  I’m not saying it was an illegal meeting.  I’m saying there’s some questions about it, and it’s my recommendation that you deal with, you address these questions by bringing these, all these issues that were discussed up for discussion again tonight, and you take action on, or you don’t take action.  And I would ask that the commission concede that that’s the way to deal with it, and that whatever was addressed at that June 30th meeting ought to be addressed again.  The point is, I didn’t say it was an illegal meeting.  I don’t think that’s a word that fits the facts.”


“What’s, what is [an] illegal meeting?” Morris demanded of Seaton.  After a few moments of silence, he said, “Tell me.  You’re the, uh, you’re the legal thing.”


“An illegal meeting is an illegal meeting,” Seaton finally responded, unhelpfully.


“Well, I—” the mayor began, then he started over.  “It wasn’t advertised.  It’s not under any of these papers right here.” [Indicates some newspapers.]


“It was advertised—” Seaton began.


“Where?” Morris demanded.


“—but it was not advertised in the paper,” Seaton concluded.


“Where?” Morris repeated.  “It ain’t advertised in this paper.”


“I said it was not advertised in the paper,” Seaton repeated, with obviously strained patience.


“It wasn’t advertised on the doors,” Morris said again, “because I come up here and looked. [Pause]  Now this has been going on quite a while, and I’m, you know, I’m just—  I’m tired of it.”


After another pause, Seaton observed that “the underlying problem, is a lack of communication.  That’s one of—  You know, we had a problem a month or so ago, that involved communication.  I’m not saying whose fault it is, but that’s the problem.  In addition, there was a mistake made about getting it into the paper.  That was just an honest mistake.  I don’t think it needs to be blown out of proportion.”


“When is the end of the fiscal year?” Norris asked.  “June 30th?  Okay.  Tommy, are you not aware that we have to have two readings on this budget?”


When Morris indicated that he was aware of that fact, Norris continued. “Well, you’re the mayor, and you’re supposed to be leading us—”


“That’s right,” Morris interjected emphatically.


“—so why didn’t you—” Norris continued, “you knew it needed to be approved before June the 30th, so we could act on the budget.  Why didn’t you lead—”


“Why didn’t he [Thrasher] get it to me?” Morris complained.  “I don’t know all these figures.”


“You’re the one,” Norris began.  You’re the leader.”


“Yeah,” Morris said, sarcastically, “y’all let me lead a lot, don’t you?  Y’all go and up-serp [usurp] everything that I try to do—”


“Well,” Norris insisted, “that’s because you won’t lead.”


“I’ve led a lot more than you have, in my life,” Morris responded.  “But just like this right here.  This shouldn’t have never been discussed, on this matter.  A special called meeting is a special called meeting, and it’s stated right in the charter.  Only one thing will be—”


“Okay,” Norris interrupted, “so we’ve got an illegal meeting, here.  All we did was to do the budget, here.  Let’s approve the budget for the second reading and get on with this meeting.”


“No—” Mayor Morris insisted.


“We’re beating a dead horse,” Norris replied plaintively, and the meeting momentarily dissolved into confusion as several people spoke at once.


After several seconds, Morris said, “I’m trying to get it straight to you and him and him [indicating the three commissioners present], and Dwana ain’t here, but what needs to be done to keep this city straight?”


“Use a little common sense,” Norris responded.  “That’s what you need to do.”


“I believe I’ve used more than you do, buddy,” Morris replied.


“I don’t know,” Norris said.


At this point Burks asked Browder is he was going to make a motion, and Browder in turn asked, “Are we in a place where we can make a motion?”


“Wait a minute!” Morris objected.  “We’re not making a motion until I get through.  I’m the one that’s running, I’m the one that’s running this.  That is— You can’t take that out of that charter.  I’m the one that leads—”


“Tommy,” Browder said, resignedly, “I’m not arguing that.  All I want to do is see this meeting proceed at some point in time.”


“Let’s get on with it,” Norris agreed.


“We will proceed,” the mayor responded, “but I want to get my views across.”


“You got your views across,” Browder replied.


“No, I haven’t yet,” Morris insisted.  “I haven’t yet. Just like this tax resolution; you passed that.  That’s—”


“We discussed that at the last meeting!” Norris said.


“You cannot discuss it on a special called meeting, Mike,” Morris responded.  “You can not.  The only one item can be discussed on a special called meeting.  Isn’t that right?” he then asked Seaton.


“Well,” Seaton replied, “I think there’s, yes, there’s truth to that.  I don’t …”


“And just like this Imagination Library,” Morris continued.  “It was put in on a special called meeting.  Just like, to give $500 to—”


After some confused discussion about whether the issue had been raised at the regular meeting or the called meeting, Morris continued.  “I told Terry, I said here’s what she wants.  I said, she wants five hundred or maybe a thousand, but he said the only thing we need to give her is a hundred.  Now, didn’t you say that?”


“Five hundred,” Thrasher replied.  “I said we could stand five hundred; we couldn’t stand a thousand.”


“You told me one hundred dollars, Terry,” Morris said.  “This is what goes on between me and him.  All right, and then here’s another thing.  You started talking about the employees, hiring the employees.  That wasn’t supposed to be talked about at the special called meeting.”  After a long pause, Morris turned to Seaton and asked, “Was it?”


“I agree with you, mayor,” Seaton said.  “The special called meeting was on June 30th for the second reading of the budget.  And, to be run in the paper.  And these other things shouldn’t be discussed.  It’s just that simple.  I think you’ve made your point.”


“It don’t do no good,” Morris said, continuing his plaint.  “They go right ahead and do it even after that.  I’m wanting some action from it, some way.  I’m tired of it.  They need to go by this charter right here, is what they need to do…. What do we need to do now?  Is there any way that these people can be reprimanded?”


“I think they’ve been adequately reprimanded,” Seaton responded.  “Maybe more than adequately, Mayor.  I think you’re making— There may be a lot of issues, and a lot of problems, but I think enough has been said about this.  There wasn’t any intent.  Everybody was together.  Some things come up, and relatively minor things were discussed at that meeting.  I think everybody needs to learn from it; I’m sure everybody has.  And the next time there’s a special meeting to discuss a budget, I think everybody will remember that the discussion needs to be limited to what the meeting is called for.”


“Every time I’ve every called for one,” Morris continued, undeterred, “or anybody’s called for one, when I’m here, I say only thing can be discussed is this particular item.  But no, they didn’t even send me a, call me, do nothing, send me a notice that they was going to have a meeting.  That’s what tees me off so bad.  They’re just, really, trying to make me look bad.  But I’m not approving, myself, this meeting, minutes.  The special called meeting.”


“But can we as a committee approve these minutes?” Norris asked.


“I don’t see how you can,” Morris responded.


Norris then asked Seaton, “Can we, Mr. Attorney?”


“What I’d ask you to do,” Seaton responded, “somebody make a motion to accept what I’ve said about this, and—”


“Which was?” Norris asked.


Seaton replied, “Which was that there’s problems with the meeting, and all actions the committee, the commission took at the meeting should be ineffective, and—”


“We can handle this under old business, can we not?” Browder asked.


“Any time you want to,” Seaton said, “as far as I’m concerned in this meeting—”


“What do you want us to do?” Norris asked.  “To take this out, and then vote on it again?”


“Open it up—” Seaton replied.  “Open each issue up for discussion, and discuss it, and vote on it if you want to.  But I think, I guess, I feel like there needs to be a motion and a second and a vote to accept what I’m saying.  And declare that any action taken by the commission at that June 30th meeting is ineffective.”


“I move we accept Mr. Seaton’s recommendation,” Browder said.  “Handle the business at this meeting.”


Norris seconded the motion, and then Mayor Morris asked, “Now, this is to kick it out, and start all over?”


“That’s one way to put it.” Seaton replied.  “It’s to find that what happened at that meeting was not effective.”


Mayor Morris called the question, and the motion passed by a unanimous vote.


Norris then said, “I would like to make another motion that we enter into discussion about the second reading on the budget for 2008-2009, to approve it.”


“Well, Mike,” Browder said, in an effort to get back to the agenda, “why don’t we just follow the regular order of business here on the agenda.  I mean, that’s, you know, we’re going to handle that, that’ll be old business.  The budget is old business.  The tax, and Imagination Library.”


“Okay,” Norris agreed.


“What I see there, though,” Mayor Morris said, “I know y’all are not going to agree with this, but that should be advertised for another meeting.”


Browder asked, incredulously, “We can’t approve our budget on a second reading at a regular stated meeting—”


“It wasn’t advertised,” Morris interrupted.


“It doesn’t have to be advertised,” Norris asserted.


“Well, it does—” Morris insisted.


“I think budget meetings have to be,” Lacey opined, “you have to advertise that you’re talking about.”


“What about it, Ken?” Browder asked Seaton.


“It’s not our budget,” Lacey said, before Seaton could answer.  “It’s the mayor’s budget,  He’s the one—”


“I think you can take action on it right now,” Seaton said, responding to Browder’s question, “but I don’t know where you get—”


“The budget has to be printed in the newspaper, in its entirety,” Thrasher interjected, “with the 501-c-3 expenditures.  Now, whether you can vote on it tonight and run it in the paper next week, I can’t answer that.”


“No,” Seaton said, with unhelpful ambiguity.


“Has to be run in the paper twice?” Browder asked.


“No,” Burks responded, “it’s already been run in the paper.”


“Just once,” Thrasher said, also responding to Browder’s question.


“It’s been run though—” Norris began, only to be interrupted by Browder, who asked, “Well, is it one or two times?”


“Two times to begin with,” Morris insisted.


“One time,” Burks said.  “And you run it in the paper one time.”


Thrasher, attempting to bring this “Who’s on First?” routine to an end, said succinctly, “Meet, vote on it, and run it in the paper, and then meet and vote on it.”


“This will be the second reading,” Burks observed.  “They already voted the first time.”


“Right,” Thrasher agreed.  “Did the budget make the paper?”


“Yes,” Burks replied.


“Okay,” Thrasher said, as though that settled it.


But Mayor Morris thought otherwise. “The first budget did—”


“It’s the same budget,” Thrasher interjected.


“—but the second budget didn’t,” Morris continued.  “The second reading of the budget did not make the paper.  I’ve got the papers.”


“No,” Burks explained, “the budget was printed in the paper.  And all y’all need to do is the second reading on the budget.”


“But it’s got to be advertised,” Morris continued to insist.  “To let the people know, that their—”


“Is there a problem with waiting,” Seaton finally asked, “if the mayor thinks it needs to be advertised?”


“What’s the problem with waiting?” Morris demanded.  “We’ve been here a hundred and something years.”


Burks explained that “You have to pass a resolution to operate on the old budget if you’re going to—”


“Is that the only problem?” Seaton asked, and Thrasher answered, “Yeah.”


Terry: “Yeah.”


“—if you’re going to wait,” Burks concluded.


“It’s no problem,” Thrasher repeated, “You can do that, and do it at next month’s meeting, if you want to.”


“That’s fine with me,” Morris said.


“But,” Thrasher added, “you need to get a motion to operate under the 2007-2008 budget until the August meeting.”


Browder then made a motion to that effect, which Norris seconded.  In the vote that followed, Lacey and Norris voted no, while the mayor and Browder voted yes.  After Morris announced that the motion failed, Norris said that he had changed his mind, but when Morris asked what he had changed it to, Norris replied “No,” which was in fact the way he had originally voted.


“Well,” Morris asked, apparently rhetorically, “what are you going to do?”


“We shall see,” Norris responded, cryptically.  “We shall see.”


It was at this point that the normally supportive Lacey, who has been Morris’s protégé ever since taking office in January, took his first nip at the hand that fed him. “I think,” Lacey said, “I think it’s time for you, Mayor, to run the city, and it’s your dad-gummed budget and I don’t understand why you have a problem with us approving your budget.  We’ve already approved it once.  I don’t understand why you would cost us more money, more time.  If you want, this is what you wanted, so, I mean, it’s your budget.  I’m ready to approve it.”


“Frank,” Morris replied, “I wasn’t even invited at my budget hearing.”


“You didn’t have to be invited,” Norris observed.


“I sure did,” Morris insisted.  “They didn’t tell me about it.”


“I’m not, you know, all that’s water under the bridge,” Lacey said.  “We have a city to run, and we’re not acting very—”


“If y’all would quit acting like kids,” Morris interrupted, “we could run it.”


“I’m ready to approve a budget,” Lacey said, impatiently.  “And we can do it legally, so I don’t see why we don’t do it.  I make a motion that we approve the budget on second reading.”


“Absolutely,” Browder said, emphatically.


“Was that a second?” Thrasher asked, but before Browder could respond, Norris said, “I’ll second.”


“Can he do that?” Morris asked, turning to Seaton.


“He can make that motion,” Seaton replied, “y’all can vote on it, and if I see a problem with it I’ll make a report to that effect and we’ll have to call a special meeting and do something.  I don’t know what we’ll do.”


“I think it would be dangerous to call a special meeting,” Lacey said, and the other two commissioners agreed.


“I ain’t coming to no more special meetings.” Browder said.


“Well,” Norris said, “neither am I.”


“That’s it,” Browder added.


“I mean,” Norris said, “this is ridiculous.”


After some crosstalk, Seaton regained the floor. “The question I asked a while ago was, is it a problem, is there expense, is it an issue to just operate under this old budget until next month?  The answer I got was, there way no problem, and it seems to me like the best solution would be pass the motion Jeff made—”


Lacey interrupted. “There is an expense, and there’s no reason—”


“Well,” Seaton replied, “I was told there wasn’t.  If there is, what is it?”


“It would be the advertising expense,” Lacey answered.


“Frank,” Morris said, playing down the significance, “we’ve operated on the old budget through November.”


“You’re right,” Lacey agreed, “and I have done it—”


Norris interrupted to say, “We shouldn’t be doing that.”


Lacey then resumed his criticism of the mayor.  “I’ve done everything I know, for the benefit of this city, and for you, and many times been the only one here to support you, and I don’t understand why in the world you’re trying to accuse me of violating anything.  And I’m not the one that didn’t didn’t notify you, I’m not the one that, I didn’t do any of this, but yet, by golly, you’re willing to persecute me with everybody else, and I haven’t done anything wrong, Tommy.  Not a dad-gummed thing, and this is a good budget, and you presented it the first time.  I don’t know why you weren’t included the second vote, but we need to vote on it and get on with business.  We have a city to run.  We’ve got a whole bunch of other things to go over, here, and we still haven’t accomplished many other things that we said we were going to do in earlier meetings.  This happens about, seems like about every two years.  This is just that time that we have to work through it.”


“Well,” Morris said, “I still say I didn’t present the second reading of the budget, and I’m not going to stand behind it.  Especially, they raised taxes and everything else on it.”


“Nobody’s raised taxes,” Lacey stated.


“They put the tax in there—” Morris began, only to be cut off by his erstwhile ally.


“It’s the exact same budget,” Lacey said.  “On June 16, this [the minutes] says, ‘Mayor Morris says that he thought this was a good budget.’  It’s the exact same budget.”


“All right,” Morris said, “but this was voted on on this meeting [the 30 June meeting].  This was even voted on to give the museum curator $11 an hour, which shouldn’t have never even been in there.”


“You know,” Lacey said with rising impatience, “the money’s already there.  It’s got nothing to do with this meeting.  They can do with their money what they want to do with it.”


Morris persisted. “But it shouldn’t even been brought up, is what I’m saying, Frank.  It shouldn’t even have been brought up.”


“It was a budget issue,” Lacey said.  “It can be discussed.”


“The only thing you ought to have done at that budget meeting,” Morris continued, “if you’d have had me where I knew I was invited to them things, all you’d have had to done was up or down the budget.  But no, y’all says, ‘We’ll do it without Morris.’”


“No,” Lacey replied with evident annoyance, “’Y’all’ didn’t say that.  ‘Y’all’ didn’t say that.  We asked— No one knew where you were—”


At this point Browder reentered the fray. “Well, now, as far as all the notification goes, nobody notifies me it’s time to go to work in the morning.  The meeting was talked about in the regular stated meeting when the budget was presented.”


Norris agreed. “We knew we were going to have a second reading, and the end of the fiscal years was June the 30th.  Everybody agreed that we wanted to have the second reading before June the 30th.”


“I’ll be the first one to admit,” Browder said, “that June 30th meeting was not in the paper.  I was under the impression that it had been in the paper.  I guess maybe I’m at fault for not looking through the paper and seeing it, and I think we’ve already taken care of that issue.  I don’t know why we can’t go forward with our budget from this point.”


“Let’s get back to your issue that you know to go to work,” Morris said, referring to Browder’s remark a few moments earlier.  “You know you’ll get fired if you don’t go to work, so—”


Browder’s response matched the mayor’s tone: “I guess the only difference in that is, and this is, they ain’t going to fire you, right?”


“Well, they will, someday,” Morris replied, “if you don’t do your job, and you don’t show up for work.”


“We had a motion—” Browder began, wearily.


“Let’s get this over with—” the mayor began, only to be interrupted by a “Hallelujah!” from Browder.


“—what are we going to do?” Morris continued.  “You, somebody made a motion or something.  I’m tired of fooling with y’all.”


Lacey responded, “The motion on the table to approve the budget, and the second reading, as presented, like it was in the first meeting.”


“I’ll second the motion,” Norris said, and Mayor Morris called the question, but when Thrasher began to call the roll, Morris objected.


“Wait a minute,” he said


“I thought you questioned the motion [that is, called for a vote],” Thrasher said.


“I’m fixing to talk,” Morris said.


“Oh,” Thrasher responded.  “Okay.”


But Lacey said, “You called the question.  That means no more discussion.”


“Boy,” Morris responded, “you getting technical in your old age, ain’t you?”


“No,” Lacey replied, explaining that he was merely stating the rules.


Morris then had his say. “The only thing I’ve got to say about this, I still say it’s wrong, I need to hammer to y’all people you cannot do just what you want to do.  So now you can have your vote.”


The motion carried, with Morris casting the only no vote, after which Morris muttered, “Motion passed on conditions.  Seaton is going to see if there’s any wrongdoing.”


* * *


Morris then turned to the agenda and read, “’Reports.  Financial.’  By somebody I don’t know who is—”  In fact, the next word on that line of the agenda was “Thrasher.”


Lacey interrupted the mayor in mid-sentence: “I make a motion we approve the financial report.”


“All of them?” Morris asked.


“The financial report,” Lacey repeated.  “It has to be done separate.”


Browder seconded the motion, but before the vote could be taken Morris said, “I’ve got a question about it.  On this— I may be wrong, looking at this, though.  Last year, I’m looking right here, as of 2007-08, as of 6/30 of ‘08, is this the last year, here?  We’ve got some that’s run way over.”  There then followed some discussion during which Mayor questioned individual line items that have run over, and Thrasher and other city employees tried to explain to him that it’s the totals that count and not the individual items.  When the mayor finally ran out of questions the financial report passed by a unanimous vote.


Lacey then made a motion, which was seconded by Norris, that the remain reports be approved, which was done by a unanimous vote after some discussion.


Mayor Morris then moved on to old business, beginning with MuniGas.


“Well,” Seaton observed, “not a lot has changed,” and indeed nothing emerged in the ensuing twelve minutes of discussion to contradict that observation.  Perhaps the most significant item of information to emerge was Seaton’s own acknowledgement of the complexity of the MuniGas contract: “The issue is,” the town attorney said, “this contract is so long and complicated, and I, if you guys want to spend, I don’t know, probably a couple thousand dollars having one of these Bass [unintelligible], some lawyer like that, take a look at this, and I’m sure they’re going to say it’s fine.  But I don’t know.  I’m sorry to put y’all in the position I’m putting you in about this, but I just don’t feel comfortable telling you that I understand the contract and that I’m okay with it.  I wouldn’t have one problem with y’all relying on the good reports you’ve had regarding these folks, in moving forward.  You just, I think, need to make a decision, do you want to spend some money to get an expert take a look at it, or do you want to go ahead and make a deal.  Or not make a deal.  Let me say one more thing, Mayor.  I hope, and is guess this is wishful thinking on my part, but I could talk to a lawyer that had already looked at this, and knew what they were doing, and given a good opinion about it.  I did talk to one lawyer that works for TVA, and of course she finally said, again, ‘I look at this from TVA’s point of view, and I’m not going to give you anything you can rely on.’ …  I can understand where she was coming from, and where probably every other lawyer I talk to would about be coming from.”


The rest was largely a rehash of information covered at earlier meetings, and the discussion ended with no action being taken.


The next few items were disposed of more quickly.  Thrasher reported, regarding the Downtown Project, that “all the deeds have been signed and registered and it’s all in TDOT’s hands.  It’s been sent to TDOT, we’re waiting on them to take action.”


Norris added that he had “talked to Bart a week or so ago and tried to get some sort of time frame, and if everything goes right we’re looking at probably the middle of September, something like that, maybe to put a shovel in the sand.”


Police Chief Bill McCall reported on the “Speed Cameras” situation. “Got in touch with Redflex the next day after y’all asked me to look into the matter of getting a couple of speeding cameras, or the possibility of it.  And I did.  Got a letter back from him by fax, thanking us for our interest in it.  It’s not going to be a quick thing, I can tell you that.  It’s going to be pretty prolonged, because they have problems with populations under ten thousand, because of the expense of installing these systems.  But he says that don’t mean it can’t be done.  Get me some data.  So I’m supplying him with the necessary data.”


The town’s “Vision/Mission Statement” was tabled without significant discussion, then, Thrasher reported on the last item of old business, which was listed, somewhat confusingly, as “New Businesses.”


“We’ve got,” Thrasher began, “if you’re not aware of it, a company called Pickwick Express has rented the eastern part of the Quick-Mart building, and he’s got out a little blurb.  I think his first edition is September the 1st.  It’s going to be a website, free advertising for individuals, business advertising for businesses, and, I don’t know.  It’s just a small business.  I thought y’all would want to know about it.”


“We’ve got a client looking for one acre, up to two acres of land on 64 highway for a retail business.  That’s as far as we’ve gotten with him.  We’ve sent him whatever we know of the property that’s available.  He hasn’t come down and talked to anymore, so there’s a possibility of a retail business coming somewhere on 64.


“And this gentleman called me again today, and he will borrow our conference room one upcoming Saturday, and will be interviewing potential employees for a sewing factory to go in the Garan Building.”


“That’s for sure going to happen?” Norris asked.


“Well,” Thrasher responded, “a lot will depend on how many people he gets, that’s ready to go to work.  He’s really sweating the fact that he will not be able to get enough labor.  That’s why he’s going to use the conference room, and talk to people.”


“How many you need?” Norris asked.


“Thirty,” Thrasher replied.  “Minimum.”


“That’s the reason they left the first time,” Mayor Morris observed, “on account of couldn’t get no labor.”


Browder asked, “How big of a portion of that building is he planning on getting, Terry, has he said?  Do you know?”


“About twenty or thirty thousand square feet,” Thrasher said.  “Basically, where L&A, or L&S Sales, the part they were in.”


At this point Mayor Morris addressed two men in the audience, asking “Who are y’all with?”


“Hart, Freeland and Roberts,” one of them responded.


“Hart, Freeland and Roberts,” Morris repeated.  “You’re not on the agenda, are you?”


“No,” the man acknowledged.


Morris asked the commissioners if  they wanted “to listen to them talk” before the board continued with the regular agenda, and when the board agreed to do so the man who had spoken rose to his feet.


“I’m Allan Pettigo, with Hart, Freeland and Roberts, and this is Kyle Dunn.  And we responded to a letter for proposals, request for proposals on a water and sewer study, and so we’ve got, I’ve got the water proposal in my hand.  He’s got the sewer.  And basically it’s just to take a look at the system, see where it stands, what the current state, and then how it might be improved.  We’ve got cost numbers in there with a table showing the labor hours involved.  We tried to look at it from the standpoint of what’s affordable.  You can study things to death, or you can have somebody that has objective eyes kind of look at it and make their determination and then write down their findings and then send it to you, and then you’ve got something you can look at and build on, as far as a plan, to go ahead with any changes you need to make.  So, we can go into it in depth, or just leave it here to read at your leisure, but we’ve got seven copies that we can leave for you.”


“Why don’t you just leave it?” Morris said.  “We’re ‘in depth,’ I think, tonight.”


* * *


Pettigo and Dunn then took their leave, and Mayor Morris proceeded on to the “New Business” portion of the agenda, skipping over the first two items without comment.  Those two items, which he would come back to later in the meeting, were:


(A) Dismissal - Terry Thrasher; and

(B) Illegal Meetings


Item (C) under new business was “Imagination Library,” but as Marge Blassingame was not there to make the presentation the board at first decided to put it off to the following month, only to have it reemerge a few minutes later.


Item (D) was “Close APD Drug Fund,” and Burks reported that “we’ve been told by the auditors we could close that little fund.  We don’t collect drug money anymore.  They do that through the county drug task force, so we won’t be getting any money to add to it, and we just about spent it all.  And we took part of it out to go on one of Bill’s cars, and part of it to outfit those cars.  So they had made a recommendation last year that we might want to close it out, but y’all have to vote to close it.”


“How much is in there?” Morris asked.


“Oh, right now there’s about $2,000,” Burks said.  “We’ll just put it back in the general fund and police fund.”


Lacey made a motion to close the account, which was seconded by Norris and passed by a unanimous roll call vote.


“Can we back up one step to Imagination Library?” Browder then asked, and when Mayor Morris asked what it was the board spent some time discussing the program, which provides books to children at an early age to encourage them to read.


“Ms Blassingame, she said they needed more money,” Norris remarked.  “I don’t know why, but the reason this was going to be brought up is because Adamsville, not just McNairy County, but Adamsville is the lowest on the totem pole as far as participation in this program in the entire state.  And they need some help.  I was going to suggest, and I should have done, but closing out this drug fund?  When you put that back in the general fund I’d suggest that we earmark that for this Imagination fund, because they need the money.”


Browder was thinking along the same lines. “Well, of course, we already talked about $500 to that.  If we were going to do something with that kind— If we’re able, if we feel comfortable in doing something with that drug fund money, I would like to see it increase our Imagination Library contribution to a thousand, and the rest of that money go to the One to One program, at the school.  I don’t think, you know, that program just getting of the ground.  Commissioner Lacey had stated that the county’s not funding that this year, and I don’t think we realize, and won’t realize for a few years to come, how important that program is to our kids.  If we can do something as a town to help our children, I think we need to do that, and it appears to me that we’ve got the money to do that right now.”


Seaton asked whether there weren’t “rules about how that [drug fund] money can be spent,” and Burks confirmed that “it will go back into general fund the police department funds.”


Mayor Morris also asked for an explanation of the One to One program, which Browder had mentioned, and Browder provided it.


“Bottom line,” Thrasher said, “McNairy County school system One on One [sic] program.  We put a thousand in there.”


“Already?” Morris asked.


“Yeah,” Thrasher replied.


“And they’re asking for more?” Morris asked in apparent disbelief.


“Well, no,” Lacey said.  “I’m asking for more.  Selmer doubled theirs, because the county cut their funding.  I thought we do, double ours, to two thousand this year to help out also.  But both of these programs are the difference in a future generation or— Well, that, that, understands and knows, I mean, the Imagination Library, if kids don’t learn to read, what, we know the struggles, and then, are graduating high school now without the ability to properly use a computer, you’re one step behind, already.”


“Further than that,” Browder agreed, meaning further than one step behind.


Norris then moved that donations to both programs be doubled—Imagination Library from $500 to $1,000, and One to One from $1,000 to $2,000—and his motion was seconded by School Board Member and Chairman Frank Lacey, who also participated in the unanimous vote to provide those moneys to the school system.


“Barge Waggoner” was the next item on the agenda, and Mayor Morris called on Barge Waggoner’s representative, Shannon Cotter, for a report.


“I had called up here and talked with P.W. [Paul Wallace Plunk, of the utility department].  We try to keep our clients informed of what’s going on, and how costs are affecting various projects.  Y’all, where you’ve gotten elevated storage tank.  We have contacted some contractors about steel prices and delivery times, so we can kind of estimate where we’re going to be in y’all’s project.  [Unintelligible name] is estimating that construction costs for steel tanks only are probably 50% higher than what they were this time last year.  They estimated a 250,000 gallon elevated tank would be at four hundred thousand.  That’s not taking all the little extra things that you have to hook up to it, the water to it, and all that.  We’re just talking about steel members only.  So he’s estimating it could be, by bid time, $600,000.  Now, that’s one potential bidder.  That’s not saying what it’s going to be.  We don’t know.  I don’t want y’all to be blind-sided by any of this, when we do take bids.  And they’re also saying you’re looking at a minimum of 300 days delivery time on the steel for elevated tanks.  Which may work to your advantage, sitting here discussing your budget as it is.  Which means you may not have to complete all your funds this fiscal year.  You may not be able to disburse them [unintelligible word or two] next year.  I wanted to come just to inform you of where you are in the project.  The plans and specifications are ready.  We’re waiting on y’all to get your contract.  Jimmie Ann, I don’t think you’ve received that yet, have you?  As soon as you get that, I believe your environmental has been submitted by the development district and has cleared that portion of it, once you get the contract.  We’ve requested the wage rate.  The designer portion will be submitted on your behalf to the state, so y’all can get permission to advertise the contract for execution.  That’s for your information, just to keep you informed, and I’ll be glad to answer any questions you might have.”


“Well, can I ask you one thing?” Morris asked, mounting a familiar hobby-horse.  “You know, you’re saying about an elevated tank.  Ain’t a ground-level tank cheaper?”


“I’ll discuss that with engineering and get you an answer on that, Mayor Morris,” Cotter replied.  “I’m not qualified to answer that.”


“I know the maintenance on it would be a lot cheaper,” Morris continued.


“I will ask that question—” Cotter began.


“But what we’re after now is storage, anyway,” Morris said.


“We have in there [i.e., in the report] you need 250,000.  That gets you to what the state is going to require, with a little bit of wiggle room for growth.  Not a whole lot of wiggle room for growth, but a small amount for growth.”


“But if we’re going to go, don’t get the little wiggle,” Morris said.  “Put a big one in there.  You know, get you a big-sized tank, and you’re through with it for a while.”


“I will ask that question and let you know tomorrow morning,” Cotter replied.


The next item on the agenda was the appointment of a member to the board of zoning appeals.


Thrasher explained that “Mr. Gene Ruth has moved out of town, was serving on the board of zoning appeals.  We need to take somebody to take his place.  I contacted a few names, just because they were handy.  Gary Henline says he would serve.  Roger McClain said he would serve.  And Commissioner Garrison contacted me and said that she would serve.  That’s all the names I’ve got.”


Morris questioned whether a commissioner could serve on that board, and Thrasher replied that “We’ve never had one, and I’ve got a call through to MTAS.  I think that the board does not serve on that because this is the final say-so, the board of zoning appeals, and I don’t think they wanted to get politics involved.”


After a brief discussion Lacey nominated Roger McClain, and the motion, seconded by Browder, passed by a unanimous voice vote.


The next item was the appointment of a member to the industrial development board.


Thrasher explained that “Mrs. Garrison has offered to serve, Tommy Ross has agreed to serve, Roger McClain—no, y’all have—Roger McClain has said he’ll serve, and Gary Henline will serve.  So you’ve got—”


Referring to Commissioner Garrison’s capacity to serve, Morris said,  “I still don’t believe that, on the industrial board, that, that—”


He was abruptly interrupted by Lacey, who said, “I make a motion Tommy Ross.”


Browder questioned whether the commission actually appointed a member or merely submitted names for consideration. 


“These names,” Thrasher replied, “you need to really send more than one name, because the way it’s structured we’re to send three names, and the county commission names the appointee.  Y’all just suggest.  They’re not on the board until the county commission votes them.  So you might pick you out two or three of these names.”


“I’ll make a motion Tommy Ross and Gary Henline’s names be sent,” Lacey said, and Browder seconded his motion.  Oddly, Mayor Morris move immediately to the next agenda item and no vote was taken on the motion.


That next item was the paving of Hughes Street, which may just have made its farewell appearance on the Adamsville City Commission agenda.


“This thing keeps coming up,” Thrasher began, “about blacktopping Hughes Street.  And the last, well not last, several minutes [sic—means to say “meeting”] ago, this city commission voted to split the cost of blacktopping Hughes Street if the school board or county would give us a five-year lease on the property.  And that’s basically what we’ve tried to word in there.  And according to Charlie Miskelly—  Frank, would you be the one to sign that, or does he sign it, or how would that work?  You’re chairman of the— “


“Probably me, I guess,” Lacey responded.


“I’ve got problems with that,” Mayor Morris interjected.  “Y’all already know it.  We are in a push, or bind, to blacktop the roads out on our streets.  Some of them are in bad shape.  Blacktop’s go to sixty, eighty dollars a ton, and if you do that for the county out there, and— It’s just going to make it a lot faster job.  People go through there faster.  Right now, they’ll go slower, because it’s not like a highway.  But we need it on our streets.  I don’t know what you’re talking about now, in price, now.  The last price we got, I figure, was what, twelve or fifteen thousand?”


“Somewhere in that neighborhood,” Thrasher agreed.


“All right,” Morris continued.  “It’s went up since then.  So, you’re looking at a lot of money.  And the school board gets twenty-five million dollars, right at it.  Am I right, Frank?”


“Twenty-two,” Lace replied.


“Twenty-two,” Morris repeated.  “And we try to work off a budget of five, five-and-a-half million, and it’s—”


“Which is about what we get from the county,” Lacey interjected.


“What, five-and-a-half million?” Morris asked.  “Somebody out here, you know, are people that ride these streets, they’re going to have to do without, if we do that.  Y’all need to check in on that asphalt.  It is high, now, and it don’t go very far.  That’s all I’m going to say about it.”


“Refreshing my memory a little,” Browder observed, “it’s been several months ago when we dealt with this the last time, we were the one that approached the school board with this idea, were we not?  My personal opinion is, since we were the one that approached the school board, and the school board has come back affirmative, I think we need to live up to our original agreement.”


“Well, you got a good idea there,” Morris agreed, “but, you know, asphalt was a third, back then, what it is now.  If they had waited another year, it would have been triple.  But I’m just telling you somebody, some roads, some places, might even be in front of your house, Jeff, are going to have to be not patched, if we do this.”


“I understand that,” Browder replied.  “That road’s traveled, that all I can say.”


“Yeah,” Morris responded, “but it’s not supposed to be traveled fast.”


“Well,” Norris said, joining the discussion, “that’s the reason you should have your police there, patrolling.  And I think any streets that are involved in the transportation of your children to and from school are of utmost importance.”


“We do that, other streets,” Morris began, and then he dropped it.  “But— Let’s vote on it.  Get it over with.  Do I hear a motion?”


Browder made the motion, which was seconded by Norris.  In the vote that followed, Browder and Norris voted yes, Morris voted no, and Lacey, who had minutes earlier seen no conflict in advocating, seconding, and voting for the expenditure of Adamsville moneys on the McNairy County schools, abstained.


Morris, taking the position that the motion had failed, moved immediately to the next agenda item, “Sale of City Stuff - Garan Building (7-26-08).”


“All the equipment that was left in there by L&A Sales,” Thrasher explained, “was sold to two men.  These two men want to have a one-time auction sale at the building, and they’re going to clean all of that out, bring in some other merchandise.  It will be a one day, Saturday thing only.  I think they’ve been in contact with Mr. Lacey about selling any of the bank furnishings that he hasn’t already sold.  And they told the city it won’t cost us anything to sell any of the stuff we want to put in there.  Old scrap lawnmowers, just anything that we’ve got that we can haul down there and line up in front of the building.  They’re going to charge a buyer’s premium, and that’ll pay them their fee, and we get what the merchandise brings.  So I just want to know if y’all want to—”


Browder interrupted Thrasher and harkened back to the just-complete vote. “I was just confused.  We had two vote yes, one no vote, and one didn’t vote.  Is a not, is an abstention from voting the same as a no vote?”


“Law of the majority,” Morris proclaimed, unhelpfully.


Seaton observed that two votes was a majority, but Morris insisted otherwise.  “Not when you got a commissioner [Garrison] not here.  And he [Lacey] abstained.”


“I didn’t know it was an issue,” Seaton said, “but two to one’s a majority.  I don’t understand where you’re coming from, Mayor.”


“Two— they’s four people here,” Morris said, arguing that two votes does not constitute a “majority” of four votes. “You got two votes for—”


“An abstain is not a no vote,” Seaton explained.


“Well, what is it?” Morris demanded.


Seaton replied, “It’s a ‘not vote.’  Abstain—”


“An abstain is a no vote,” Morris insisted.


“No, it’s not—” Seaton began.


“What’s ‘pass’?” the mayor asked, switching tacks.


“What?” a bewildered Seaton responded.


“Is ‘pass’ a no vote?” Morris asked


“Pass is not a vote,” Seaton replied.


 “Pass is a no vote,” Morris insisted.


“Not in my opinion,” Seaton said.


“Well—” Morris began, chuckling.


Seaton tried again.  “Frank feels like he needs to abstain because of his relationship with the school board, and I agree with him—”


“I agree with him, too,” Morris agreed.


“—but,” Seaton continued, “we had two votes in favor of the motion and one vote against the motion, and the motion passed.”


Morris continued to insist that two votes did not constitute a majority of the four people present.


“If Frank would have voted no,” a weary Seaton explained again, “it would have been a tie vote.”


“Well,” Morris said, dismissively, “y’all do what you want to.  You’re going to anyway.”


“So it passed?” asked the Independent-Appeal’s Tom Evans, from the audience.  “Are we paving the street?”


“We’re paving the street,” Norris replied.


“But,” Morris added, returning to his argument that paving Hughes Street meant neglecting others, “no, some of the streets out in the town, we’re not.”


Before that dead horse was finally laid to rest, Mayor Morris recognized Willie Jones in the audience, who asked “why don’t you put some speed bumps” on Hughes Street to reduce the speeding.  Morris replied that, “legally, you can’t put speed bumps on a road that’s a through road.”  In the brief crosstalk that followed City Attorney Seaton, referring to the mayor’s just-uttered legal opinion, said, “I don’t know if that’s right or not.”



Dismissal Fracas


“Next business,” Morris then intoned, returning to what was in fact the first item of New Business on the printed agenda. “’Dismissal - Terry Thrasher. Morris.’  It’s come to a boiling point, that I cannot work with Terry any more.  This has been going on for six and a half years, and no matter what I bring up, he’s against, or he gets mad if I bring it up.  And it goes back to not informing me about meetings, and when I come up here to the city hall to talk to him, sometimes I’ll be talking to him, he’ll just leave.  And I’ll say, ‘Don’t leave.’  So this has been going on six and a half years, and when it come down to this last deal with y’all sending the charter up to Jackson, up to Memphis, without my signature on it, and me not knowing the first thing about it.  He didn’t tell me.  He didn’t even tell me it was up there, until I found out about it in Nashville.  And y’all want to know who had it stopped?  I stopped it.  I got some friends up there.  But this is the only thing.  It’s just constantly back-stabbing me continuously with him.  You can go in there to talk to him, and I’ve told him to shut off his cell phone.  Well, about the time I get in there the telephone will ring, and I’ll tell him to shut it off.  Well, he’ll get mad about that.  I’ve told him to shut off his buzzer, and he’ll jump up and run out.  Well, come to find out, most times there ain’t nothing he went to.  He just didn’t want to talk to me.  And then, on this last deal of hiring— And I could go on and on and on about the things that we discussed, or haven’t discussed because he’ll just take off and leave.  And this last deal of hiring somebody for the office up here, that is not this commission’s, to hire just regular people.  Your job is to hire the people like Terry, heads of the departments.  But I went in there, and I had told them to pick out the top— I picked out the top ten, of the applications, and I said, ‘Now y’all go through this top ten and give me three.’  Well, that’s what they done.  So I picked out, Pam Young was in it.  I picked out Pam Young, because her qualification is just as good as anybody else’s.  And as far as her work schedule, she ain’t had but four jobs in her life, so I’d say she’s stayed with a job.  But he says, ‘I’m not going to hire her.’  I says, ‘Why?’  ‘They don’t want me to.’  I said, “Well, who’s they?’  ‘They.’  I said, ‘Who is they?’  He said, ‘The commissioners.’  Well, before I came to talk to him, on a Friday night—or Friday evening.  Or Thursday.  I talk to Frank.  Frank said, ‘Tommy, you need to hire somebody.’  I said, ‘All right.’  I talked to Teddy.  He said, ‘You need to hire somebody.’   I said, ‘I’ll let—[pause, while the tape is changed]  So I said, ‘I’ll let you know Friday morning.’  Didn’t I tell you this?  So, when I— I mean Monday morning.  And I come in here Monday and I said, “I want Pam Young hired.’  And I had talked with Debbie.  Debbie said she could work with her well.  And I told him to hire her.  Well, Tuesday I come in here and found out that I wasn’t even invited to the budget commission meeting.  And I said, ‘Terry, did you call’— You can shake your head all you want to.  I said ‘Terry, did you call Pam?’  He said, ‘No.  Not going to hire her.  They don’t want me to.  They don’t want me to.’  And that’s when I says, ‘Okay.’  I said— He said—  And when I asked him, I said, ‘What about not telling me about the planning, I mean the budget, Terry?’  ‘Well, you ought to know about it.  It was in the minutes.’  I said, ‘Terry, I’ve got other things to do besides looking after your job all the time.’  So, I says, ‘As far as I’m concerned, you’re fired.’  And as far as I’m concerned he’s still fired.  I don’t know who’s told him to come back.  I guess y’all did.  But everything I do up here, see, y’all up-surping [sic: usurping] me.


“Now Frank, his own self, told me to hire somebody,” Morris said, finally bringing his monologue of more than four minutes to a close.  “Didn’t you?”


“Yes,” Lacey acknowledged.  “And Pam wasn’t in the three.”  [“Pam” being the mayor’s niece by marriage, Pam Young.]


“She was in the top three.”


“No, she wasn’t,” Lacey replied.  “No, sir.  She was not in the top three, and we even discussed the fact that we need to hire someone that had the resume, without prejudice, and when you told—when I told you that on Friday, ‘You need to hire somebody,” I believe I said, that’s qualified to do the job by the qualifications that we had mentioned, and I assumed you was going to make the best decision.  Now, I didn’t know which ones you would consider, but there were three resumes there.  One of them turned the job down.  One of them lives in Savannah and you didn’t want to hire her.  And the other, that left the other girl, and then you brought in this other one, and—”


“No,” Morris interrupted, “Pam was always in the top ten, because she—”


“She might have been in the top ten—” Lacey began.


“She wasn’t in our top three,” Thrasher interjected.


“She was in the top ten,” Morris repeated.


“She might have been in the top ten,” Lacey acknowledged.  “I’m not saying she wasn’t in the top ten.”


“She wasn’t in our top three,” Thrasher repeated.


“Not in the top three you showed me, Tommy,” Lacey said again.


“Frank, you know better than that,” Morris said in a sorrowful tone.


“Yes, sir,” Lacey responded defiantly, “I do know better than that.  I know exactly, I know exactly what was there.’


“You know better,” Morris repeated.


“Ken,” Norris asked, “whose responsibility is it to hire the person—”


“Plain people,” Morris interjected, meaning regular city employees, and not department heads.


“—that is going to replace Jimmie Ann?” Norris continued.  “Whose responsibility is it?”


“I thought there was a committee set up,” Seaton replied.


“There was—” Lacey began, only to be drowned out by several seconds of crosstalk.


“My understanding,” Seaton continued when the noise settled down, “the department heads hire people in their department.  And this, I suppose, I feel like that this is a little difficult, because when any job is created, I think maybe there was a plan to do some follow up, and—  Anyway, I guess I think that Terry’s the department head, and he has the authority to, without any other action by the commission, to make a decision about people hired in his department.”


“Or the mayor,” Norris added, meaning that department heads could hire “without any other action by” the mayor, as well as by the commission.


“Well,” Morris asked, plaintively, “what’s the mayor here for?”


“There should be no intervention by the commission, or the mayor,” Norris observed, “and they should, the supervisors should be allowed to hire who they need to hire, they feel they need to hire, because that’s who the commission is looking to to get the job done.  Not Jimmie Ann, but the supervisor.  We would deal with the supervisor, if the job was not getting done.  If you don’t do that you start micromanaging the whole thing, so—”


“That’s what y’all are trying to do,” Morris insisted.


Browder said, “I think the mayor has all the free will in the world to suggest, just like I think any one of the commissioners would have, in a department head position, and, I know we’ve talked about this before.  Like I say, I think it’s the department head’s job to hire the people under him, but I still think, you know, the mayor or any one of us could make suggestions to that department head.  I don’t think, you know, that we’re barred from doing that.”


“Sure,” Norris agreed.


“Only time y’all got any power is at the meeting,” Mayor Morris insisted.  “When this meeting’s over, y’all’s authority has quit.  I have to deal with these people every day.  And I deal, at least twenty, twenty-five hours a week, with these people.  This is what I’m trying to get over.  If I cannot pick out who I think—and I’ve hired a many a people, many people in my career.  If I can’t pick out who I think is best for the job, then y’all come up and say, ‘We don’t want them.’  I just don’t think that that’s in the charter, now.”


“I don’t know what Terry told you,” Browder said, returning to the specific hiring question.  “I don’t remember ever having said I didn’t want any one particular person.  The only thing that I’ve heard anyone say at any time was, ‘Terry’s the department head.  Hire whoever you feel you need to put in the position.’  Now, if somebody else has heard something other than that, I wish you’d speak up now.”


“Let me just tell you one thing on that,” Morris said.  “I have hired everyone that’s been hired up here.  They come to me and say, ‘Can we hire them?’  But when it come to this one, they went to y’all.  Which up-surps [sic] my power every which a way.”


“Who have we hired?” Thrasher asked.


Morris ignored the question.  “ Bill [Police Chief Bill McCall] always comes to me. Paul Wallace comes to me.  Well, when did it change?  Just because—”

 

“Did you hire,” Lacey interrupted, “did you offer to hire the most qualified for the job?”


“According to the applications,” Morris replied.


“Okay, then, no, you didn’t,” Lacey said.  “Because, I mean, we had them, we had them, you ever were there when we did them.  And, no, we didn’t.”


“What do you mean, we?” Morris asked.  “I wasn’t there.”

“You were sitting right there—” Lacey said, indicating a chair, “or right here, and I was sitting there—”


“You added one to it,” Morris said, changing the subject.  “I showed you ten people, and you added one to it.”


“But the top three were the top three,” Lacey insisted.  “And the first girl turned it down, because the money wasn’t right.  The second girl, who everybody wanted to hire anyway, was from Savannah.  And we didn’t want to do that because you didn’t want anybody hired from out of town.”


“When you’ve got qualified people here,” Morris said, agreeing with Lacey’s last sentence.


“Now, it doesn’t matter to me,” Lacey continued.  “I don’t want to be responsible for the person.  Because if we hire her, and if you hire her, then he has no authority over her.  That leaves you with the authority over her.  And if she gets mad at him, she’s going to come to you.”


“She don’t come, she don’t got a job,” Morris said, the meaning of which may have been clear to him, if not to anyone else.


“I don’t know that we’ll ever get anybody to work for the city if we’re going to play these kind of games,” Lacey said, “and I don’t know that we could get any of the ones that wanted to work—”


Pam Young interrupted from the audience.  “Can I say something, please?”


“Sure,” Uncle Tommy said.


“Somebody at this table is lying,” Young asserted, “because I had a commissioner call me, that I’m not going to name, that told me that I was in the top three.  Terry, I’ve interviewed with Terry, he never even told me what the job, what the qualifications were for the job.”


“Well,” Lacey began, “we, and we failed there, because they were supposed to be listed in the paper, too.  And that’s why we got seventy-five applications.  And we, and we also, I think, we, and we also acknowledge we did not list the qualifications, but we didn’t list the pay range, which brings up the problem that, you know— We’re trying to move this city into the 21st century, with technology and everything else, and that was one of the main requirements, was being able to do that, and knowing certain operating systems and things, and that’s how the criteria was supposed to have been set out.  But it wasn’t set out that way, in our, in the ad that was in the paper, and we even fussed about that—”


Young interrupted: “What are the systems you’re talking about?”


“—fussed about the ad,” Lacey concluded.


“There were no qualifications put in the paper,” Norris observed.


“What are they?” Young asked.  Lacey fussed with some papers and did not reply.  “He didn’t even ask me what my qualifications—” Young resumed, only to be interrupted by Uncle Tommy, who had his own fish to fry.


“Let’s get back to my part on Terry, first, then I’ll let her say something.  But I have, just like I say, I have tried and tried to work with Terry.  Now, I know that y’all are the ones to say yes or no.  But I’m asking you to dismiss him. Because I will not work with him.  You’ll have to hire somebody else to go between me and him.  And you take a man that’s, with the perks and everything, making $50,000 a year.  And all he does most of the time is go after the mail, and stuff like that.  And then won’t do what I ask him to do.  Won’t even try to work with me.  Now, y’all do what you want.  I’m throwing it in your hands.”


“Do we need to take a vote on it?” Norris asked


“I, I, I don’t, I don’t understand,” Lacey said.  “What are you throwing in our hands?”


“What do you want us to do?” Norris asked the mayor.


“Frank,” Morris began with some hesitation, “I wanted to keep you out of this—”


“I just want to know what you’re throwing in our hands,” Lacey asked, quickly.


“—I wanted to—” Morris continued, before interrupting himself to respond to Lacey’s last question, “Yeah, I’m throwing it in y’all’s hands.  But I just wanted you know I’m a fixing to say what you told me.  Now, you can deny it or say it, but you told me that you had the votes, after December, to dismiss him.  But you didn’t have— And I said, ‘Well, why don’t you do it now?’  But you wanted to wait until after the elections.  Now you know you told me that.”


“I didn’t say wait until after the election, did I?” Lacey asked


“Well,” Morris replied, “you said December the 2nd.”


“We wanted, we want to, we want to,” Lacey spluttered, before deciding on what tack to pursue, “I said we want to handle things the right way, and get them done the right way.”


“I knew what you—” Morris began.


“Did I not say that?” Lacey insisted.


“I knew where you were—” Morris began again.


“And did I not ask you to back off,” Lacey interrupted again, “and stop trying to bully us into what you’re wanting done, because you didn’t know—”


“You didn’t say nothing about bullying,” Morris replied, having been successfully diverted from the crucial issue.


“Do you feel like that’s what you’re doing to us?” Lacey asked, moving the discussion away from Lacey’s undenied suggestion that Thrasher’s dismissal be put off until December.


“No, I’m not trying to bully,” Morris insisted.  “I’m giving it to you.  You can—”


“What are you asking us to do?” Lacey interrupted.


“I’m asking you to dismiss him,” Morris replied.  “I’m not working with him.  It’s went on for six and a half years, and that’s just it.”


“Sometimes we have to look and see where the real problem is,” Lacey said, “and I, and for the life of me, there are a lot of people I’d rather not work with over my career, but I didn’t have the choice not to work with them, so I made it work.  And it looks like to me we’re in that position right now.  You don’t like him; I don’t know if he likes you or not.  Y’all have got to figure it out, because we’ve got a city to run, and we’ve got business to take care of.  And we need somebody in there to replace Jimmie Ann, and we’ve got to get these things done and we’ve got to quit playing personal politics.”


“Yes, sir,” Browder said, from the choir.


“Why don’t you talk to all these others, then?” Morris asked Lacey.  “Everything I’ve brought up, they’ve voted against it.  But I’m just saying, let’s get it over with.  Either keep him or don’t keep him, but you better hire somebody else, because I am not— I’ve done started by-passing him, anyway.  I go to Paul Wallace.  I’ve did that for a month, now.  I don’t want to argue with him.  I’m getting too old for all of it, and I’m not, I’m just not going to do it.  And I’ve got another year and four months to go on this mayor’s deal.  So y’all can make up your own minds.”


After several seconds of silence, Lacey said, abruptly, “I move we adjourn.”


“I move for you to make a choice,” Morris countered.  “Do you not got the guts to make a choice?”


“I think by adjourning, we do make our choice,” Lacey replied.


“I don’t,” Morris said.  “I want a voice vote.  And I’m— That’s one thing you can’t take away from me—”


“There’s a motion on the table,” Lacey interrupted.  “It requires a second.”


“I make a motion that we fire him,” Morris said.  “That’s my motion.”


“You can’t make a motion when I’ve already got a motion,” Lacey said.


“Yeah,” Morris responded, “you wasn’t supposed to do it.”


“You can move to adjourn any time,” Lacey responded, primly.


“Well,” Morris said, turning his attention to the audience, “I wanted y’all people to see what kind of commissioners you got.  They ain’t got no balls.  The meeting’s adjourned.”


Several voices pointed out that there was no second to the motion to adjourn, then Willie Jones from the audience said to the mayor, “There’s no need for using that kind of language in this meeting.”


Several other voices chimed in in support of that sentiment.


“You’ve got ladies present, right here,” Jones continued, quaintly.


“Figure of speech, Willie,” Morris said.  “Figure of sweet— uh, speech.”


“Use it on the outside of the door,” Jones said.  “Out yonder.  Don’t use it in here.”


“Well,” Morris responded, “you don’t tell me what to do.”


“Well, I’m just suggesting you do it, then,” Jones said.


“All right.” Morris replied.  “You suggest it, but you don’t tell me.”


Morris then asked, “Do I hear a second?”


“To what motion?” Browder asked, with understandable uncertainty.


“He wants to adjourn,” Morris said, indicating Lacey.


“I withdraw my motion,” Lacey said, throwing Morris off his stride.


“What?” Morris asked.


“I withdraw my motion,” Lacey repeated.  “Make whatever motion you want to, Tommy.”


“Well,” Morris said, “I make a motion that we dismiss Terry.  You know, I think it would be good for the whole [unintelligible word].  He goes to y’all, he goes to me, he goes to y’all.  He uses both sides against the middle.  And I’m tired of it.  I’ve done it for six and a half years.  But it’s left up to y’all.”


“Well,” Norris asked, “if Terry doesn’t resign, does that mean you’re going to continue to be mayor?”


“Am I going to continue to be mayor?” Morris asked with surprise.


Norris responded affirmatively.


“If he doesn’t?” Morris asked.


“Right,” Norris replied.  “Have you considered resigning?”


“Never,” Morris replied, firmly.  “Have you?”


“Well,” Norris said, “I really wish you would.”


“I wish you would, too,” Morris responded.


“Mayor?” Jerry Burks said from the audience, interrupting this snappy repartee.  “May I address the commission?”


Several voices from the commission replied affirmatively.


“You, all of you know where I came from, said Burks, who is married to the Jimmie Ann Burks.  “Paul Wallace came from an organization.  Willie Jones was there.  We have, we have— I have never in my life sat through a board meeting to come up with anything like this, that y’all are putting on.  There was organization in that organization.  They went to a board meeting, they did their business, they adjourned and went home.  They had nothing to do with the hiring of the employees, nothing whatsoever.  They didn’t even want to.  They hired a general manager, and that’s it.  And I think that you people would do good to—” 


When Burks trailed off, and there were no further comments from the audience, Morris asked, “Well, are y’all going to make a motion or what?” 


“You have a motion on the floor,” Lacey replied, “and it hasn’t had a second.”


“Well,” Morris said, “if it hasn’t got a second, somebody else make one, then.”


Lacey complied, saying, “I move we adjourn.”


That was not what Morris had in mind. “I still say, I want an up-or-down vote.”


“But you don’t have a second,” Lacey pointed out.  “If you don’t have a second, there is no vote.”


As Lacey was speaking, Morris said to Seaton, “What about that then?  Can I ask for a roll call vote?”


Lacey continued, saying “You don’t bring a motion to the table if you don’t have a second.”


“You make the decision,” Morris told Seaton.


“My decision is,” Seaton responded, “you made a motion and it died for a lack of a second.  Frank’s made a motion to adjourn, and he can’t get a second, so we sit here until someone comes up with a solution, I guess. [Pause.]  Which, my recommendation would be, someone second Frank’s motion that we adjourn.  And everybody have an opportunity to maybe think about these problems and come back up here next time and use, a new try to move forward and doing things like it needs to be done.  Now the mayor is upset about some things, and I understand why.  The mayor has overreacted.  And the mayor has every right to make his motion, but we’ve got to move forwards, just like Frank said.  And we’ve got to move forward.  And at the least you need people to find a way to work together and get past these personal differences.  Everybody’s got to work on themselves, and doing better.  I know Terry will do better, and I know Terry and you, Mayor, need to be able to communicate.  That’s why, that’s the whole point of this June 16th meeting, or June 30th, whatever it was.  Y’all can’t communicate with one another.  And that needs to change.”


Morris then addressed Thrasher directly.  “You know, you need to get a different attitude.  I’m the mayor.  I was voted by the people.  He was put in here by people, the commissioners, to work.  He should listen to me some.”


“And he does,” Seaton said.  “He does.  But he’s got a job to do—”


“Very little,” Morris said.


“I just wonder, though, you know,” Lacey began.  “If you didn’t have a second for your motion, why would you bring it up in a meeting, other than to further humiliate this board and the city, and drag our name through the mud even further, and prevent us from doing good in the city like we should be doing, as opposed to continuing to harp on the same things that, obviously, there’s a problem, but we don’t do anything good to make the problem better.  All we do is deepen the gap.  And I don’t have a problem at all with voting on your motion, but I wouldn’t have brought the motion here if I didn’t have a second.  Because all that’s doing is being divisive, and that’s what you’ve done tonight.  You’ve done a very good job of dividing yourself from everyone else, and I—”


“You know we’ve already been divided—” Morris began.


“No, no, no you haven’t,” Lacey interrupted.  “No you haven’t, Mayor.  No you haven’t.  I think there’s been, I know Jeff has, and I know I have.  I mean, you know, there’s been people that have supported you throughout—”


“Why don’t you look at me when you talk?” Morris asked.


“I’m reading,” Lacey responded.


“Are you afraid to look at me?” Morris asked, ignoring Lacey’s response.


“Tommy,” Lacey responded wearily, “I’m not afraid to look at you at all.  I’m sitting here, I’m, I’m—”


“Why don’t you look at me?” Morris persisted.  “You’re talking about me, why don’t you look at me?”


“Why are you doing this to us?” Lacey asked, flatly.


 “I’m wanting to get some action,” Morris replied, belligerently.


“Do you have a second?” Lacey asked, impatiently.  “If you don’t have a second, how are you going to get action?  What kind of action do you want?—”


“I’m waiting on y’all,” Morris replied.


“—Are you wanting the newspapers to act?” Lacey continued.  “Are you wanting the community to act?”


“Y’all are,” Morris replied.  “Y’all seem to be wanting the newspapers to act.”


“No, Tommy,” Lacey responded, “we simply want to run this city for the best of these citizens, and you’ve done a great job in helping us keep cost down, in helping us realign some things, but this is completely— It completely destroys everything you worked up to until now.  Because you’re wanting to make sure that everybody knows you’re the mayor, and by golly you have a right to do something.  You do have a right, but it takes a second.  If I want to do something, it takes a second.  I wanted to adjourn; I couldn’t get my second.  We have to work together, and if we can’t work together, which this shows we can’t work together, then we have a serious problem.”


“Well, I’m just telling you,” Morris said, with unabated defiance, “y’all done made your decision, but I’m just telling you: hire somebody to work between me and him.”


“Well, we’re not going to do that,” Norris said.


“Well,” Morris responded, “I ain’t talking to him.”


Norris then said, jokingly, “Well, just I wouldn’t talk to him either, Mayor.  I wouldn’t talk to him either.  I just wouldn’t talk to him.”


“Some people don’t know how he is,” Morris complained.


“We know how you are, though,” said an unidentified man in the audience.


“Huh?” Morris responded.


“We know how you are,” the man repeated.


“I know how you are, too,” Morris replied.


“You don’t even know me,” the man said, dismissively.


“Yeah, I do, too,” Morris insisted.


“But I’ll tell you what I believe,” Morris said, “It may be right, it may be wrong, but you’ll know where I stand when I open my mouth.  It ain’t like some people, that’ll cut you in the back ever, every way you go.  But let’s get the meeting over with.  I just told you what I mean.”


“Well, I think we really need to assess the situation here,” Browder said, referring to hiring a replacement for Burks.  “If we wait another meeting goes by before we hire anyone, whoever that person is, is going to be in a critical bind, are they not?”


“That’s already been taken care of,” Thrasher said, softly.  “That part has.”


“Okay,” Browder said.


“What’s already been taken care of?” Morris asked, suspiciously.


“All we’re looking at is—” Browder began, as the mayor and others begin to speak.


We’ve already got somebody lined up starting in this position,” Thrasher responded.


“I’m not going to do it again,” Lacey said, referring to making a motion to adjourn.


“I move we adjourn,” Browder said, taking the hint.


“Second,” Lacey said.  “I’m good at seconds.”


And the meeting ended there—fittingly, in light of the chaos and acrimony which had been on display over the previous two hours, without a vote being taken on the motion to adjourn.

  

Town Board Meeting

16 June 2008
 


For such a short agenda, Adamsville’s June town board meeting went on for a long time—nearly two hours.  But, once again, the level of acrimony and dissent remained low.


The minutes were unanimously approved on a motion by Jeff Browder, seconded by Frank Lacey, and the financial reports were approve without dissent on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Browder.


Lacey then asked Police Chief Bill McCall whether he thought installing a “photo cop” similar to the one recently installed in Selmer would be good for Adamsville.


“I think it would be a good resource,” McCall replied, not only to catch speeder, but also because Adamsville has three “blind corners,” referring to the intersection of highways 64 and 22/117 in downtown Adamsville.  “We’ve just been blessed that there ain’t been a tragedy there.”  McCall said that the town could get a survey done at no charge to assess the feasibility of the system, and that if the town met certain criteria the system would not cost the town anything and in fact would actually bring in money.


The board then discussed the enforcement of speed limits within the Adamsville town limits, the upshot of which was that Adamsville police will reduce the leeway they have been giving speeders and will start issuing more tickets.  “Forty-five is the magic number,” McCall said, “but it’s fixing to drop.”


* * *


Dwana Garrison then asked McCall to tell the board about an unexpected gift to the town of Adamsville from a retired lieutenant colonel who had attended the recent Buford Pusser Festival.  McCall’s attempts to do so were repeatedly interrupted by Garrison, who appeared to be more interested in basking in her late father’s “glory” than in acknowledging the generosity of one of her late father’s fans.


McCall explained that, “at the festival I did a memorial to the trooper that lost his life, the only one in the state we had that lost his life, and if it had not been for his in-car video recorder they would have never know who killed that trooper.  And I said it’s a vital, vital instrument” that all police cruisers should be equipped with.  The next week he got a phone call “from this lady from Washington state, who was at the festival, who I would not know if she walked in this door tonight.  A lieutenant Army colonel, retired, I believe.  ‘What could I do to help you?  What would be your greatest need, if I could help you with something?’  I said, ‘We need those in-car recorders.’  She said, ‘I heard you.  I heard your speech, I heard what you said, and I’m going to help you get some.’  She didn’t say how many or what.”


Last week, McCall said, he got a “check in the mail for $7,000 from this retired lieutenant colonel, earmarked to buy in-car recorders for the police department….  I got a hold of Decatur Electronics, and I figured they’d cost about $3,500 apiece, and I talked to our representative in Tennessee, told him how it came about that we were getting these from them, or, I say we usually buy our electronics from them.  So he gets on the phone and he calls his boss, and Decatur Electronics donates us one.  And then, Decatur Electronics sells us three in-car camcorders, that’s sitting in my office right now, for $7,000, that normally are $3,500 apiece.  We got those for $2,333 dollars.  Plus they gave us one, I’ve had one in the office.  Every car on the force, now, will get, installed, a new in-car recorder.”


“And why, Bill?” Garrison prompted the chief to get to the really important part.


“Because of this lady,” McCall began, before breaking off to recount another incident of her generosity.  “Let me tell you what she did last year. I’m going to go ahead and tell it.  I’m going to tell it.  She offered to donate a drug dog, I didn’t know this [unintelligible word or two].  She offered to donate a drug dog and an officer to be trained with that dog to McNairy County, and somehow or another they didn’t return her call,” so she ended up donating the dog and officer training to a law enforcement agency in Washington state.


Brushing this aside, Garrison said “But what, I just wanted you to tell—”


“It was just because of this lady’s nice gesture—” McCall continued, persisting in his wrong-headed insistence on giving the donor some credit, only to be interrupted by Garrison with a loud, “No!”


“What did she do it in memory of?” she insisted, “why she did it in memory of?  She wanted to do it in honor of.  That’s what I want to get, so that the mayor, who’s been saying—”


McCall finally got the message.  “She said, ‘Don’t use my name.’  Just do it in honor of Sheriff Buford Pusser.”


“So, see!” Garrison said, triumphantly.  “Strangers that come into our town, and folks that spend money during that, and come into this festival, that some people don’t think that it’s really worth it, look what the whole community, besides getting to enjoy a good time, is getting.  Wouldn’t you agree, commissioners?  I mean.  I mean, I just think we need to write here a nice letter, and we need to do—”


“We’ve already mailed it,” McCall said.


“Because when somebody does something like that,” Garrison continued, “and they sure don’t have to do that, you know, and doing it for the reason she done it for, and she done that dog in honor of, too, and we have a copy of that, if y’all’d like, that article.” 


* * *


“All right,” Lacey said, when Garrison finished.  “I’d like you to go ahead and make that phone call, Bill, if the rest of the commissioners are okay with it, on the photo thing.” 


Turning to a completely unrelated topic, Lacey said, “My second question was, what’s the city’s responsibility, and what can you do, if you find, or we locate illegal aliens in this town?”


McCall explained that there was really nothing that local authorities could do, because the state of Tennessee has no law on the books for dealing with illegal aliens.  “The only authority to determine the alien status are federal officers under Title 8 of the United States Code 287.  We cannot arrest, we cannot detain an alien here, or an immigrant here, solely because they look like they don’t belong here.  That’s profiling.  That’s strictly against federal guidelines, state guidelines, Ken [town attorney Ken Seaton] will tell you that, all the way down to the end.  The only thing we could do is this: if they break our laws, like DUI, or like we did have one that we sent back.”  McCall said that the department had taken a criminal complaint about a man who turned out to be an illegal alien, and when they alerted the federal authorities the man was deported. “Three months later he shows back up in Tennessee, right back here at the same complex, with his wife, again.  We knew that he was an illegal alien, because they arrested him, come got him, and sent him back.  Then we just go arrest him, because we had knowledge of it and we knew it, and held him in detention, called them again.  But there again, they make the sole choice.  Nobody else can do it except you’ve been trained by them, and you’ve got to have a letter by the Secretary of Immigration and Custom Enforcement to give you the authority to do that.  It’s pretty tough.  In other words, like I said, it don’t look good for the home team, right now.  The state of Tennessee must adopt, Frank, to answer your question, the state of Tennessee has got to adopt some federal laws, like Arizona did.”  


“But,” Browder asked, “if they break a law, then—”


“If they break my state law,” McCall said, “we arrest them, yeah.  I can arrest them on that.  But I cannot arrest them for just being an alien here.  I can’t even stop them because they don’t look like they’re Americans.”


“If they break a law,” Lacey asked, “a Tennessee law, or an Adamsville law, and you arrest them, what do we do?”


“We arrest them,” McCall replied, “and we can do an alien status check on them through our NCIC computer, which goes to, down in Virginia.  And supposedly, he says that we can, the very best we can do, we get that officer on the street some information back, hopefully, within 20 to 30 minutes.  That’s a long time to detain somebody for that status.  But if it’s something out of the ordinary that we thought that really needed to be checked on, we do that.  If they came back, if there’s a problem with them, the only thing we can do is call them.  We don’t arrest them.  We can’t arrest them.  We don’t have the authority to arrest them.  It’s plainly stated: ‘the authority is determined in title 8 of the federal code 287,’ and only— let me see.  City, county, and even state troopers cannot arrest them.  On that charge of being an illegal alien.  We just can’t do it.”


“Well,” Mayor Tommy Morris interjected, wryly, “when they send them all back, somebody around here’s going to have to go to work.”


“That’s why they’re all coming here,” McCall said.  “We don’t have nothing against them here.  We don’t have nothing that says they can’t come here.  And that’s why they come here.  Tennessee.  Tennessee has no law against them.”


“We don’t notice near as many of them now as we did,” the mayor observed, before asking if anyone had anything to say about the parks and recreation report.


Garrison did. “I’d just like to say, hats off to all the city employees who worked so hard for our festival, for our entire community.  The state tells that there was about, from Wednesday to Saturday night, the state estimated there was about 10,000 that came through here, and it was the biggest one that we’ve had to date.  But what I want to thank the employees for— but also, any time Paul Wallace’s group, they jumped in, public works department, parks and rec department, police department, everybody pulled together to make this a wonderful festival.  And, you know, it couldn’t have been done without those, the help of everybody and the other volunteers throughout our community, that volunteered to do stuff, and I just want to say a very special thank you, and to know that they all worked so hard, wouldn’t you say, Debbie?  You couldn’t ask anybody to do something that didn’t just jump right in and help us.  And what’s that guy’s name?  Dr. Irvin?  Paul Wallace, he was a real, well, you know, an asset through it, and the museum and some other problems we’re having.  I just wanted to mention that, mayor, and how much appreciate it, and I hope the whole commission did, and what all they done to make our community look good.”


When she finished, Mayor Morris asked for a motion to accept all reports, which was provided by Lacey, seconded by Garrrison, and passed by a unanimous voice vote. 


* * *


In old business, after a long discussion the board unanimously approved the second reading of the sign ordinance (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Browder), and, more quickly, the second reading of the B-1 and B-2 residential ordinance (on a motion by Browder, seconded by Garrison).


The next agenda item was “Vision/Mission Statement,” a copy of which was included in each commissioner’s packet and read as follows, in its entirety:


VISION

To be the best small city in the mid-south in which to live, work, play in or visit.

MISSION

To offer the citizens of the area the finest services of gas, water, sewer, trash, police & fire protection & providing good recreational opportunities, while keeping taxes and rates as low as possible.


Town Administrator Terry Thrasher explained, “It’s the one y’all developed.  We looked at it.   Ya’ll were going to think about it over this, since the last meeting, and see if there was any changes you wanted to make.”


“I don’t like that,” Mike Norris said, “but I haven’t had time to think about it.”


“I didn’t know about it,” Mayor Morris remarked.  “Well, you want to table it until next meeting?”


“That’s what I prefer to do,” Norris said, and the other commissioners were in agreement.


The board also tabled the next item, “Engineering Service,” after Thrasher said “I really put that on there thinking we would have more feedback from the engineering companies that we sent the letters off to about water/sewer, but I’ve only had two answers.” 


* * *


The next agenda item, “Seaton Loop - Water,” engendered more discussion.  Utility Director Paul Wallace Plunk began by saying, “Y’all asked me at the last meeting to give you a cost for the Seaton Loop tie-together, and that cost, estimate cost $16,500.  That’s about 3,000 feet of line.”


Plunk said that he had received a petition with twelve signatures requesting that the line be put in.  In response from a question from Browder, Thrasher said that sixteen hookups per mile were required to make a project feasible, so the twelve signatures for just over half a mile (2,876 feet) was within than range.


“Let me ask you one thing on that,” Morris said.  “You say you’ve got a petition signed.  That’s just like signing a petition on a lot of other stuff.  Did they put up any money?”


“No,” Plunk replied, “but they would have to before.  They would have to pay a tap fee before anything was ever done.”


The board members then discussed the costs of such a project, as well as the possibility of putting in a gas line at the same time that the water line was installed.


“I make the motion, then,” Norris said at last, “that if we get the signed participants on the petition to, get a check for their taps, then we would proceed, you know, to put a water line in.  And also ask them about gas, at some time.”  His motion, seconded by Garrison, passed by a unanimous roll call vote. 


* * *


Morris then read “New Business,” only to be interrupted by Norris. “May I ask a question, before we go to that, on old business?  What is the status of the charter?”


Thrasher said that he hadn’t heard anything, whereupon Garrison said, “It did not pass in the senate.”


“Well,” Norris said, “I have two other things that I wanted to ask about.  One is, and I don’t know if this would come under old business or new, but it’s, we’ve been talking about this.  What is the situation with Jimmie Ann’s, what is the situation with applicants on Jimmie Ann’s position?”  Jimmie Ann Burk is retiring this year as town clerk.


“We’re down to three candidates,” Thrasher said, “and Frank looked through these, what day was that, one day last week, Thursday, and we’re going to make a decision, probably in the next two days.”


But, Garrison said, “last time I talked to you I thought you was going to bring it before the board, and then make a—  That didn’t work, or—?”


“I’m ready to make a recommendation to the board,” Thrasher said.


“Well, then,” Garrison asked, “why have we got to wait two more days?  I mean, I’m just asking.  I don’t know.”


“I really wanted to do a little more reference checking,” Thrasher said.


Norris joined the discussion, saying “I was of the opinion that we had someone within the city employment that was under serious consideration.”


“That fell apart,” Thrasher said.  “He backed out.”


“But,” Garrison persisted, “you, yeah, but I know when I talked to you a few days ago you said you basically had somebody you were ready to, I don’t know who it is, you were going to bring it to the—”


“I’m ready to bring,” Thrasher began, “like I say, I would have liked, I would like to check a few more references, but I’ve checked enough of her records—”


“He’s to bring it to me,” Morris interjected, “and then I’m going to bring it to y’all.”


“Oh,” Garrison said.  “Okay.  That was just what I was last told by him.  I’m sorry.” 


* * *


“Is that all?” the mayor asked Norris, setting off a quarter-hour discussion of a recurrent agenda item.  (The good news is that at the end of that quarter hour the matter appeared finally to have been put to rest.)


“One other question,” Norris replied.  “The property down here on 64.  We agreed on a price, and we agreed to put a for-sale sign up.  And I’ve not seen a for-sale sign yet, that’s been two months ago.  What’s the problem?”


“Teddy Hughes is supposed to be making us a sign,” Thrasher said, before apologizing for having let the matter slip. 


In the audience were Carolyn and Albert Bazzell, and Carolyn Bazzell demanded to know why the board had been willing to sell the property to another person for $8,000 but would not sell it to here and her husband for $10,000 when they offered that amount. “So why am I not as good as she is,” Bazzell asked.  “That’s what my question is, is how I have been here since 1965, I have never failed to pay my bills, and I have always tried to be a good citizen.”


“And I think you have,” Garrison said, smarmily.  “And I was in favor, since she didn’t get it, to automatically go right next to you, so I would like for the commission to address this, here.”  She does her usual self-righteous routine.


Bazzell was not through, though, and she and her husband, Albert, regaled the board with extensive complaints about the obstacles various town employees had thrown up to their efforts to expand their business.  For a long and painful period the board room was utter bedlam, with board members carrying on conversations with each other while Carolyn Bazzell droned incessantly onward at the top of her voice, apparently oblivious to the fact that no one was paying any attention to her except for Garrison, who punctuated Bazzell’s disquisition with occasional self-congratulatory interjections.


After an interminable period, Bazzell said, “I’m still willing to give the ten, that I offered.  I’m still willing to do that,” and Mayor Morris asked, “Can we sell it to her?” before the bedlam resumed.


Finally, Morris said, “As far as I’m concerned, for $10,000, if she wants it, she can have it.  Put it in there just like it was for that other girl.  If you don’t do something for a year, it comes back to us with so much discount.  Is that okay with y’all.”  When he asked for a motion, Lacey responded.


“I make a motion that we sell the lot to these people—I don’t know who they are—for $10,000 with the condition that it be a building such as that [indicating some papers the board had just been handed by the Bazzells during the preceding “discussion”], or in a year it reverts back to the city—”


“Or,” Mayor Morris suggested, “if they’re showing good faith, we can give them an extension.”


“—and” Lacey continued, throwing in a wild card, “the money be used to purchase the two lots on Crowe Street for $10,000.”


“I’ll second that motion,” Garrison said quickly, before Mayor Morris reasonable asked, “Can I ask which two lots on Crowe Street we’re buying?”


“The ones we’re using already,” Garrison said promptly.  “The ones that the city park uses over there, that are in between, that we could never get them to price it.  They finally priced it, and if somebody else buys it—”


“By the water tank,” Lacey added.


“Do we need them for the park?” Morris asked, which was answered affirmatively, and after some further discussion the motion passed by a unanimous roll call vote.


“Before y’all get off,” Thrasher said with misplaced optimism [the meeting was to continue on for another three-quarters of an hour], “we’ve got something we just signed this afternoon we need to add.  We need to award the contract for the Delta Regional Grant filtration plant to Barge Wagner.  They’ve done all the footwork, and we agreed that anybody that did the footwork would get the engineering support.”


Garrison made the motion, Browder seconded it, and it carried by unanimous voice vote. 


* * *


“MuniGas Contract,” Mayor Morris then read from the agenda, setting of another marathon discussion.


“Well,” Thrasher said, “you all have a copy in your packet, and I think our legal adviser has—  What about it, Ken?”


“I … don’t know,” Seaton began, doubtfully.  “In y’all’s packets, you’ve got two little pages.  Y’all see those?  I asked Paul Wallace to send me what went with those two little pages, and it’s about sixty pages.  I’ve tried to read it and understand it.  It’s too— I don’t know, I’ve struggled with how to say this.  It’s just about over my head…. It’s tough, and I don’t know where to recommend we go from here.  These sixty pages, this is a language that, a lot of it I don’t, I’m not familiar with.  This is oil, energy law.  It’s like it was written down in Texas, in some big tall building, I’m sure, in Dallas or Houston, and it’s just tough for me to understand.”


“Do you know of anybody you could contact on that to help you out on it?” Morris asked.


“Well—” Seaton said, still doubtful.


“I think—” Plunk said, “Fayette/Hardeman County has already, they have already signed their contract with, and Donny Leggett is the manager of Fayette/Hardeman Utility District on gas, and he’s the one that went with us to Chattanooga to the TVA group, and TVA knows— Their lawyers have looked over all this stuff, and TVA says ‘We wish we could do it, but we’re a government entity and we can’t do this, but we wish we could.’  So, Fayette/Hardeman has already, they’re already on the program to buy gas.  They’re buying gas for the— now.  What we’re trying to do is get in so they can do the same thing for us.”


“Well,” Morris observed, “this is a long term, and I want to make sure that we’re not signing away the city hall, up here.”


“MuniGas is a ten-year contract,” Plunk acknowledged.  “TEAC, which is what Selmer’s with and Savannah’s with, is a twenty-year contract.  That’s who they’re with.  We talked to the TEAC representative, what day was it, Terry?  Last week.  One day last week.  Might have been Thursday.  I don’t remember for sure.  But, he— That’s who Savannah and Selmer is with.  They only get a forty-five to fifty cent rebate back, where MuniGas for the last fifteen months has give eighty cents rebate back per MCF [million cubic feet].”


Morris asked if that would continue, and Plunk replied that “Nobody knows if it’s going to stay that. They’re hoping theirs will go to a dollar.  It started out, was at fifty cents.  It started out fifty cents, MuniGas did, and now, then, they’re up to eighty cents.”


“But you got to remember,” Thrasher added, “if we lose it, it goes back.  It doesn’t mean we have to pay more than we’re paying through TVA now.”


Plunk said, “If you don’t get any rebate whatsoever, let’s say that you go with— and we’re going to have to go with somebody, or either we’re going to have to buy it straight off the, at market price.”


“Like we’ve been doing?” Seaton asked.


“No, TVA has been buying for us.  Now, then, TVA—”


“At market price?” Seaton asked again.


“Yeah,” Plunk replied, “whatever the market price is.  But this is a rebate off of the market price.  If we’re not with any of these, then we’re going to pay market price.”


“Well,” Seaton said, “I was here, now, at that last meeting, when that gentleman presented this to you all, and I was very impressed with him.  He seemed honest.  He seemed like to me he knew what he was talking about.  He wasn’t pushy.  And I don’t have any reason to question this idea.  It sounds good—sounds almost too good to be true.  I just— Now, the easy thing for me to do is say it’s fine, go forward.  I just, I don’t feel, I don’t feel competent to say that.”


“You want to talk to, who?” Morris asked.  “Fayette and Hardeman County—”


“Well,” Seaton replied, “that’s what I was leading into saying a while ago.  There’s been a little bit of a track record with these folks, and some much bigger buyers than the city of Adamsville has made some decisions about this, and maybe we could try and take advantage of some relationships, and ask around, maybe get some insurance [sic] that way.  I don’t have anything, I don’t have any specific concerns.  It’s just that that stuff there is just over my head.  The scary thing about it is the ten years, and, you know, a lot can happen in ten years.  Who knows what can happen in ten years?  Five years from now we might see that there’s something about that document that ties our hands and costs us.”


“I don’t think that it will do that,” Plunk said.  “The only thing, let’s say you, you don’t get any rebate at all, then you’re going to pay market price.”


Seaton remained uncertain.  “There might be some other means out there, though, Paul Wallace, where you could save, where you could save money, that’s not available to you.  You see what I’m saying?  You’re tied.  I just— What I would like to hear somebody, I’d like to hear somebody who knows what they’re talking about, tell us what’s wrong with this.  Maybe there isn’t anybody out there like that.”


“Might be another Enron deal,” Morris suggested.


“When do we have to make a decision on this?” Garrison asked.  “As soon as possible, or not, or when?”


“Come September 1st,” Plunk replied, “we are going to have to buy gas somewhere, for whatever price it is.”  [And in the course of that one sentence, which took Plunk seven seconds to utter, Garrison, as is her wont, interrupted four separate times, saying “Okay” at two different places, “Yes, sir,” at one, and “Right, okay” at another.] 


“So, could, we—” Garrison said, her patience nearly exhausted by Plunk’s long-windedness, “Would you feel better then, Mr. Seaton, if we end up and were able to get you in touch with some of those type of people, before you made a recommendation, or, or would somebody on the board want to take that, or—”


Seaton replied, “I don’t mind, and I’m glad to hear there’s no hurry.  And I don’t— Paul Wallace and I and Terry, we’ll think about it.  We’ll try to find some people to talk to, and come back to the board at the next meeting.”


“We can even talk with TVA,” Plunk added.  “TVA will still manage everything that we do.”


“The way interpret this stuff,” Seaton said, “TVA’s a party to it.  The way I interpret those documents, TVA is a supplier, and TVA does not, will not purchase the gas for us any more.”


Plunk agreed.  “TVA does not, will not purchase the gas for us any more, like they’ve been doing.”


“They will supply the gas for us,” Seaton said.


Plunk continued. “All I had to do was call TVA and tell them, say, ‘Buy me 10,000 [unintelligible word] this morning, at this price.’  And TVA would— Now, if we go with MuniGas, they can’t purchase it for us, they can’t be the marketer for it, but they will check all the records.  They will make sure that MuniGas does everything they’re supposed to do.  We’re still with TVA.”


“And we’re going to stay with them?” Seaton said.


“Yes,” Plunk confirmed.


“And I think if they’re involved in the execution of this—” Seaton began.


“And they have looked over all this,” Plunk added.


“Then,” Seaton said, “those are the people, maybe, we need to get some reassurance from.”


Plunk said “I’ll try to contact Jim Powers tomorrow, with TVA.”


“Tell him your lawyer,” Seaton said with a chuckle, “tell him he don’t know what he’s doing.  He needs some help.”


“Nah,” Plunk replied, “I won’t tell him that.”


Norris then raised another issue. “Regardless of what we do on this, are we— I understand, the last time that we talked about this, that we’re looking at roughly 20% increase in our gas prices?”


“It’s a possibility,” Plunk agreed.


“What’s the percentages of that happening?” Norris asked.


“We don’t know,” Morris said, but Plunk offered a guess: “Probably 90%.”


“Ninety percent,” Norris repeated.  “That’s what I figured.”


“With the kind of numbers I see in the paper,” Seaton offered, “I’m surprised it’s only 20%.”


Plunk pointed out that “Savannah has already had to have an increase.”


“The reason I’m bringing that up,” Norris explained, “is that I wonder if there— How is that going to effect the citizens here, that receive gas?  I mean, they’re already paying four dollars a gallon for gasoline.  Now we’re fixing to have to up the gas prices by 20% or more.”


“But that’s not really our—” Garrison began, only to be rescued by Thrasher.


“You could make a determination,” the town administrator said, “if you look on, when we get into the budget, what you’re going to have operating overhead, and you could take some retained earnings and not shift the price to the consumer as quick as possible.  But you have to be very, very careful.  Because you’re basically, to keep the city at a comfortable footing, you’re probably talking about going up on your gas rates whatever percentage it comes into the door.  We pay eleven, we’ve go to go up—”


“Well,” Plunk offered, “right now, we have gas in storage.  We have enough gas in storage, that we’ve already bought, we’ve already hedged.  And that gas that we’ve got in storage cost us $7.91 for an MCF.  Right now, today’s market, it’s probably eleven or twelve dollars.  So that’s five dollars an MCF more than what we’ve got.  But we’re going to run out.  We’re not putting any more in storage right now, because I told them do not put anything else in storage until we decide what we’re going to do.”


Thrasher explained that “that seven dollar gas is a result of buying gas from four to ten, and it averages out at seven.  We can keep the average down here, but it’s eventually going up there somewhere.”


“Well,” Garrison opined, “we’ve been doing very good for the past few years.”


“Is this going to effect you this winter,” Norris asked, “are there any programs out there available that would help the citizens—”


“Heating assistance, is available,” Thrasher replied.


Norris said, “We need to be advertising, and go on and get it out in the paper and all, and tell them what they can do.”


“See,” Thrasher explained, “the government has to tell you how much money they’re going to put in the kitty, and then the more money they put in the kitty, the more people that qualify.  It’s all in how much money they’re willing to put in, how much we can—”


Jimmie Ann Burk added, “It will be run in the paper when they know how much money they’re going to get.  They’ll run it in the paper, and then Cindy will have the forms over at Senior Citizens.  There’s lots of ways, you know, that people will find out about it.”


After some further discussion, Browder returned to the subject of the rebate currently offered by MuniGas. “When we talk about eighty cents, what kind of money are we talking about saving now, I mean I guess the basic question is how many MCF we’re going to burn.”


“We burned, last year, 197,000 MCF,” Plunk replied.  “We’ve run just a little under 200,000 MCF per year.  I had some figures with me last time.  I don’t have them with me now.  The eighty cents would save the city a hundred-and-something dollars.”


“If it was 200,000, it would be $160,000,” Thrasher said.


“Now,” Plunk continued, “the one that Selmer and Savannah is with is Tennessee Energy.  For three, three or four years, they got no rebate whatsoever, because the fellow that was managing it played the market with it and he lost three and a half million dollars, so they didn’t get any discount.  There wasn’t any there to get.”


Finally, Mayor Morris said “I’m for letting Seaton and them meet together, and let’s put an end to this thing.  [To Seaton:]  Work on things.”  The board was in agreement with this. 


* * *


“Department Heads Salary,” Morris said, reading the bottom item on the agenda and setting of a short but confusing exchange.  “I put that on there.  I think we need to put a limit on department heads’ salary.  If they’re going to be a salaried department head, I don’t think we ought to pay no overtime if they have to work in place of some of their men, or something….  Just like Bill, here, is the chief of police here, we paid him some overtime this last week.  He worked, what, eight hours overtime or something?”


“All day Friday,” McCall replied, briefly.


“No,” Morris said, “you got a, you worked in somebody’s place, didn’t you?  What was it I saw on there?”


“All I remember is holiday pay,” Thrasher said.  “Now, we had a cop or two that picked up, somebody had some overtime, but it wasn’t Bill.  What we’ve been doing, is the police department works straight shifts.  If you get a holiday, like the next holiday coming up is the 4th of July.  Instead of trying to cover the shifts paying overtime, police department just works their regular shift.  So the guy that’s working on the 4th of July would get his regular pay, plus the day of holiday’s pay.  So instead of getting ten days pay, he’ll actually get eleven.”


I looked at it wrong, then,” Morris said, “but I want to see last week’s pay, Bill.  Don’t have to do it tonight.  I’ll do it tomorrow.”


“Can I say something?” Asked Plunk, himself a department head.  “I don’t get no overtime.” 


* * *


“All right, let’s go on,” Morris said.  “We’re down to the budget now.”


Thrasher attempted a brief summary. “General fund we project to be $4,190 to the black, next fiscal year.  The sanitation special fund would probably come out about 7,250 to the black.  State street aid is 56,000 and 56,000 out.  ATD drug fund, probably $250 ahead. Debt service number one for water bond, 7,500 ahead.  The capital projects, or the CDBG grants, the water tank and the water filtering project, those zero out.  Same amount comes in goes out.  Water/Sewer fund could come out in the black 26,250, the gas could be in the black about 122,000, and the grand total of the budget next year would be about $208,740 to the good, under these numbers that we gave you guys.  And this budget is heavily loaded in capital.  We put a lot of money in there in capital, because we haven’t put a lot of money in there for the past few years, and there’s lots of things we need to do.  We’ve got trucks in the utility department that need replacing.  We’re looking at a vac—how do you pronounce it?—vactron truck.  You going to bring that up a little bit about the auction sale?  We’ve got an auction sale that’s got two trucks in it that we need one of, and if we can get over there and they’re in good shape, we can buy them right and it would save a lot of money.”

 

“Another thing,” Morris interjected, “is we’re renting that vac-tractor, is that what they call it, or something? You know, we’re cleaning out the sewer lines with it.  Cost $2,800 a month rent, and there’s one in this auction that, just according to the paper, looks good, and Terry called today on that.”


After some further discussion, Thrasher asked, “What do y’all want to do about the budget?  If you approve the first reading tonight, you can come back on the 30th for a quick meeting and let that be the second reading and we will be ahead of the wire.”


“Okay,” Garrison asked, “we do have money in there, though, for all these personnel changes that’s going to be taking place at city hall, correct?  I mean, I just want to make sure that had stayed in there, and that we were going to have to up some of those positions and some not.”


“We’ve got a good budget, and everybody’s getting, what, a 2.7 raise?” Morris said in summary.  “And we’ve got in there for capital outlays, of laying some water lines, some vehicles, it’s just a guess deal.  You know, you got to put down a bunch of numbers.”


“Well, I had two questions,” Norris said, to no one’s surprise.  “One is, you know, in looking the budget over, I couldn’t tell, so I just wanted to ask, you know.  There’s been a tremendous increase in the cost of fuel.  Have we, has that been adjusted for in this budget, because it’s going to like double this year as opposed to what it was last year.”


“Well, I had two questions.  One is, you know, in looking the budge over, I couldn’t tell, so I just wanted to ask, you know.  There’s been a tremendous increase in the cost of fuel.  Have we, has that been adjusted for in this budget, because it’s going to like double this year as opposed to what it was last year.”


“It always,” Thrasher said, “but we just threw the ball farther down field this time to say maybe we got it in front of what the gas price is going to be. But if it doesn’t, remember gas is a revenue fund and water is a revenue fund, and some of this capital money we’ve got in there we may not spend anyway, so our budget will be on firm footing if gas does do that.”


“Well,” Norris said, “that was the other thing.  I was asking as far as revenue was concerned, you know, there’s people that are traveling less, there spending less on gas now.  Does that mean we’re going to less revenue tax-wise—”


“But that goes into street paving and things like that,” Thrasher explained.  “It doesn’t go into general funds.”


“All right,” Norris continued, “the other question I had, you know, this is not a big money item, but I think it’s important to us.  And that is, I didn’t see any kind of a specific dollar amount in there for landscaping, maintenance, and mowing and all kind of things I asked about last year.  And, you know, we’ve had problems with that for the last two years, you know, being able— We shouldn’t have to.  There ought to be money allotted for that, and we ought to be able to just go do it.”


Thrasher explained that those expenses were included in the general fund. “We don’t break it out, just like for flowers and signs.”


Lacey then said, “The question I’d like to ask about the budget is, what are the different departments doing to cut back?” to which Plunk and McCall both said they had addressed the matter in meetings with their departments.


“Those are the things I think the people we represent need to see,” said Lacey (who is currently campaigning for the position of state representative, to go with his currently held positions as school board member, chairman of the school board, and commissioner of the town of Adamsville), “is us being wise with our money.”


“Well,” Morris observed, “the homeowners are having to cut back; we need to cut back.  Show our good faith.  They’re the ones that really, I guess, are paying the bills.”


“I make a motion that we pass the budget on the first reading,” Lacey said, before gratuitously adding, “without having to raise taxes.”


“We ain’t got tax raises in there,” Morris pointed out, and the motion passed unanimously after being seconded by Garrison.


“We need to amend the motion of the budget this year,” Thrasher said before the meeting broke up.  “Sanitation fund, we need to amend the motion that we will take in up to 186,200, is that what you got?  And we need to amend the sanitation budget from 160,000 to 162,500…. So I need a motion that we amend the 2007-2008 budget.”  “You’re amending from 100,000 up to 186,200, and from 160,000 to 162,500.”


Lacey made the motion, which was seconded by Garrison and passed by a unanimous roll call vote.


The last word was had by Shawn Sisk, in the audience: “I want to interject something.  Several of you, since y’all raised up saving money, if y’all will allow me to work with you, I can save you a couple of thousand, two or three thousand dollars a year on your fee for your sirens.  That’s about all I’ll say for that.  Y’all keep that in mind.”


The meeting was adjourned on a motion by Browder, seconded by Garrison.


 

Town Board Meeting

19 May 2008
 

May saw the full resumption of hostilities in the on-going war within the Adamsville town board, with Mayor Tommy Morris accusing the town’s commissioners of “usurping the charter” and telling the board that “the next time this happens I’m going to sock you with a charge on malfeasance and misfeasance.”  Town Attorney Ken Seaton spoke at length, generally supporting the mayor’s complaint, and the commissioners were largely subdued, except for Dwana Garrison, who supplemented her accustomed belligerence with some childish mockery.

 

* * * 


These hostilities broke out more than an hour and twenty minutes into another marathon session, which began smoothly enough with the unanimous approval of the minutes (on a motion by Frank Lacey, seconded by Mike Norris), the financial report (on a motion by Garrison, seconded by Lacey), and of the remaining reports (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Norris).


Garrison provided an update “about the Festival coming up.  Most all of you know it’s this week.  We are in full swing.  We already have people in from all over the United States, and also from Canada, that are in here with us.  Want to invite everybody out Saturday morning for the opening ceremonies.  That’s at 11:00 a.m.  The sheriff that has won the award this year is Sheriff Joe Arpaio from Arizona.  Didn’t realize what a big celebrity he was until all this took place, and CNN and Fox News got excited.  Bill [Police Chief Bill McCall] had nominated him.  He is the sheriff who makes the jail mates sleep in tents, called tent city, and wear pink boxer shorts.  And it should be really big.  We’ve got things lined up.  We have a new carnival we’ve never had before, and it looks fantastic up there.  They’re already up there and setting up.  We got the fireworks location changed.  It should be, thought, still a great fireworks show.  Talent contest.  Terry’s head of the ‘fifties and ‘sixties music.  Because of graduation, Frank and I and some others have Thursday night with our seniors, and also Mayor Seaton, I mean, excuse me, Judge Seaton, I’m sorry, has, will have a big talent show on Friday night.  Saturday we have a parade.  There are no four-wheelers allowed in it, no horses allowed in it, no motorcycles, unless it is ridden by police officers.  It will be a very slow parade, led by police officers and all the way through it, mostly beauty queen winners, politicians, and we do have a float this year.  The parade, the floats, Adamsville Elementary School went to the Humboldt parade and won best out-of-town float first prize, and we’re excited to know that we’re going to have a float in our parade.  And it was called “Walking Tall Through Berryland.”  So, that’s going to take place, and we hope to have lots of people in and spend lots and lots of money with us.  And I just wanted to bring that up, Mayor, since that was under the reports, the Home and Museum, we look to, hopefully, sell quite a few things.   I know Rene and her staff will do that.  And one other thing.  We had a large, we had a very nice donation made today at the museum by this couple here from Ontario, Canada.  [Jim and Maria Hebbard, from Brampton, Ontario.]  They have put in a rose garden in the front of the home where we had some unsightly bushes and it was needing something terribly bad done.  And they spent the money, and Sheryl and them are over there and planting it, and the rose garden is Pauline Pusser Memorial Rose Garden, and they have bought some gorgeous bushes to plant there, and I want to say a very special thank you to you two for doing that.  It’s very nice of you.  And they’re from Canada.”

 

* * * 


Moving on to old business, Mayor Morris called on City Administrator Terry Thrasher for a report on “Long Range Plan Cost.”


“We just got this in,” Thrasher said, holding up some documents, “and I didn’t copy it because we hadn’t, it’s the rough draft.  But MTAS run a survey for us.  Kind of similar to what we’re trying to get the engineering firms to for us, which we talked about last month.  But MTAS has had this under study for the past several weeks, and they finished it up late last Friday.  Came down and brought it to me, and gave us some preliminary cost figures, their estimation of what we can do to get a leg up on our water and waste water program.  And it really wasn’t as bad as I thought it was.  I was very shocked that they couldn’t find a way to spend more money than they did.  But, they’re talking about the water tank improvement, which I think we’ve got an engineering group here to talk about that anyway, and replacement of some pumping systems and this, you know, rough figures, but they also went over our financials up through the year 2007 and they called me and said, ‘You’ve got a lot of money.  Where’d you get it?’  I said, well, we don’t have a lot, but we’ve got everything going our way.  But our interest income was up nicely, and our bonds are retiring very well, and they think we’ll be in a great position if need to, which we probably will, to go to rural development and get grant loan program to do the long-term stuff that you guys have been talking about, which is the replacement of old water lines.  That’s going to be the most expensive thing.  We’ve started a—[Turns to Paul Wallace Plunk of the utility department]—I don’t guess you’ve started the smoke testing of the sewer system yet.  But we’ve got, that’s part of their study, part of their recommendation, that we smoke test our sewer system.  But we’re talking about, about $675,000.  Would do a lot for us.  Probably put our sewer pond, with a 300,000 over, in other words we’d have a 300,000 more in gallons of capacity if we did that.”


Responding to a question from Jeff Browder, Thrasher said that the $675,000 was for water and waste water combined, and Morris observed that “Where prices are now, that won’t go far.”


“This would be the long range plan?” Norris asked.


“This will do—” Thrasher began.  “It will not replace water lines like the one down Main Street needs replacing, and some of these old cast iron metal lines that Tommy’s told you about being in the ground for, what, Tommy?  Forty years?”


“Well,” Norris said, “why don’t you write us up a report and get it to us—”


“I will,” Thrasher said.


“—we could sit here and talk all night,” Norris concluded, which was nearly prophetic, given how long the meeting actually lasted.


“Well,” Thrasher added, referring to the report, “this is boiler plate.  We can do it.  We can afford to do it, and it’s not going to affect us much.  The one that we’re, that engineering companies give a study on, is the one where we have to replace water lines.”


“So,” Lacey asked, “what is, I mean, how valid or accurate is that report, and that price?”


“Very,” Thrasher replied.  “The accuracy has got to be within ten percent of the cost.”


“Is this what Paul Wallace was supposed to be doing,” Norris asked, “or are—”


“Part of it,” Thrasher answered.  “He gave them a lot of the figures that they used to come up with this.”


“Well,” Norris asked, “are we finished with it now, Paul Wallace?  Have you got more to do, or what?”


“No,” Plunk replied, “there’s some more we can do.”


Thrasher added, “When the engineering firms start talking to us about the long plan, we’ll have to do some more figures for them, too.”


“But after this right here,” Lacey asked, “will we be able to supply the needs for any increased industry in our industrial park?”


“Yeah,” Thrasher responded, “I’d think this would help.”


“And to subdivisions from around, water—” Lacey began.


“Yeah,” Thrasher continued, “because we’re talking about another 200, 250,000 gallon tank?”  Thrasher looked toward Barge Wagner representative Shannon Cotter for clarification of the tank size, then he continued. “Two hundred and fifty thousand more storage, which will help us, will fix our state problem.  And it would give better pressure in quite a few lines.  So, yeah, that’s—”


Norris interrupted: “How does this figure in relation to the grant that we already have?”


“Well, that is one of the grants,” Thrasher replied, turning again to Cotter, who confirmed it.  “That’s the CDBG grant we applied for, we got that for the water tank.”


“But,” Browder said, joining the discussion, “that’s not a grant to meet any pressure problems or anything like that.  I mean, you know—”


“I think it will help the pressure,” Thrasher interjected.


“Of course,” Browder continued, “I realize it’s a bad thing to live outside the city limits, but when I did, I lived on a road that had a two-inch water pipe.  And I don’t care how hard you press it, you’re not going to get but so much water into a two-inch water pipe.  And when you build the next eight or ten homes on that road, and everybody gets up in the morning and getting ready to go to work, I saw a pretty good fluctuation in water.  Now I’m not going to say we’ve got a lot of that, but I know I did, and I know we have it in spots.  But, that’s, are we talking about doing some work on that—”


“Well,” Thrasher responded, “a lot of this work is places where a line goes to here, and skips a mile and a half and comes from the other way.  We’ve got a lot of deadheads.  We don’t like deadheads because of the stale water and the pressure.  That would fix a lot of those.”


“But I guess I,” Lacey said, “I guess our main concern, or what we have talked about was, we were wanting to be sure our fire ratings would stay the same, or improve some, after these improvements, and we would be able to supply any number of industries or homes, or, if we have two fires at the same time, be able to put them out without any question.  And this right here you’re saying will—”


“Well, trying to give you a percentage of what that part—” Thrasher began, then he turned to Plunk and asked, “What will that fix?  A third of the problem?”  After some cross talk, Thrasher said “I’d say it’s done twenty-five to thirty-five percent of our problems, this would alleviate.  But the other 65% is going to take the replacement of water lines.”


Plunk opined that “The only way you’re going to fix your problem with, your fire rating, you’re going to have to do like Hardin County.  You’re going to have to go to a dump system.  That’s the only way you can do it.  They did it, and they’ve lowered their rating two points.  That’s just a big plastic dump bin out here, but you’ve got a truck running to it all time to put water in it.  You don’t have to have that high a pressure off of the fire plugs if you’re using the dump tanks.”


“Is that a costly situation?” Norris asked, and when Thrasher responded “No” and Plunk “I don’t think so,” Norris asked, “Why don’t we do it?”


“We’ll need to look into it,” Garrison agreed.


“We don’t need it here in town, do we?” Mayor Morris asked, setting off further discussion of in-town water requirements.


 “A dump tank,” Thrasher said, “for a municipality, is not going to help change the ISO rating a whole lot.  What they’re going to want to do, is they go to the elementary school and the high school and the nursing homes and places like that.  And they want to have a certain gallon-per-minute flow.  The bigger the industry, or the bigger the building and the more people in it, they want more flow.  So, dump tanks don’t get you flow out of the fireplug.  If I’ve got two fire trucks pumping two attack lines, I’m looking at 400 gallons per minute minimum, and a fireplug will produce 500 gallons a minute.  So you can just barely fill the truck up and get it in the dump tank.  The dump tank is a short way to get around the problem, which is not having enough water flow, which was what I was saying.  All the line that was replaced when they widened 64 east and west, they changed some of that line.”


“If we’re fixing to redo downtown,” Lacey remarked, “I would hate to redo downtown and then come back in two years later.”


Thrasher pointed out that “You won’t tear it up.  You’ll abandon that line.  What we’ll do is pick a spot out, somewhere down in here, tap it, go north, go west, and go around that.  We’re not going to dig that line, we’re just going to abandon it.”


“Probably tap it in two or three different places,” Morris added.


“Now,” Lacey continued, “I think that’s what, I mean, the way I understand it, what I would like to see us do, is get a price to give us a 100% bid.  A 100% fix.  Even if we’re not able to do it, we’ll at least know this is what we’ve got to do—”


“We’ve got a plan,” Norris interjected.  “That’s what we were asking for—”


Lacey continued: “—to go forward, because right now we can’t think ahead for the worries that are behind us.”


“Well,” Thrasher replied, “the engineers that we’re asking to come in and give us bids are going to take it from the step that this MTAS took us, into the next, probably, 15-20 years.  So, how much money do you want to borrow, and how quick do you want to pay it back?”


“Right now,” Lacey replied, “we don’t want to borrow any.  We just want to look and see what we’ve got to look at.”


“Well,” Norris asked, “when are we going to get something back from the engineers?”


“Hopefully,” Thrasher replied, “by next meeting I’ll have some numbers for you.”


“And I guess from those engineers,” Browder said, “if we don’t already, we probably need to ask for a percent of increase by year.  You’re looking at something, $674,000 this year, and it’s going to be five years out when you do it, then you’re probably looking at a million.”  Turning to Barge Wagner representative Bryant Bondurant, he asked “Do you automatically figure that in when you do something like that?”


“You can figure inflation.” Bondurant replied.  “It’s a hard guess—”


“Yeah.  Sure,” Browder agreed.


Bondurant continued. “You can figure it in and make an estimate, but, man, especially the last few years, it’s real hard to do.”

 

* * * 


Looking at the agenda, Mayor Morris said “Let’s go to ‘Direct Deposit, Payroll.  Thrasher.’”


“We’ve checked on this,” Thrasher said, “talked about it, several of us have, and I’d like to recommend that the city go to direct deposit for the payroll.  We’ve got about thirty-seven, thirty-eight people.  It’s very time consuming, and we can probably do it cheaper, with the system we looked at last week through one of the local banks, and I think we ought to go to direct deposit.”


After nearly ten minutes of discussion about methods and procedures and employee concerns, the board voted unanimously (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Norris) to adopt a direct-deposit payroll policy.



* * *


“New Business,” Mayor Morris said, referring again to the agenda.  “Paul wanted me to bring Barge Wagner up.  What does Barge Wagner want to tell us?”


Plunk explained that “they’re the ones that did the water study for us, about the CDBG grant on the water tank.  So, they’re here to explain that issue to us tonight.”


“Come right on up here and explain something to us,” Morris said, and Bondurant came to the front of the room.


“Well,” he began, “what we wanted to do in the study was determine where to put the water tank.  We knew we needed a water tank, and so that was the main purpose.  We got to look at the whole system, and that’s what we did during the study, and evaluated where the pressures were throughout the system and where would be the best place to put that tank.  And where our recommendation was, was at the end of Holmes Road.  Now, we met with Paul this afternoon, there’s a gentleman at Old Union Road and—”


“Old Union Road and Harris Road intersection,” Plunk said.


“At that intersection,” Bondurant continued, “which is in generally the same area, it’s also, that elevation is a little bit higher, which is fine.  Makes the tank be a little bit shorter.  So, you know, our recommendation would be to go with that location rather than the one we actually put in our report.”


“On this tank,” Morris asked, “I though Hardin County was getting a grant for that.”


Thrasher replied, “We tried to get them to for the last two or three years, but now I don’t think they—  They got turned down—  They didn’t ask for one.  They got turned down on something else.”


“Can I, may I address that?” Cotter spoke up from the audience.  “Not to interrupt Terry, but may I address that?  I’ve done this fifteen or twenty years, and I used to do it for the CDBG people that run the program.  If you are the supplier of the service, in this case, water, you have to be the applicant.  Now, the only other way it could have happened was for the county to apply on the city’s behalf and use the county’s eligibility numbers—that’s per-capita income, unemployment data, stuff like that.  But since Adamsville is the provider of the water in this vicinity, they were the appropriate applicant.  I do not know what Hardin County applied for.  I don’t even know that I’ve got a list of who applied for what and who was funded.  Sometimes I do, sometimes I don’t.  But in this case the CDBG people have awarded y’all the $500,000 grant for an elevated storage tank of 250,000 gallons, plus all the other stuff that goes with it.  And that was submitted back in February of this year.”


“So we done got it, then?” Morris asked.


“Yes, sir,” Cottner replied.  “You have it.  This is money in hand.  So you’re in good shape there.”


Thrasher then said to Plunk, “You might point out about the difference in moving the tank, with the price of the land.”


“Yes,” Plunk complied.  “It’s my understanding that Mr. Carl Banks, who owns this property, will donate the land where the tank is going.  Jimmie Ann has talked to him more than I have, but that’s my understanding, that he would donate the land.  Of course, this afternoon he said, ‘I would get free water, wouldn’t I?’ [General laughter.]  I said I believe that could be worked out.”


Lacey asked where the property was located.


“It’s at Old Union,” Plunk replied.  “And it’s past the Old Union pumping station.”


“That’s out 69 North—” Lacey began.


“Yeah,” Plunk replied.  “Go to Jot-Em-Down Store, and turn right.  And Shannon would like to know how it got to be named Jot-Em-Down.”


Responding further to the mayor’s earlier query, Cotter said,“Looking at the funding left for CDBGs for this year, Hardin County, it doesn’t even look like applied, or was even funded.  Now that’s just a quick run through, but that’s— I hope that answers your question.”


“Well,” Morris persisted, “what I was concerned with there is that if we use our ability for a grant for down in there, what if, can we still have the ability to get grants up in here?”


“Yes, sir, that has no—” Cottner began.  You have been awarded that $500,000 to erect a water storage tank and all the items that go to support that tank.  They will not take that away from you.  In fact I talked to Paula Roberts, the grants manager, today on the way out here and told her that we were coming to Adamsville to look at a site today for a recommendation, and she was just elated that you’re getting one.  So you’re in good shape there.  Once this one’s done, Adamsville is eligible to apply again, for anything that provides services.  It’s the same concept that if you’re applying for a fire truck in your five-mile service radius, even though it’s outside your city limits you are the provider of that coverage area, so you could get a truck from them to serve that area.  Well, you would be eligible to apply.”


“What’s the time frame? “ Lacey asked.  “Time line?”


“That depends upon what action you take tonight,” Cottner replied.  “If you say, ‘Yes, we’re willing to accept this gentleman’s offer to put the tank on this place,’ the next thing that will happen is I will get with the development district, show them the site, they will start the environmental, there’s some paperwork that has to go through with the property owner to get him to sign on the dotted line saying he knows he’s eligible for compensation but he’s waiving that right and he’s donating the property.  Then we’ll start the survey and go from there.”


“And then, is that a month?” Lacey asked.


“I would say,” Cottner replied, “by the time your environmental is done, you’re probably, I would say you’re two months, at least, getting the environmental done.  By the time you advertise, run it in the paper, send the letters and all that kind of stuff.  Design is probably, four months?  Four months for the design—”


“Talking about next year,” Morris interjected.


“Yeah,” Bondurant agreed, “you’re going to be toward the end of the year before you can get started with construction.”


Finally, Mayor Morris asked, “What do we need to do?  Give her an okay tonight for this?”


“I’m for it,” Lacey said.  “I make a motion that we give them permission to talk, negotiate with this guy, and get the land [unintelligible word], get the environmental started and—”


“Get going on it,” Garrison interjected.  “And I’d like to second it.”


The motion carried by a unanimous vote, after which Lacey asked for further clarification regarding when the tank could be put in.  Cottner said that the project could be under way by the end of the year.


“And then after you start it,” Lacey persisted, how long will it be?”


“They can put up a water tank pretty quick,” Bondurant replied.  “Probably, no more than four months.”


 “So, this time next year we’ll have a water tank?” Lacey asked.


 “Yeah, I’d say so,” Bondurant replied.  “Yeah.  About a year from now.”


* * *


The next item on the agenda was “Munni [sic] Gas,” discussion of which went on for a dozen minutes.


Muni Gas representative Dwight Luton took the floor.


“I retired as utility director for the city of Clarksville about two years ago,” Luton began.  “I worked there twenty-eight years, and I was over the gas, water and sewer.  And the reason I tell you that is that one of the things we did at the city of Clarksville, we were the first city in the United States to do a gas pre-pay.  This is not a gas pre-pay on behalf of Adamsville, but we were the first city in the United States to do a gas pre-pay.  Then I was involved in about five more pre-pays over the next fifteen years.  And when I left the city, actually what I was doing was working on a gas pre-pay for a number of cities that wanted to buy some gas under index.  Most all of us pay index, or a little more.  And the price of gas, that’s a very sensitive issue right now.  And about a year ago I ran into Muni Gas.  Muni Gas is a non-profit, owned by a city in Texas, Lagrange, Texas, started Muni Gas.  They fall under the same rules and regulations that all of the cities of Tennessee do.  Muni Gas is an instrument of the city of Lagrange, so it’s non-profit.  Started listening to their program, and I started telling the cities that I was dealing with, and they liked it much better, and the reason they liked it much better, most of the time you do a pre-pay, you usually get a discount on about half of your supply.  Because you don’t want to lock in all of it.  You can’t commit to that much.  And some of the discounts have been, Cynergy is a good company, done twenty, twenty-two cents.  TEAC done about twenty-four cents.  So a lot of them has been doing in the twenty, twenty-some-odd cents range.  Muni Gas has been, for sixteen straight months, at eighty cents under index, which is unheard of.  It’s been the best deal on gas in the United States that I’ve ever seen.  And, so.  That is not guaranteed.  But they’re a non-profit.  The three prior months they were seventy-four cents.  And so they just started selling gas outside of the state of Texas in January ‘07.  In December ‘07 they bought 2.5 billion dollars worth of natural gas to sell just to cities alone.  They don’t sell to anybody but cities and utility districts.  Then in June ‘07 they bought another two billion dollars worth.  So they’ve been selling a lot of gas to cities.  There’s nearly a hundred cities they’re selling to.”


Luton continued. “The good thing about Muni Gas is, it’s quite unusual, they’re not a supplier.  It’s a real unique financial deal.  It meets all IRS rules and qualifications for tax exempt gas.  But you keep the supplier of choice.  The supplier you’re using now, you can keep that supplier, or if you decide to change, you can change, as long as they’re on the Muni Gas program.  Muni Gas is kind of tailor-made for cities and municipalities to provide gas at a discount.  Gas is $6, you get the discount.  If it’s $10, you get the discount.  So it keeps you under index.  Where, most all the cities I know that, is paying index or above.”


Summing up, Luton said “It’s a really good program for cities to buy natural gas and still maintain their relationship with who they’re dealing with now.”


“Only problem I’ve got with it,” Mayor Morris said, “I don’t like to tie up nothing for ten years, contract for ten years.”  He then asked, “How does this compare with what we’re already getting with TGA?”


Luton said, “You can keep TGA, will continue, I understand, will be, manage your gas, and so it will be eighty cents less than what they’re selling it to you, and they’re buying into this program….  So whatever you’re paying now, whatever deal you cut with any supplier, it will be eighty cents under that.  Now keep in mind—I never want to mislead you—that’s not guaranteed.  But Muni Gas has— it could be higher, and it could be lower.  But it’s been eighty cents for sixteen straight months.”


After further questioning of Luton by the mayor and the commissioners, Paul Wallace Plunk said “TGA is going to manage everything, just like they’ve always done.  It’s just whenever we get a bill to pay the gas, it will come from Muni Gas instead of TGA.”


“So,” Thrasher summed up, “since we’re getting our gas from TGA, we’re going to continue to get our gas from TGA, all we’re taking is the eighty cents, or whatever percent that it is.”


“Well,” Norris observed, “this may not be the time to discuss it, but we talked about this a little bit the other day, the fact that the public out here, a lot of folks are having trouble paying the bills now, and it would be my opinion that we should have, maybe we need a new, separate meeting for this, to discuss this and determine some ways of helping the consumers to pay their bills by averaging them out, I don’t know what other programs are available out there, but you’re going to have that come up.”


“I think we ought to turn this literature over to our legal department and let him look at it,” Morris finally said, “and then we will get back to you.  Is that all right?”


“I would recommend you do that, too,” Luton agreed.  “I think your legal needs to look at it, and if you decide to do it, at some time you will need to pass a resolution, and then there will be some contracts.  We’ll have to get information from Mr. Plunk, there’ll be some contracts, we’d want your legal to look at that, too.”


Plunk added that the savings to the city would be considerable. “Last year, in ‘07, we bought 179,648 MCF of gas.  All right, with an eighty cent discount, that would have been a saving of $143,718, on last year’s gas.”

 

* * * 


After some further discussion of gas usage, Mayor Morris moved on to the next agenda item: “Ordinance to read—Sign Rules & Residential use of B-1”


“We’ve got two ordinances,” Thrasher began.  “The planning commission recommends to the city commission that we change the sign rule for all premise signs.  All premise directional signs identifying subdivisions located wholly or partially within the corporate limits of Adamsville, provided that each subdivision shall be limited to one such sign, which will be placed on a lot fronting on an arterial or collector-status road.  These signs shall be limited to two faces, with a total sign area not to exceed 100 square feet.  The signs shall be removed after the sale of 90% of the lots in the subdivision that it identifies.”


When Lacey made a motion to approve the sign ordinance, Morris observed that “This is just the first reading.”  [Evidently, first readings are not voted on at Adamsville town board meetings.]


“All right,” Thrasher continued, “number two.  An ordinance amending the text of the Adamsville Municipal Code addressing residential uses in the B-1 business district and in the B-2 business district.  Residential apartments, provided the following conditions are met.  Apartments shall be an accessory use to a permitted commercial or service use.  Apartment shall be located above the ground floor, or behind the primary structure fronting a street, and contain a separate outside entrance.  No more than two apartments shall be allowed in any one building.  Adequate parking shall be accessible within 200 feet of the apartment.  Any apartment to be developed shall not be less than 500 square feet.  The character of the building as a commercial structure shall not be changed by the addition of the residential use.  This shall not prohibit building improvements designed to enhance the architectural character of the building.  An accurate and scaled site plan shall be presented to the board of zoning appeals.  Compliance with the Southern Standard Building Code, the 101 Life Safety Code and other applicable fire and electric and plumbing codes at the time of the issuance of the certificate of occupancy.”


The first reading of this ordinance was also not voted on.

 

* * * 


The next several agenda items were disposed of quickly.  The board voted unanimously (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Browder, to “contract with Williams, Jerrolds and Godwin for the next year’s audit.  Thrasher then said, “You all have this in your package, where we did the little thing up at the Pickwick Inn.  I took a few ideas that you guys had thrown at me, and a few other people threw about, and I developed this.  It’s for your discussion, approval—”


“We’ll work on it,” Garrison said.


“Let’s work on that a little bit,” Norris agreed.


“I just want you to take it and work on it, and do something with it,” Thrasher said.


Garrison said,“Get back with you before the next meeting.”


“In other words,” Morris said, “we’re going put that one off.”


“Parade permit,” Morris read from the agenda.


“The city has an ordinance,” Thrasher responded, “or has it on the books, Section 16-110, parades and so forth regulated.  It shall be unlawful for any club, organization or other group to hold any meeting, parade, demonstration, or exhibition on the public streets without some responsible representative first securing a permit from the recorder.  We don’t have a permit.  We have not ever seen one.  We’ve never issued one that we’re aware of.  But we have this in our charter, and I borrowed a sample permit from our neighbor, and I think we ought to pass it, and accept it, so we can get it signed before we have a parade.”  A motion to that effect was made by Norris, seconded by Lacey, and passed unanimously.


Mayor Morris then asked if there was anyone in the audience who wished to address the board.

 

Vickie Cottner rose and identified herself to the board.  “I sit on the board of aldermen for the city of Crump and I’m here to represent, I have twelve signatures here on a petition.  These people are interested in having city water between 255 and 1130 on Seaton Loop, and a few residents on Lakefield Lane….  I was told it would be $300 for a water tap and $30 for service charge.  Is that correct?”


Mayor confirmed that those were the correct charges.


“I was just here on the behalf of those people,” Cottner said, “and I know that they would greatly appreciate anything that the city and the board could do to give them the option of being allowed to hook up with the Adamsville Utility Department in the very near future.”


“I believe that we went over this a year ago, or two years ago.” Morris said, observing that there would be considerable costs associated with extending the water lines out to that location.  “And it wasn’t feasible,” he said.  “We’ve got to have feasiblilty.”  But the city would look into it, Morris said.  “What we need to do, Vickie, is let Paul Wallace get his stuff out and I’ll look at it and we’ll get it to the board.”

 

* * * 


“Is there anybody else?” Morris asked, and Jim Hebberd rose in the audience.  “Yes, sir?” Morris said.


“I want to thank you for listening to me here today,” Hebberd began, “because, really, some people would wonder what right I have to speak before you since I don’t live in the States.  But for the last couple of years I’ve been coming down to your museum, to Adamsville, and they say that Canadians go to Florida for snowbirding.  We don’t.  We come to Adamsville.  We love the place.  The people are super-friendly.  We’re hooked.  Except for one thing.  I have become, like many other people, a great fan of Dwana’s dad, and we’ve gone to the museum many times.  And I’ve noticed a few things that I’d like to respectfully put to you that might help with improvements for the museum.  Such as the front lawn.  We spoke to some people from Italy today that visited the museum.  There were some from Illinois.  And there was a few other people, and they all mentioned the same thing.  It would help with the appearance.  It looks like in spots it’s just drying up and dying up.  And in my feeling, Mayor, I think it would really, truly help, you know, make the museum what it should be and what it is.  Also, your verandah, at the tail end of it, there’s parts of it starting to give way.”


“The verandah?” Morris asked.


“Up front,” Hebberd explained, “where you go into the main room—”


“Front porch,” Garrison volunteered.


“Front porch,” Hebberd agreed.  “Sorry.  We call them verandahs, I’m sorry.  You might want to have some people take a look at that, also.  But believe it or not, that’s it.  It’s just something about that lawn that a couple of people commented on today.  Not people who work there, or live here in Adamsville.”


“Well,” Morris said, “we’ve got a park crew that’s supposed to be mowing the yard and keeping it up.  I haven’t looked at it.”


Garrison said the problem was that the grass couldn’t grow because of the trees, and Mayor Morris said he thought the parks department was taking care of everything.


Norris pointed out to Garrison that “You’ve got money there [in the budget] to do it now.”


“No, Mike,” Garrison responded dismissively, “we really don’t.  It’s getting awfully close, because Debbie’s had to buy a lot of things, we’ve had to, to fill up the gift shop for the festival, coming in.  And, once again, you’ve got back down to the problem, too many people afraid to do too much.  And we’re short on help.  We’ve got people in the park system who can’t take care of what they’ve got to say grace over.  And, speaking of this, I’m getting ready to tell you, when I was, Sunday, at the Community Center, the flower bed up there is horrendous, and we spent over, out of the Buford Pusser Foundation, $2,000 to have that done, and Judy, Teddy and Porkchop at the time were going to see that that flower bed did not get in the shape that it was before, and there’s a lot of grass growing in it already, and that stuff needs to be taken care of.  If I was physically able, I’d get on my hands and knees and get down there and pull that out, but I’m not.  But that really hurts me to see that being done.  Paul Wallace, do you know when you’re going to get some of these younger guys, or when you could—  Because right now we need to put, I guess, our best face forward, when we’ve got people like you and others traveling in from all over.  Especially at the house.  And then, you know, people renting the community center every weekend.”


“We’ve been spending enough on flowers lately,” Morris observed.  “They ought to be growing.”


Garrison returned to the subject of the grass not growing.


“I think that’s just a lack of—” Lacey began.


Norris interrupted: “That’s just maintenance.”


Lacey continued “—that’s from lack of care—” only to be interrupted again, this time by Garrison.


“Okay,” Garrison said, “but what I’m saying is we’ve got to have more people to care.  You know, there’s just so much of Teddy that can go around.”


“I agree,” Norris said.


“Okay, then,” Garrison said, “okay, do you want to hire a new person in that department, or what do we need to do, guys?”


Mayor Morris pointed to Plunk and said, “He just hired four today, didn’t you?”


“I got four high school students,” Plunk replied, “as soon as school’s out.  I’ve got one that starts in the morning.”


Garrison was skeptical.  “Okay.  Now, with that, will they have a little sense to go along with what their, you know, jobs should be?  In other words, I know if you sent Madison [her daughter] out there with no lead, I’d hate to see what would come back, but so I’m just saying, I hope that these people, you know, you’re going to train them.  Which I’m sure you are.”


“They’ll have somebody to show them and tell them what to do,” Plunk said, patiently.


“Because,” Garrison said with ill grace, “I don’t want them killing the flowers that are there.  Okay.”


After further discussion about grass and the condition of the museum, Browder observed, “This is, you know, as far as our town goes, this is the weekend.  The flower bed in front of the civic center needs to be done before this week.”


“We’re working as hard as we can on everything we’ve done this week—” Plunk began.


“I understand,” Browder interrupted.  “I understand that, Paul.  Don’t misunderstand me.  I’m not complaining at all.  I’m just saying that whether it’s lack of manpower or whatever, things like that, especially in that area of town, need to be taken care of before this week.”


Garrison joined in on the criticism. “The ‘Welcome to Adamsville’ sign.  Is Mr. Lipford through putting whatever he was going to put there?  If he is, we still need more….  I seen Mr. Jeff Lipford out there.  He’s put a little something, but—”


“He put some dusty miller out there,” Norris said, “and I saw some little small red flowers.  I don’t know what they are.  I think they’re—”


“Well,” Garrison complained, “they’re not being watered, so how are they going to live?”


“It’s supposed to rain tomorrow,” Morris offered, helpfully.


“Well,” Garrison continued to complain, “I just, it’s kind of a pitiful situation.  Coming into town.  As you said, right now’s our time.  We’ve got all these people coming into town, between six and eight thousand people.  They should be done, and we’ve got a lot of games going on, tournaments.”


Norris said, “That’s the reason she [Norris’s wife, Sarah] came a month ago—”


“I know, I know it,” Garrison responded.  “But Mr. Lipford’s not done enough on the signs.  If he got the contract, that’s not good enough on the signs.  I’m just saying that, and I’m sure Sarah would agree.”


* * *


“Next thing is ‘Charter,’” Mayor Morris read, broaching the most serious subject of the evening.  “I put that on there [on the agenda].  I’m very disturbed by this commission sending the charter changes to Nashville, to get the charter changed, without me even knowing about it.  I’m the mayor, or supposed to be, and I’m supposed to sign off on everything.  Checks, sometimes I sign checks that I don’t want to sign, but y’all vote to pay these people and I sign the checks.  But, now, I think y’all have went over your authority by working up this charter and rushing it to Nashville to get it in this year’s legislature.  And I’m very disturbed about it.  I think you’ve usurped the charter by doing this.  It was not brought before the full city commission to be voted on to send it up there.  And y’all, I think you just took your authority just a little too far this time.  And I’m going to let Mr., legal man, here, tell you what we have discussed today.  We’ve talked two or three times today.”


Garrison made a noise and waved her hand, but Morris said, “Let him [Seaton] speak.”


But Garrison persisted.  “I just want to say something that you may not know about, okay?  May I say that first?  And I’m not trying to fuss.  But the mayor, Mike Norris, Jeff Browder and myself were all here at a meeting with Ronnie Neill, and that day the mayor agreed to all the changes that were going to be put in [Morris shook his head], verbally.  We all heard him here.  Frank Lacey said that he agreed, whatever we all agreed upon, and the mayor was in that, too.  I mean, I just wanted to say that just on our behalf, before you [Seaton] just come down and see you hear both sides of the story.”


Mayor Morris responded.  “The last time that I was in on this we went through the charter, and some said ‘I don’t like this,’ some said ‘I don’t like that.’  I said, ‘What you need to do is you go home, you write down what you like, everybody writes down what they see.’  And that’s the last thing I knew about that thing, ‘til I heard it from Nashville that y’all had sent it up there to get it changed.”


“Well,” Lacey acknowledged softly, “we shouldn’t have sent it without the mayor knowing.”


Garrison then turned to Lacey. “You were agreeing, you, you, you sent it Frank.  You knew it was going up there.”


“And I said we shouldn’t have,” Lacey repeated.


“Well,” Garrison persisted, “he agreed upon it that day—”


“No I did not,” Morris said.


Garrison then turned to the two remaining commissioners for support.  “Mike Norris and Jeff, would y’all please—”


“Well,” Browder responded, “I’d have to say, ‘without you knowing it’ I think is not entirely true statement.  I mean, we had two meetings on this, everybody was made aware of it, it was plainly posted.  As far as not knowing it, I’d have to disagree with you [Mayor Morris].”


“I didn’t know that y’all had sent it to Nashville,” Morris said.


“Were you not given an opportunity to sign?” Norris asked.


“No,” Morris responded.  “No, sir.”


“Was he not given an opportunity—” Norris said to Thrasher.


“No, sir,” Morris repeated.


“You knew, though—” Garrison began petulantly, only to be drowned out by several unintelligible words from Thrasher.


Mayor Morris continued.  “What I’m saying is, that the last time that I knew anything about this charter was when we agreed to come back, and we would all discuss it and put it together.  And then the next thing I know, they call me from Nashville, it’s up there.”


“No,” Garrison insisted.  “It was all in here that day, Mayor you agreed, we all made our changes and said, and then Frank said he would agree that whatever we thought was right, and you said—”


“Well, now,” Browder interjected, “that was before we had the last meeting.”


“The last meeting that he was in here on, that’s what he said,” Garrison insisted.


“I did not,” Morris said.


“Then you had a meeting after,” Thrasher observed.


“And then you had a meeting after that, too,” Garrison admitted, “but, yeah, he told Ronnie Neill—”


Browder observed, “The meeting that Frank said that he would agree with, that was before we had the last meeting with Ronnie.”


“Okay,” Garrison said.  “Well—”


Mayor Morris interrupted.  “I think that y’all just went too far on this, now.”


“Well,” Norris asked, “what would you like to do, Mayor?”


Morris responded, “I want y’all to quit trying to run this city and leave me plumb out of it.  [Turns to Seaton.]  Now, what did you find out today?”


“Well,” Seaton began, “I learned Friday that the charter had been sent to Nashville, and that was the first I’ve heard about it, and I, in my mind that was a pretty significant event, and I learned that it was the mayor’s position that after that had happened without him having any knowledge of it, and I thought that was a rather significant event, so I took it upon myself, and the mayor asked me to look into it and make my own judgment about what had happened.  And I talked with Terry a little, and Ronnie Neill, and it sounds to me like that that meeting took place on the Thursday after the last city commission meeting.  I remember there being a long discussion about when to schedule the next meeting about the charter.  It’s my understanding that Tommy was at that meeting.  That’s what Ronnie Neill says, and that’s what the Mayor says.  And I think the mayor’s position is, he left that meeting thinking that there would be additional discussion about these proposed changes and, I suppose, a vote.  I understand Frank was not at that meeting.  I also talked to Frank today.  He’s by the phone at the bank all the time, and I can call him when I have things on my mind like this.  I think that probably Terry and Ronnie Neill picked up on the fact that if this was going to get to legislature during this term that it had to happen quickly.  I think, based on the discussions I had with different people, that Ronnie Neill took it upon himself, probably, maybe with, at Terry’s direction, to get this charter in a final form, and that happened, and it was circulated for everyone’s signature, I understand, maybe while Tommy was on his cruise.  It’s the mayor’s position that it wasn’t presented to him, and I have a problem with that.  I think that should not have happened.  If anybody wants to take that as criticism, they can.  Now, again, as I learned all this, it appeared to me to be a significant issue.  I also had a little problem, there was, after that meeting last Monday night, or last month, on Monday night, the next morning a little sign, evidently was posted at city hall saying that the commission would meet again on Thursday to discuss the charter.  Or regarding the charter, I don’t remember the exact language.  Certainly didn’t indicate any vote would be taken, and I don’t think the vote was taken.  And that bothers me a little.  It doesn’t bother Ronnie Neill, and I respect his opinion about these things.  He knows more about this area of the law than I do.  It doesn’t bother Ronnie.  His position about it is that Randy Rinks can present proposed legislation without formal action, or any action, by this commission, regarding a charter, and that, in effect, Randy Rinks was told by letter, I guess, some document, and I’ve not seen that document, that these are the changes that the commission was proposing.  And I, you know, in my mind, he assumed there was a vote.  He would assume the rules were followed.  And, again, Ronnie Neill is comfortable with what happened.  I don’t know that Ronnie would say he was comfortable with the mayor being left out.  But, one thing that’s very important—  I don’t want this issue to be blown out of proportion, because it’s important that the proposed changes to the charter include the same provision that’s in the old charter with regard to the adoption of a new charter, and that is that it is accepted and approved by the legislature that this commission has to pass it by a two-thirds majority, which would be four out of five, within, I believe, sixty days of when it passes.  So if—”


Thrasher interrupted. “It has to be done twice.”


Seaton continued.  “It has to be, well, okay.  So these changes in the charter are not going to happen without there being an open discussion, with the public having full opportunity to be heard, with all the members of this commission having a full opportunity to say what they want to say about it.  So, again, I don’t want the effect of what’s happened to be blown out of proportion.  No real harm has been done, and I don’t know, I, again, I don’t know, Ronnie Neill is comfortable with the way it was handled.  I respect his opinion.  I’m not, but no real harm’s been done.  I think, in defense, Mayor— [pause to change the tape, so I took the opportunity to change the batteries and the first video ends here—subsequent numbering will be from second video, once it starts up]  In the defense of all the commissioners and Terry, they were depending on Ronnie Neill, the expert, to lead them through this process, and I’m not sitting here saying anybody intentionally did anything wrong with regard to this process, perhaps with the exception of you [Mayor] not being, of there not being the proper communication, and you not being informed like you should have been as to what had happened.  And that’s not a legal problem.  That’s another problem that, hopefully, there’ll be improvement made on.  That’s my report.”


“Well,” Mayor Morris added, “I want to put one more thing in there.  I’ve asked him to check in on malfeasance and misfeasance.  Whether he did or not, I don’t know.  If nobody don’t know what it is, I’ve got a dictionary right here.  I don’t know what it is.  I’ve read it, but I forget.  But the next time this happens, I’m going to sock you with a charge on malfeasance and misfeasance.  I’m just giving you, I’m not threatening you, I’m just telling you what I’m going to do.  Because you’ve usurped the charter, from what you’ve done.  That’s all I’ve got to say.”


“Well,” Norris observed, sarcastically, “that improves the working relationship.”


“Well, y’all ain’t tried to improve it,” Morris responded.


“We thought we were all on it, with Ronnie Neill,” Garrison said.


“Well,” Morris said with some heat, “Ronnie Neill told two different things.  I ain’t got no use for anybody that tells two different things.”


“Wooo!” Garrison said in the mocking tone affected by smart aleck third-graders.


“Make a motion we adjourn,” Lacey said.


“I think we need to.  Quickly—” Garrsion began


“I do, too,” Norris agreed


“—before the mayor gets—” Garrison continued, but the balance of her school yard taunt was unintelligible.


Morris, however, pointed out that there was still one item left on the printed agenda: “F&M Consulting Bill.”


Norris observedt that “We’ve already hashed this over once before, and did we not agree to not pay it?”  He then made a motion that the $3,500 bill not be paid.  Garrison seconded the motion, then Lacey asked for particulars and the matter was once again reviewed.  Browder asked Seaton if the statute of limitations had not run, and Seaton said that he thought it had.  Seaton also said that it appeared to him that there had been no bill submitted until last year, “when the subsequent plant grant was approved, and the city undertook to move forward with it.”  When the vote was finally taken, Garrison, Browder and Norris voted not to pay the bill, and Morris and Lacey voted to pay it.


And then finally, FINALLY, the meeting was adjourned.

 

Town Board Meeting

21 April 2008

It was too good to last, and it didn't.  The peace and comity (relatively speaking, of course) of recent Adamsville town board meetings had completely evaporated by the end of the April meeting, the low-lights of which were probably Commissioner Mike Norris's dismissal of Tommy Morris as "just an honorary mayor" and Morris's own ordering of Town Manager Terry Thrasher to clear out his office by the next day.  Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?

* * *

The April meeting of the Adamsville city commission began innocently enough, with the unanimous approval of the minutes of the March meeting (on a motion by Frank Lacey, seconded by Jeff Browder), of the financial report (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Mike Norris), and of the other reports (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Browder).

The first item of old business related to the now quite familiar property on Hwy 64 West.  Town Manager Terry Thrasher reported that the town had received three appraisals on the property.  "One appraised it between ten and twelve thousand, one appraised it at seventeen thousand, and one appraised it at twenty thousand."  Only one of the appraisals ($17,000) was in writing, and that appraiser "said that property was questionable because of the lack of sewer availability."

After considerable discussion about options for providing sewer services for the property and about how to go about putting the property up for sale, Lacey eventually made a motion that the town put the property up for sale for $17,000, "as is."  Dwana Garrison asked if the town would have to pay a realtor's commission out of the $17,000, or "are we just going to put a sign up there that says 'For Sale by the City of Adamsville?"

"You don't have to list it," Norris observed.  "You can put a sign out there and send a letter to all the realtors and say, 'This property is for sale, you're more than welcome to show it.  This is what we want, net.  If you want something out of it, put that on top of it.'  Or tell the realtor to let the buyer pay his commission.  It's done all the time.  But I'd say that you ought to get something in writing, somewhere, about the sewage thing.  Because they're going to ask you that."

Lacey pointed out that "17,000 will be a deal for the land," and anyone putting a "viable business" on that property could best use the money saved to put in a sewer system appropriate to that business, rather than have the town put in a system that might not be suitable for the ultimate purchaser. 

Browder agreed. "We can put it up for sale and get someone in there, and then we can cross that bridge when we get to it."

After some further discussion, Browder seconded Lacey's motion to offer the property for sale at $17,000 "as is," and the motion carried unanimously.

* * *

The next item of old business, "Contractor Agreement," was dealt with swiftly, with town attorney Ken Seaton telling the commission that he will have the matter taken care of the next day.

"Fireworks," the Mayor Tommy Morris then intoned.

Thrasher informed the commissioners that he had received a package of information from the Tennessee Municipal League (TML), the thrust of which was that the best course for the town to take would be to contract out the fireworks displays at various functions, as the town did the previous year.  Garrison volunteered the information that the town had obtained a five million dollar insurance policy, and attorney Seaton said that he was satisfied with the fireworks arrangements.

* * *

Next up was a rehash of the dog situation in Adamsville.  Thrasher advised that the town would not be picking up any dogs, but would instead be citing dog owners in to court.  Norris said that all the town needed to do is enforce the already existing ordinance.  Mayor Morris was not so hopeful, saying that the problem had been around since he first came into public office and would go on forever.

Commissioner Browder then explained why he had brought the issue up in the first place, saying that he was concerned about dogs that didn't belong to anybody—"wild dogs—that's the animals that I was concerned with when all this was brought up.  I wasn't concerned with anybody's animal that they even halfway claim or halfway take care of.  It's those animals that run, three or four at a whack all over town, and if you don't see them, you're not looking."  He pointed out that the town might actually face some legal liability if someone was injured by a dog as a result of the town not enforcing an existing ordinance.

Further discussion ensued, then Lacey said, "This is what I'd like to do now.  I'd like to make a motion that we require all dogs in Adamsville to be registered, and have a tag, and if you see a dog that is not registered and he doesn't have a tag, then that dog is subject to being picked up and sent out, whatever."

"I think we've already got that," Mayor Morris observed.  Thrasher agreed, saying, "We've got that in the books and it was run in the paper.  What you're making a motion is, if we see a dog like the two up there, we pick them up and carry them to Corinth."

Norris observed that "we've got to use a little common sense," and Browder pointed out that what was contemplated was a "complaints only" policy.  That is, that the only dogs that would be picked up were those about which specific complaints had been made to town authorities.

Lacey's motion, seconded by Norris, passed unanimously.

* * *

The next quarter hour or so was spent discussing the town's long-range plans.

"We're talking about long-range updates on water, gas and sewer," Thrasher explained.  "The Adamsville water department, without replacing a lot of in-ground lines, like that on Shiloh Road, down Main Street, places like that, there's somewhere around three hundred, three hundred and fifty thousand dollars worth of work needs doing—"

Thrasher then looked at utility director Paul Wallace Plunk, who responded, "I've got that up through 2015."

"Paul has looked at it all out to 2015," Thrasher continued.  "In the next six or seven years we need to spend about three hundred and fifty thousand on the water department, and that's not replacing old lines, like the one through Main Street, or any of these others.  But he's getting some more figures together, so I just wanted y'all to know they're working on this.  They haven't finished it yet."

Plunk observed that "It's very hard to get some of these figures, because you call these people and you ask them to give you a price on, like a new lift station, 'Okay, I'll get back with you.'  Well, you wait and you wait and they don't get back with you, and you call them again.  And it just takes time to put all these figures together."

"And of course," Browder added, "it would be one price in 2010, and another in 2015."

"Well," Thrasher said, "what they do, too, is they know that you're not ready to buy this, so they don't get in a big hurry."

"Well, I would think we are ready to buy this," Lacey

"I would, too," Norris agreed.

Lacey continued.  "Maybe we need to hire an engineering firm to come in here and assess it and get us, you know, what they think it is, because in my opinion this is a pending disaster."

"Well, you remember what was said at the meeting?" Norris said, referring to the long-range planning meeting the commissioners had had with MTAS's Ronnie Neill.  "You know, we can't make any kind of long range plans until the utilities are brought up to date."

"Amen," Garrison chimed in.

"You don't have what you need in several places," Norris continued.  "And Neill agreed with that.  And so, until we get that done, there's no use of doing much else.  And the faster that we can do it— I'm like Frank.  I mean, we are, we do need to be ready to do that.  Because Toyota is coming."

"Well," Thrasher said, "that gives us a start, at least."

After some further discussion about the need to upgrade systems so that Adamsville can advance, Norris said, "What we talked about in the long range planning meeting too, was that, in addition to beginning to get prepared for whatever might happen industry-wise, is that you're going to have people coming in that are going to want places to live.  You've got to have the proper utilities for them.  The industry, that's one of the first questions they're going to ask you.  Not only for their plants, but, you know, what kind of facilities have you got for the people that's going to need to move here."

"So, if we're needing to do this," Garrison said, "looks like to me, then, that we need to do it."

Lacey asks whether the board should make some decisions before hiring an engineering firm, or should hire an engineering firm before making any decisions.

"You need to hire an engineering firm first," Plunk said.

"When he gets through with this," Thrasher said, referring to Plunk's preliminary proposal, "—and he's done a yeoman's job on it—we can't spend the money until … the people with the state of Tennessee that's over our, keep us toeing the line on the water, has to have an engineer's approval before we can do any of this.  We cannot go out here and buy a lift station and put it in without their coming and checking it and making sure we're doing it the way they want it done.  So, yeah, we need to hire an engineer at some point."

"I feel like we're at that point," Lacey repeated.  "Water and sewer.  I would like to see us do it.  I mean, find somebody that can come in here and, you know, if they can find a grant, fine.  If they can't find a grant, by golly we need to suck up and get this done."

"So, that's what I was just saying a while ago," Garrison said.  "We've got thing we need to do.  We've got to do it, do we not?"

After some further discussion Lacey said, "I want to make a motion that we hire an engineering firm to do the preliminary work, with the understanding that if we, that we pay them for the preliminary work, and if we use their planning we'll pay them for their long-range work, so there'll be no confusion there, to look into our water and sewer needs, right now, in the City of Adamsville."

Norris seconded the motion, after which Lacey asked Plunk, "Is that the right motion to make, Paul?  Does that cover what we need to get done?"

Plunk said that it did, and then added, "It would be good if you have the same firm that does water, waste water too, instead of hiring one for water and one for waste water."

"And," Browder said, "I guess we're taking into consideration all the stuff that's already, wheels are already spinning on, too."

Thrasher observed, "You got Delta Regional Grant, CBDG grant, that's what, there's not going to be another grant come down the pike, until we get through with the ones we've already got.  There's no grant money available to do any of this."

Mayor Morris observed, "I hope y'all are not going to be surprised when you get an estimate on, this is what this upgrade will be.  It's going to be fifteen, eighteen million dollars."

The motion then passed on a unanimous roll call vote.

* * *

The next twenty minutes were spent in an inconclusive discussion of the town's website.

"Did all of you read this, right here?" Norris asked, holding up a proposal he had circulated to the board members.  "We need to revamp our website.  Is everybody in agreement with that?"

"What's wrong with it?" asked Mayor Morris.

"Well," Norris replied, "it's just very much out of date.  I've had two people to tell me that.  Professionals.  This [waving the proposal he still held] is a firm that I have, that I found when we went to the seminar last year.  The name of the company is MMA Creative, and they, this is their business, is to create websites that work.  And they do a lot of work with small cities.  Some of their past work— They've been in business since 1990, something like that."

"1991," Garrison supplied, reading from the proposal before her.

Norris continued.  "Examples of their work: Tennessee Meth Prevention Program, this is one of their most significant accomplishments, which was the result of their efforts to develop the first meth prevention campaign, in 2003, for the Upper Cumberland Region.  This was an award-winning program that they have.  Another one was the Cumberland Business Journal.  I'll let you, you should all read this, I guess.  They did some work for the governor here in the state of Tennessee in his last campaign.  Frank, you might want to take a look at that.  And also, My Hometown Web Module, this is a particularly good situation, here.  It's, briefly, it's an actual video that runs on your website, and there are different actual individuals in your community that are interviewed online, in video, and they're stating why they like living in your community.  Hardin County is doing that on their website.  And so, the reason that I'm wanted to bring this up is because of what I learned last year, and it's, I'm sure you're all more and more aware of it.  You have to be.  One of the statements that's been brought up to me, here of recent, is that close to eighty percent, eighty percent of everyone that plans vacations does it on the internet.  They're looking for places to go, and that's what they look at, is the website of the different communities where they plan to travel.  Industry, that's one of the major, initial steps that they take in trying to determine where they might locate an industry.  This is through the websites with counties, or communities, and that sort of thing.  So, you know, we need to be prepared for that, and we're just not.  So, the proposal that this particular company has, and I would, I mean, it's not going to be cheap, but it's not going to be just astronomical.  They have a four-step program that, to where they, their personal interview here, with our people here, to determine what needs to be in that website.  The design of it, they take care of the design of it.  Then there's the development, or the implementation of the programming and support the objectives such as discovery and design, and then the deployment of the website.  And this, according to them and their estimate, will take some seventy hours to do this stuff.  And their estimate is $6,300.  So, I would urge us to do this."

"What do we pay now?" Morris asked.

"We don't pay anything now," Norris said.

"Then why do we want to change?" Morris asked.

"Well," Norris replied, "we don't have a good one right now."

"What?" the mayor asked.

"We don't have a very user-friendly one right now," Lacey responded.

"You can't find anything, now," Norris amplified, "on what we have now."

"Well," Lacey continued, "if you explore internet websites, to do things, you want something that jumps out at you, a banner on there, advertisements, upcoming events, things like that, places to eat.  And ours does none of that.  Ours basically has his [Thrasher's] big face on it, and that's about it.  [Crosstalk]  And it needs to invite you, not just to this town, but our area.  But it also needs to have demographics on there, and stuff, what kind of labor force we have, how many people live here, you know, what kind of tax base we have.  Things like that."

Garrison 5253: "Well, we'd have to feed them that information, wouldn't we?"

After further discussion of the present website and how it isn't really being maintained, Garrison said, "I agree that we need to update ours, and I agree we need a new one, but, you know, I know, because I have a website, and it probably tells more about the city and stuff than the city does itself.  But you're got to have a good creator, that's creating that website, and you know that we feed them the information.  I just think, I just think we could get it done for less, and still get a good website, is what I'm saying.   And one thing I want to add is, we just have this one price.  Why not spend this month in getting, see if we can get two or three other companies to give us a price on it.  Because this is nowhere near what we've had to pay.  In five years."

"More, or less?" Lacey asked.

"This is more," Garrison replied.  "And we get ours updated.  We pay as we kind of go, as far as updating, depending on how much we need to tell, like during festival time and first of the year time, and then it slows down towards the middle of the year, toward the late of the year, we start updating stuff—"

"Who does yours?" Norris asked.

Garrison explained that her website was maintained by Independent Appeal reporter Russell Ingle, who then explained that plans were in the works for the McNairy County Chamber of Commerce to provide assistance to municipalities in the county in setting up and maintaining their websites, which could be done at considerably less than the $6,300 cost of the proposal Norris had submitted.

"We already donate to the Chamber," Mayor Morris observed.  "Would we not already be on there automatically?"

After some crosstalk, Ingle said, "There's still things to be discussed and worked out.  All I know is that will happen.  It won't be anything as far as cost like that."

"So," Garrison said, trying to sum up, "you're saying the possibility, my understanding, Mayor, is that through the Chamber, the Chamber is going to offer to help the city, it won't be near as costly as what this cost here will be.  But they'll be able to do it.  Now since we're a member of the Chamber, it won't be totally free, but it won't be this price here, either.  That's what he's saying."

Thrasher then interjected another consideration.  "Let me throw an interesting bit of information that came out last week.  House Bill 2717/Senate Bill 2734 is on the agenda for this legislation, requires each municipality and county to post its charter of incorporation on the website by January, on a website, or its website, by two thousand and nine— the first of the year.  And if they don't do it, you've got the, 'any county that does not will be required to post it on the Secretary of State's web.'  Which means you could get by with a little reference to Adamsville, but you've got to post it on their website or have your own.  It's going to be mandatory that you have one by January 1.  Now that don't mean it has to be good.  It just means you've got to have one."

"Well," Mayor Morris said, "what do y'all want to do about this website?  We've discussed it quite a bit.  Do you want to wait—"

"Well," Browder spoke up, "I think we need to wait and find out what happens with the Chamber, what's going on, and shop around.  Like I say, I would hope that you could build one more humdinger of a website for $6,300."

"You get what you pay for," Norris said.

"Well," Lacey responded, "you've got to understand what your website should be able to do, to be able to—"

"I understand what the website should be able to do," Norris interjected.

Lacey continued. "You've got to have somebody that can change it, and update off of, when we make policy changes, ordinance changes, they need to go on there, and event stuff, and you can have, I mean, you can actually sell ads on it, I mean, if you wanted to."

Adamsville resident Dan Brown, who was in the audience, then spoke up.  "Let me ask a question, if I could.  I've been on the Adamsville site, and I don't know what I was trying to find out, but I couldn't find out.  And it's not worth a toot, as far as I'm concerned.  But, who is going to put the data, all of the data, back history of Adamsville, and things like that people want to know.  Somebody has that, but, I mean, you may know about getting access to it, and—"

"Well," Norris replied, "that's what a good, a good designer will make it user friendly.  Our website is not user friendly."

"No," Brown agreed, "it's not."

Norris continued. "And a good website designer will make them user friendly, where they're very easy to use.  It will also link you to other regional websites, like Tennessee Tourism.  I mean, you can get in there and you can go all the state by linkage.  We need to be linked to Hardin County.  We may be.  I don't think we are, but we need to be linked there, we need to be linked to Corinth.  We need to be linked to Hardeman County.  We need to be linked to Madison County.  You know, all of the regional areas around here that would bring us in as a family, as a regional family.  We don't have that right now, and we've got to begin to do that."

Discussion then continued about getting other bids and about the various costs involved in creating and maintaining a website, during which Norris continues to advocate for his firm.

Finally, Lacey said "I would like to make a motion that we leave this to be looked at some local talent, and revisit this … next month.  And if we don't have any local talent that can give us what we want, then we consider this one right here."

After a bit more discussion the matter was dropped with no action being taken on either Norris's proposal or Lacey's motion.

* * *

The next ten minutes were spent in an inconclusive discussion of what should be the town's involvement in and expenditure toward the installation of "Utilities in Subdivisions," which ended with no vote and no decision, then Mayor Morris moved on to the next agenda item, "Summer Help—School Kids," discussion on which ranged far afield and led to an acrimonious exchange between Mayor Morris and Commissioner Norris.

"Just for informational purposes," Thrasher began, "last year we tried this.  We did not have to contract out any mowing, because we had a couple of kids that would work a little bit.  And that's because we posted an ad on the bulletin board at Adamsville Junior-Senior High School.  I have not check to see how many people we've got, but we will get three or four more like we got last year, and we'll keep everything mowed and trimmed with them and not have to contract it out.  It's cheaper in the long run."

Garrison gave Thrasher some grief about the cemetery not being mowed, and then she changed the subject: "Talking about summer help, Mayor?  It's not school kids, but May, coming up, and June's probably the biggest month at the festival, and May, June and July at the museum.  There's a man that's been there, and he helps, has been giving his, basically worked for free for three years, we need him, we need some extra hours, we need some extra manpower.  And I talked to Terry about it, and Terry just said that I would need to bring it up and talk to everybody here about it, and see.  Fred's willing to do it.  He's even willing to do it for minimum wage.  He already works there, anyway.  He's been giving his, but we need him, we need to be able to pay him some, because I think we're taking advantage of him, and Frank and Mr. Norris and Mr. Browder, I brought that up to y'all that day when we were there at the house and we had that MTAS guy there.  We've got a lot of extra preservation work that we're starting on already right now, and on computer work that's got to be done by a certain time, and that we're filing for grants, and we're needing an extra hand.  He would be able, we could get him for less money than we could anybody else, and it's not every day that he would have to be there, but—"

"Well," Morris said, "I understand he's married to that girl that works there.  That's the reason he's there, ain't it?

Norris then asked about funding. "Well, Dwana, you've got, when it comes to the museum, you've got a $58,000 budget, and you've only, you're almost all the way through the year, you've only used forty-seven thousand of that, and that means you've got $11,000 to use."

"Okay," Garrison replied, "but I have to bring this up, Mike, because they won't do it on their own, he won't let it be done, because she's afraid that the mayor won't like it, or that Terry won't like it and the mayor won't like it, so they told me I had to bring it up here, Mayor, so that's why I'm doing it."

Morris replied, "I think it ought to be, anybody you hire it's got to be brought before me.  That's an everyday deal.  It's got to be brought before me.  According to the charter."

"Why do we have supervisors, then?—" Norris began.

"Why do you have top bosses at jobs?" Morris interjected.

"—They're supposed to be able to do the job," Norris added.

"Why do you have top bosses at jobs?" Morris countered.  "I'm supposed to be the top boss—"

"You're not a top boss," Norris interjected, dismissively.

"Well," Morris replied, "I'm supposed to be."

"You're an honorary mayor," Norris said.

Lacey brought the discussion back to the issue at hand.  "I would make, and I understand what you said about decoration day, it'll be taken care of, and that that's the most important day—unless your child's up there.  And these people need to have somebody they can talk to and say, 'Hey, please.'  Because I don't want to hear about a mother, or having to get somebody [unintelligible] weeds around her child's grave.  I mean, those are the things that tear your heart out.  That's our cemetery, and you see it going down 64."

"It's just an embarrassment to the community," Norris said.  "I'll just be honest with you."

Lacey continued.  "And I, you know, maybe we need to look at out-sourcing it.  I mean, if we don't have the staff to do it, and it's probably cheaper if we out-source it."

"No, Frank," Thrasher disagreed.  "It's cheaper to do it with the summer help.  A whole lot cheaper.  Because when you bid the cemetery, the last two years we bid the yard mowing for the city of Adamsville, no body will bid on the cemetery.  They don't like it, they don't want it.  It scares them to death.  What we try to do is, it looks as ready as it ever does.  We haven't started yet, but I don't think we neglect the cemetery that much—"

"You do, too," Norris disagreed.  "There was leaves, and all along the road there, all winter long, branches and everything else, Terry.  I drive by it every day.  It looks like crap.  An there's stuff laying all over the cemetery.  It just looks like hell."

"Well," Thrasher responded, "you're going to spend a whole lot more money than we've been doing."

"Well," Norris observed, "you ain't got but $1,500 in here for the whole year."

"No, that's—" Thrasher began.

"What is that for?" Norris asked.
 "That's to—what was it we put that in there for?" Thrasher asked Debbie Moffett, of the parks and recreation department.

Moffett replied, "That was to make a sign to show if anybody went to the cemetery, they wouldn't have to come to city hall to find where their loved ones of family members—"

"But that comes under buildings and grounds. That's not part of that," Thrasher said.  "But I'm saying, if we mow that every ten days and do that, we're going to have to have a whole lot of summer help."

"Maybe we need spring help," Lacey remarked.  "Because, I mean, I understand this spring we had a lot of rain, the sun came out, and everything grew up.  I understand that.  And you can't, I mean, that's wonderful.  But, still, maybe we need to hire somebody."

Moffett raised an additional consideration regarding part-time employees. "When you hire a part-time employee at the city, if you hire them and employ them more than ninety days, you've got to make them an offer to make it full time.  But what we're asking right here now maybe is to have a seasonal employee, maybe either April through June, or May through July, and that be it.  That ninety days, he would get paid.  Even the summer-time helpers they do a ninety-day situation there, whereas when their ninety days are up you need to let them go."

Morris brought the discussion back to Garrison's request. "Well, what I was concerned with, Debbie and Dwana, is that would be four out of one family working."

"That's the reason I wouldn't approach it," Moffett said.

"Right," Garrison said.  "That's why she wouldn't approach it, and I used to feel that same way, too, until I found out what all he's been doing and how long he's been doing it free already, and he's the cheapest help that we could get this summer through the seasonal, you know.  We could hire him for minimum wage where we couldn't somebody else."

"And that family does a good job," added Town Recorder Jimmie Ann Burks.

"And they work hard in there," Garrison continued.

Mayor Morris replied, "I understand that, but it's just—"

"And he donates his time, Tommy," Garrison interrupted.  "Three years of donated time, I think that shows a little bit of respect, too.  I used to didn't think that I would want that to happen, but."

After still further discussion Lacey said that if the manager of the museum "can deal with it, I don't have a problem with it.  If it's in the budget."

"For the season," Garrison said.  "And that's what we're asking.  And that's what we're asking, Mayor, too.

"Well," Morris finally said, "I'll go along with it, but I'm against it."

* * *

Mayor Morris then moved to what proved to be the most contentious issue of the night: "Checks signed at City Hall," he read from the agenda.

"Talking with MTAS," Thrasher began, "Mr. Neill found out that we took a lot of checks out of this building and carried them down for you to sign, and his suggestion was that we didn't do that.  The checks ought to stay inside the city hall."

"Why?" Morris asked.

"And at the last meeting that we had," Thrasher continued, "it was either a planning meeting here or the planning meeting at Pickwick, this group of people okayed that, and said start doing it.  So the last time, it just so happened that you [Morris] came by here every time we needed checks signed until this past pay period.  And I said something about come by and sign the checks, and you said 'carry them down and put them in my pickup seat.'  And I said I'm not supposed to do that, you said 'Do it anyway,' and I did.  And we got payroll signed."

"I've done it ever since I've been here," Morris said.  "You've brought them ever since I've been here."

"I know it," Thrasher acknowledged.  "But I didn't know that MTAS frowned on that."

"I think where we miss the boat on this," Lacey interjected, "is, aren't checks done the same time every week?"

"Payroll is," Thrasher confirmed.

Lacey 0324: "I don't see a problem with knowing that at 8:00 o'clock on Friday morning, Tommy, we will have payroll ready for you to come by and sign, or Frank, for that matter, if he's out of town….  That's not a problem.  If I came by at eight and they were not ready, then I would obviously ask that you bring them to me….   Now, if you set a specific time up to have checks here to be signed, I don't think anyone would have a problem with coming by here and signing them.  I think it's very dangerous to take any kind of loose material outside the building, because of accidents—"

"People stealing," Garrison suggested.

"You've got to think about identity theft, too," Browder added.

"I'm going to tell you something," Garrison said, her voice rising.  "If we're laying checks, checks need to be signed, and whether it's the Mayor's truck, Paul Wallace's truck, your truck, or my truck, that don't need to be happening.  Now that's ridiculous.  That's ridiculous, like I said, identity theft and everything that goes on today, that needs to be stopped right now and right here.  If y'all are not going to, surely y'all are going to back me up on that."

"I don't think it needs to be done—" Browder began, before being cut off by Mayor Morris.

"Well," Morris said, "I'm going to tell you what, if I'm going to sign them up here, I want my office back, right over there [points to Thrasher's office], and I want them laying on that desk."

"Wait a minute—" Garrison started, but Morris ignored her.

"That's my office," he said.  "It was the mayor's office.  I let him use it—"

"Whoa," Thrasher said.  "Wait a minute.  You had the office down there—"

"No," Morris interrupted, "that wasn't my office out there.  Y'all put me in there.  I want that one back.  It's been the mayor's office.  It was built for the mayor's office, and I want you out of there tomorrow."

"Frank?" Garrison said, as though Lacey was the mayor's keeper, "Can you not do anything?"

"What am I supposed to do?" Lacey asked.

After a generally unintelligible exchange between Garrison and Lacey, during which Garrison said "but you said that you would handle this," Thrasher reentered the conversation, saying to Mayor Morris, "I talked to you about it, and you said, 'I don't need it.  Let him have it.'"

"I didn't need it," Morris replied.

At last, town attorney Seaton lost patience and said, "Have a motion and move on to something else."

Garrison then said, "I make a motion that we all, that checks have to be signed here at city hall.  Y'all will have to have them at a certain time, and it has to be that the mayor knows when that time is set, and the vice-mayor, so if one, if the mayor can't be here, then the vice-mayor take care of it.  We don't, we need to be in motion, we don't take checks outside this building and lay them in somebody's truck, just for them to be signed or looked at later or to be stolen.  I mean, that right there puts a great liability on the city, leaving a bunch of checks unsigned, they can get there and forge whatever, and—"

"Amen," Norris said.  "Is that a motion?"  He then seconded it.

In the discussion that followed Lacey observed, "I think you have to be very careful when you say don't take checks out of the building, because obviously—"

"Unsigned," Garrison interrupted.

"Signed or unsigned," Lacey continued.  "And I agree completely.  Any normal business would have checks available at a certain time to be signed.  That's common.  That's not a problem.  And I don't think any normal business would take checks all over the town to get them signed.  However, I, this is what I would encourage the city to look very seriously, look into direct deposit.  Electronic fund check deposit can save you, number one, it can save you all this problem that we're talking about, because the money's automatically put into an account, wherever you want it to be put.  Everything, it doesn't cost the city any, matter of fact, it would save the city money.  So, you know, in dealing with this, even, at some point in time that's going to be, that could be the very next step we look at.  But checks definitely should be scheduled and you should know when they are going to be ready.  And so, now, as far as what office is going to be where or whatever, that's not, I mean, I'm not involved."

"I'm not involved in that office—" Garrison began.

"All right," Thrasher interrupted, "I'm going to move out of that office for this man to come up here twice a week and sign checks for an hour or—"

"I tell you," Morris interrupted, "I may just move in up here, you don't know.  It's my office."

"Your office is down there," Thrasher said, pointing down the hall.

"No it ain't," Morris asserted.

"It was," Thrasher replied.

"Well," Morris responded, "you put me down there."

"No, I didn't put you down there—" Thrasher began, before his words were drowned out by crosstalk.

"Let's get on with this meeting tonight," Morris finally said, "and then maybe we can work out something, but, all right.  Checks to be signed.  I'll sign the checks up here at the office, but they'd better be here at a certain time. But you know [pointing at Thrasher] you brought me them checks nearly at dinnertime on Friday for me to sign.  If they're not going to be here nearly at dinnertime for me to sign, so I will not come up here nearly at dinnertime and sign them."

"We will set up a time schedule and they will be there," Thrasher said.

"I try to work with y'all every way in the world, and I don't raise no Cain—" Morris said, and when the vote was finally taken on Garrison's motion Mayor Morris cast the lone "no" vote.

* * *

"Pilot lights," Mayor Morris said, reading from the agenda.

"We've got a directive from our insurance carrier, TML," Thrasher said, "that we need to stop lighting pilot lights.  That's going to go down hard, because we put an ad in the paper about October 1, and have two or three boys out here that light pilot lights.  But they say our liability is just as bad for lighting pilot lights as it is if you worked on the appliance itself.  So, I'm just saying that we've got to put this in our think tank and be ready to advertise, because that's been going on for years and years and years in Adamsville."

"If you can't do it," Norris observed, "you can't do it."

After some discussion, town attorney Seaton said that he would look into it.

"Next," Mayor Morris said, "Planning Commission Recommendations.  Terry."

Thrasher said "We've got two things that the planning commission recommended to the city commission, and that's the amendment to address apartments in the B-1 district.  If you will remember, it is not legal to live in an apartment in the B-2 district, which goes from the Methodist Church to Jimmy Max Pettigrew's drugstore.  And they are making a recommendation, planning is, that the city commission adopt this, that you can live in an apartment anywhere in the B-1 area, which would be up and down 64 Highway."

"Bring us something in writing," Norris suggested, "and then we can talk about it."

"All right, let's do that," Thrasher agreed.  "We've got this change in the sign ordinance, but we might, we can just let this go until next month so that we can get this typed up.  We're likely to get into a long discussion."

"Yeah," Mayor Morris said, "we've been here a long time."

"We've got three more things we need to talk about," Norris said.

"I know," Thrasher responded.  "Yeah, I've got one that probably will, talking about your charter.  I've got some dates from Ronnie Neill."

"When was this put on the agenda?" Mayor Morris asked.

"I didn't get them until—" Thrasher began.

Norris interrupted. "Well, I thought we were supposed to have met before last week—"

"Thursday," Thrasher added, helpfully.

"You know," Norris continued, "we didn't get together, and so I made some recommendations and it's stuff that's really important.  Go ahead, Terry."

"I've just got some dates for Ronnie Neill to come down—" Thrasher began, only to be interrupted by the mayor, speaking to Norris.

"No," Morris said, referring to Norris's having told Thrasher to go ahead.  "I control this.  From now on, let's try to not add a lot of stuff to the agenda, if it's not on here."

"Well," Norris responded, "if you'd have been here Friday, or Thursday, then you'd have known that, Mayor."

"Well, wasn't nobody else here Friday, was there?" the mayor asked.  In fact, Norris was the only commissioner to show up for the Thursday working session.

"I was," Norris responded.  "He [Thrasher] was, too."

"I'm not coming to extra meetings like that," Morris declared.

"Well," Norris responded, "you don't really have any say-so."

"Yes, I do," Morris replied.

"No you don't," Norris responded, with equal petulance.

Morris then turned to Seaton and asked, "What controls have I got over this meeting?"

"Tommy," Seaton replied wearily, "I don't know.  Just let Terry go ahead and say what he wants to say."

"Well, if it's going to take an hour I don't want," Morris responded.

"Well, maybe it won't," Seaton said, "if we'll be quiet and let him—"

"Go ahead," Morris said to Thrasher, abruptly.

There then followed a tedious discussion about when the commission should meet with Ronnie Neill to discuss changes to the charter, which concluded five minutes later with a unanimous vote (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Norris) to hold the meeting at 6:30 on Thursday, April 24.

* * *

Sarah Norris then presented estimates and recommendation for flowers at welcome signs and along Main Street and around the library, which produced contentious discussion, but no vote.

Lacey then made a motion that a committee, consisting of the mayor, the town manager, one commissioner, and Jimmie Ann Burks, be appointed to interview and select a replacement for Town Recorder Burks, who will be retiring on September 1.  Garrison volunteered to serve on the selection committee, and Lacey's motion, seconded by Norris, passed unanimously.

Lacey also made "a motion that we request a meeting with the industrial development board at their earliest convenience to discuss signage and upkeep at the Adamsville Industrial Park."  Norris seconded the motion, and the meeting was set for 6:30 p.m., before the regular May board meeting.

Garrison then suggested that the time for the working sessions be changed from 5:00 p.m. to noon on the Thursday before the regular monthly meetings, and the change was agreed to without a vote.

The meeting finally ended with the announcement of some good news by Mike Norris. "We did get the last temporary easement signature that we needed today, so we can now proceed.  We've got to come back to every one of them now to get a permanent thing signed, so we can record it, that has to do with the easement.  And once we get that done, then we can send this to TDOT to get approval, and then begin the bids."

And on that note, the marathon two-hour April meeting of the Adamsville town board was finally adjourned, on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Norris.

 

  

Town Board Meeting

17 March 2008

For a while it looked as though the March meeting of the Adamsville Town Board would have to be rescheduled for want of a quorum.  Dwana Garrison was ill and could not attend, Frank Lacey was out of town at the funeral of a relative, and Jeff Browder was late getting back into town from a trip, leaving only Mayor Tommy Morris and Commissioner Mike Norris at the table until Jeff Browder arrived at about 7:10 p.m.

After Browder's arrival, though, matters proceeded briskly, with Norris and Browder, as the only commissioners present, either making or seconding every motion for the evening.  The minutes were unanimously approved (on a motion by Norris, seconded by Browder), as was the financial report (on a motion by Norris, seconded by Browder), and the remaining reports were collectively approved by a unanimous vote (again, on a motion by Norris, seconded by Browder). 

 

Mayor Morris then turned to the first item of Old Business: Dogs. 

 

City Manager Terry Thrasher said that he had paid a visit to the Corinth animal Shelter.  "They will handle our dogs for $35 per dog, and the manager will order us the equipment we need.  It will cost about three hundred, maybe three-fifty.  If we're going to do this, I think we need to run ads in the Independent Appeal for at least two weeks, explaining our dog policy, which you've got a copy in your package of, and inform the public that we will respond to complaints only.  Not just a dog in the yard.  If they've been bitten, or a dog has tinkled on their flower bed, or killed their cat, or something.  When we get a complaint, an officer, either a police officer or the codes officer, will go to the owner and explain the procedure.  On the second complaint the owner will be ticketed, come to city court, pay the fine plus court costs.  The third complaint will be cause for the dog to be picked up.  And try to pick the dog up early enough in the day that it can be carried to the Corinth shelter between 8:00 a.m. and 4:00 p.m.  Once the dog has been turned over to the Corinth shelter, they will set the price for it to be reclaimed by the owner.  So, now, that's where we are.  They will handle them.  That is the price.  It will cost us three or four hundred dollars for equipment, then we run ads is the paper." 

 

Browder made a motion to approve Thrasher's proposal, which Norris seconded.  In the discussion that followed, City Attorney Ken Seaton expressed some concerns. "I don't know about loading somebody's dog up and taking it to Corinth without them having a hearing.  I've got reservations about it," he said.  "I'm not saying that I'm against this being passed.  I'm just saying it carries with it a little bit of risk, and potential trouble on down the line." 

 

After further discussion, Seaton restated his concern. "I'm not saying that I'm against this.  I'm just saying that, well, you know what the Constitution says about taking someone's property.  Somebody could make some kind of far-out argument that that's what this is."

 

Norris expressed the opinion that once the policy was implemented the problem with stray dogs would be quickly solved, and dog owners would keep a closer eye on their pets. 

 

"I guess that's probably true," Seaton said.  "The point is, just be careful about this 

 

Norris brought up another consideration.  "Well, what concerns me is that if you don't do this and one of these strays contracts rabies and then bites somebody, if we haven't done anything about it—" 

 

Seaton continued to caution against "catching" dogs and transporting them to Corinth, suggesting that fining people, repeatedly, if necessary, would be the better policy. 

 

Mayor Morris voiced a concern that people from outside the town would regard the new policy as a convenient way of disposing with unwanted pets, simply by dumping them in Adamsville. 

 

After more discussion, Norris said, "Well, this is better than what we're doing now, which is nothing.  I think we ought to try it." 

 

Thrasher pointed out that the new policy did not envision city employees going out and actively looking for dogs to seize.  "If the dog doesn't have somebody complaining about it, we're not going to fool with it." 

 

Given the concerns raised, Thrasher modified his proposal. "Something you guys ought to, you might consider, amend your motion and pass this part of it.  Running the ad, fining them, and just don't put the going to Corinth on here yet.  And give us a month and see what happens, and then—" 

 

"I think that would be the better idea," Mayor Morris said. 

 

Browder agreed.  "I amend the motion," he said.  "We'll save off on Corinth." 

 

The motion was seconded by Norris, but before a vote could be taken Police Chief Bill McCall spoke up.  "Well, being as you're on the subject of dogs, Terry, it's a good time right now to get it up and bring it out, you have in your ordinance, you cannot have any pit bulls in this city."  The ordinance makes reference to the American Kennel Club's designation of what defines a pit bull, which raises identification problems.  McCall said the pit bull/not pit bull problem had come up twice in the previous two weeks. 

 

Mayor Morris was not optimistic. "This dog situation has been going on ever since the first time I got on the city commission in 1976, and we haven't solved it, and I don't look for us to solve it tonight.  If you really solved it, you'd have to get you a dog lot, veterinarian, and every thing else." 

 

"Well," Browder said, "I think there for a pretty good little while, as bad a situation as it was, Mr. Rudy kind of handled this situation, and now that he's gone, you know, when you've got people coming to four or five or six meetings a year complaining about, you know—  I know the problems bad, and you know it may be unsolvable, but I think we've got to do something." 

 

"Well," Norris agreed, "you have to do something to attempt to control it." 

 

"All right," Thrasher summed up, "we're going to run the ad, and fine them, and you guys are going to take it under advisement, he's [Seaton] going to research it, we're going to work on it." 

 

Thrasher next informed the board that two businesses had expressed interest in renting space in the Garan Building, "and one would suit us fine, but the other is a fiberglass company [which manufactures water slides]."  After discussing for several minutes the problems the community has experienced with previous fiberglass operations, Norris said, "I believe I'd rather look at that other tenant, myself," and Browder agreed. 

 

The City Web Site was next on the agenda, and Thrasher said that he expected to receive a CD from Steve Brown, who created and maintains Selmer's web site, later in the week demonstrating what he could do to upgrade the Adamsville web site. 

 

"Well," Norris said, "while you're on this subject, I have another company in Nashville that I've talked to.  I found them last year at the tourism conference, and they, that's all they do, is design and maintain websites for small companies, small cities.  They specialize in small cities, small towns.  They've done some work for Hardin County."  Norris said he was trying to get them to come down and give the town a proposal on what they would charge "to update ours, or to completely redesign it.  So anyway, I'd like for us to compare both of them." 

 

"Well, I think we ought to," Thrasher agreed.  "I don't think we ought to just jump on because Steve Brown did one for Selmer.  We may not like it, but I say let's get the disk, let me burn some copies and what not.  You [Norris] can look at it, and you [Browder] can look at it, and I don't know who all else, but we can pull it up here at city hall for the ones that want to look at it here.  And at least see what—" 

 

"It's a really important situation," Norris stressed, "because what we were told last year, and it's been confirmed by a lot of other people, well in the meetings that I went to last week, by the economic development people, the website is, that's the first thing that a lot of people, tourist, you know, that might visit your town, or companies that are looking to relocate, are looking for that, and they are looking for the information on there that can help them decide." 

 

After some further discussion Mayor Morris, who had earlier confessed his lack of knowledge about such matters, closed the subject. "Well, we all agree to do it, so let's do it and go on." 

 

Thrasher then informed the board that he had received a call that afternoon from an appraiser regarding the Hwy 64 property.  "He thinks the property out on 64 West is worth between ten and twelve thousand dollars."  Everyone was in agreement that the city should get a second appraisal done. 

 

The board also agreed to reduce the number of members on the Planning Commission from eight to seven.  Arguing for the reduction, Thrasher said this would facilitate the work of the commission, since it would reduce the number needed to constitute a quorum from five to four, and he explained that this would not require removing any sitting member, since one seat was currently vacant.  The motion, made by Norris and seconded by Browder, passed unanimously. 

 

Also unanimous was the vote on a motion by Browder, seconded by Norris, to approve the following resolution regarding the Safe Routes to School program: 

 

"Resolution authorizing the filing of a 2008 Safe Routes to School grant.  Whereas the Mayor and Aldermen of Adamsville, Tennessee, have committed themselves to improve the safety and physical well-being of the citizens that they represent, and, whereas said public officials have determined that safe access to Adamsville Elementary School for student pedestrians and bikers is the most pressing need that can be addressed with grant assistance from the Safe Routes to School program, and whereas Adamsville wishes to make application to make Phase I sidewalk, crosswalk and other improvements around the school in the amount of $185,000, which will be a request of $185,000 from the Safe Routes to School program, now, therefore, be it resolved that the Mayor of Adamsville is authorized to make and sign the application for Safe Routs to School funds and enter into any and all necessary agreements and assurances to consummate the application.  Read, adopted, and approved in open public meeting this seventeenth day of March, 2008." 

 

The last item on the regular agenda read "Reword Contractor Agreement."   Thrasher explained that "a few months ago you guys passed a memorandum of understanding that would be entered into by the city, and a grant writer, and an engineering company, to make sure that the engineering company and the grant writers understood that if we applied for a grant, and they did the paperwork and the footwork, and we did not get the grant, that they do not get any money.  And some of the engineering companies and the grant writers seem to think we need to amend this memorandum to where they can feel assured that if they do the work and we get the grant, that they will get the job and we won't give it to another company." 

 

After some discussion about what changes, if any, needed to be made, Mayor Morris asked Town Attorney Ken Seaton what the town needed to do. "We just need to start over," Seaton replied. 

 

Norris said, "I make a motion that we give that form to our attorney and have him rewrite it to where if we get the grant then the engineering firm is guaranteed the job."  Browder seconded the motion, which passed unanimously. 

 

Though it was not on the agenda, the board then spent some time discussing safety concerns and the fireworks display at the up-coming Buford Pusser festival. 

 

Mayor Morris observed that "some people says it's a no-no, it's a bad, you know, to have fireworks.  I was hoping Dwana would be here.  It's a great liability.  I imagine you [Seaton] could tell us that." 

 

After some discussion of potential problems, Morris said,  "What I brought it up for, I don't want to get the town in a liability of setting somebody's place on fire and all.  Because I like fireworks just as well as that four-year-old kid up here does.  But I'm just wanting to look after the town, and make sure that we're not going to get into no big lawsuit if we have the fireworks down here at the park.  If there's somewhere else we could have them things, great.  I'll be 100% for it.  But I'm just wondering if we wanted to have it." 

 

There was some discussion of past fireworks displays, and utilities director Paul Wallace Plunk pointed out that there was "a lot of high-power explosives" last time. "I was part of it last year, but I can tell you, it was, it could have been a dangerous situation.  Because, it's just like the accident over at Selmer, you move all the people back, and then they'll start inching forward.  We had the same thing down here.  We had to get them so far away, and then once you turn your back, here they come.  So it's just a continuous fight to keep them pushed back." 

 

Browder said, "I think before we do away with it, we ought to at least look into the possibility of relocating where they're shot." 

 

The others were in agreement. "I'm not in favor of doing away with it," Norris said, and Mayor Morris added, "Well, we all have in mind what I was talking about, so, I'm not for doing away with it, I think it just needs to be moved somewhere."  Plunk agreed, saying, "Well, this year, if there is fireworks, we will look at different location for it." 

 

Thrasher suggested that, since the fireworks display could be seen for miles, problems of finding a safe place from which to launch fireworks, and a safe place for them to land, could be solved by moving the launch site down to the sewer pond. "If you go to the west bank of the old sewer pond and shoot them this a way, they're going to land in one of them two ponds." 

 

The meeting was adjourned on a motion by Browder, seconded by Norris. 

 

Working Session

13 March 2008

Nobody showed.  Neither the mayor nor any of the commissioners bothered to show up.  So much for that good idea.

 

 

 

Town Board Meeting

18 February 2008


City beautification and dogs were the main topics of discussion at Adamsville's February town board meeting.


Hwy 64 Beautification Project

After the board briskly (and unanimously) approved the minutes (motion by Browder, seconded by Lacey), the financial report (motion by Lacey, seconded by Browder), and the remaining reports (motion by Lacey, seconded by Garrison), Town Manager Terry Thrasher asked if the board would consider a non-agenda item.

Thrasher observed that Bart Walls, of Askew, Hargrove and Harcourt, the firm that is handling the towns Hwy 64 Beautification Project, was in the audience, "and I wonder if we can give him a few minutes to tell us anything he thinks we might need to know, or we might ask any question that's on our minds, and not have him sit here all night and have to drive back to, I don't know where he drives back to."

"We have gotten approval from TDOT on our language for our easements," Walls told the commissioners, "and we can now obtain our easements from our property owners.  We still lack just a couple of property owners, in getting our initial contact forms filled out, so we're very close to being able to move forward with everything on the project.  Like I say, we do have approval from TDOT on the constructions plans and specifications, and we're still working on this right-of-way certification phase that is, seems to be taking forever and a day, but we're moving at TDOT's pace, of have been.  So we've—  On our property maps, we've still got probably three, or maybe four properties that we need to pull the deeds on and verify just a couple of things on our property map, and may have to send those back to our city attorney [Ken Seaton] and get him to double check the title opinions on those.  I have received the title opinions from him.  Appreciate that.  And hopefully here, inside, depending on how long it takes us to get the construction easements signed by everyone, and recorded, hope to be able to go ahead and bid this project, I would say, inside the next six weeks, maybe?  Just depending on how quick we can get all of our easements executed and recorded."

"Who's not signed, Bart?" asked Mike Norris.

"We have the Pit Stop, and Jerry's TV," Walls replied, "and I don't know if there'll be any hold up, really, on Jerry's TV, because TDOT has told us that the right of way is at the building face on the north side of the highway.  And that's been part of the holdup throughout this whole process, is that in doing the right-of-way certification and determining where the right of way actually is, we couldn't find any information, or any deeds, that said that the right of way was actually out at the building face.  All the deeds that we could find show that the right of way is actually out in the road.  So we went back to TDOT and explained that to them and showed them what we were able to find, and TDOT produced some construction drawings that showed that the right of way is out there, but they couldn't actually produce any deeds either.  So they told us that we could base our right-of-way certification off of some of the prior construction projects that TDOT had done, such as the intersection improvement that happened, maybe a couple of years ago?  That set of plans shows the right of way being at the building face on the north side."

Dwana Garrison asked, "You said, now, my understanding was that our city attorney had gotten you the title opinions, is that what you said?"

Walls answered affirmatively.

"But, now," Garrison continued, "you've got two or three still, there's some question about?"

"There's a couple of more," Walls replied.  "The properties that are on the southeast and southwest corner of Highway 17 and 64, right there.  There's a couple of little slivers and pieces of property that are, they're not, over the years the properties have been sliced off, and the right of way has been, the road's been improved and things like that and so there's some lingering little pieces in there that we've got to get the deeds on those little pieces so that we can make everything fit together properly."

"Is that your job," Garrison asked, "or is that Ken's job?"

"Well, it's my job," Walls responded, "and then I will get him the deeds that we're able to pull—"

"So you'll be on top of that, getting back to Ken?" Garrison asked.

"Right, and we'll get that back to him—"

"You say six weeks," Garrison interrupted.  "You don't sound like you can actually do it in six weeks and have all your figures and all."

"Well," Walls responded, "like I say, it depends on how long it takes to get the easements."

"Well," Garrison asked, "you're going to stay on top of your part, though, and get it to him?"

"Right," Walls agreed.

"Okay," Garrison responded.

Walls continued. "We've got about, roughly thirty-five pieces of property that we have to get construction easements on."

"But they've signed—" Garrison began.

"They've signed the intent to donate," Walls said.  "Everybody that we've dealt with has signed a form agreeing to donate the construction easement—"

"What's the status of the Pit Stop?" Norris asked.

"I believe we're going to talk to them on Wednesday," Walls said.  "Terry and I have an appointment set up to go and to visit with them and to talk with them some more."

Norris continued: "And my understanding is that we cannot do any bidding until the easements have been signed and the deeds for the construction easements have been recorded."

"That's right," Walls confirmed. "Once we get all of the easements signed, we'll send a copy of the title opinions to the state, a copy of the deeds to the state, a copy of the initial contact forms to the state, and a copy of the recorded construction easements to the state.  And then once they get those and they verify that we've got that for all those properties, then they'll send us a letter with great big letters on it that says, 'You may proceed with construction.'"

"One other thing," Garrison asked.  "If it doesn't work out with the Pit Stop, we could stop it, though, right there at the end, could we not?"

"That is a possibility," Walls acknowledged.

"That's what I'm saying," Garrison continued, "we could stop it, so if they do not agree to go ahead and be a part of the project and let it continue down in front of their place, the new sidewalks, then we could stop it right there."

"Yes," Walls acknowledged.  "That's not the desired result—"

"Oh, I know that," Garrison interrupted.  "I understand that."

"—but that is a possibility."

"I just wanted to make sure that was a possibility," Garrison repeated, "in case, you know, they decided not to do that."

"Right," Walls agreed.

"That won't hold up the rest of it," Garrison repeated.


City Beautification Committee

Alta Lane was also on hand to update the board on the activities of the City Beautification Committee.

"Well," she began, "I came to show you what the City Beautiful [sic] Committee has accomplished and get your approval on some things.  And the first thing, we made a brochure.  As you know, I suppose, we're going to have a fund-raiser, selling engraved pavers, and we have made a brochure, and this is very rough.  I have one for each of you.  And as you can see, I just cut and pasted.  I just cut and pasted, and the finished brochure will be really nice, on nice paper.  And if you would read, okay, let's see the inside first.  The pricing of these pavers is very complicated, so I spelled it out very specifically, so that anybody can understand how much a paver will cost and what they will get for that price."

After some discussion of the size and price of the various pavers and the wording of the brochure, Lane asked for money to have 250 copies printed up and said that her daughter could do it for about half what a printer would charge, with set-up costs of about $25 or $50, and a cost of $.50 per brochure.  The board ultimately voted unanimously, on a motion by Jeff Browder, seconded by Frank Lacey, to authorize the expenditure.


Dogs

The issue of dogs, and what to do with them, which has been brought up by audience members in several recent board meetings, made it onto the agenda this month and was addressed by Commissioner Browder, who provided board members with copies of an email he had received from Michael Boston of the Corinth Alcorn County Humane Society, which read:

We agree to take animals from Adamsville, TN on a per animal payment basis.  Payment should be made to Corinth Alcorn County Humane Society (CACHS) on a monthly basis.  We have the ability to take as many as you find necessary to bring to us.  We are open seven days a week and will also be available to take in animals from you during closed hours.

The animals would be brought to our shelter by someone from Adamsville.  The per animal fee is $40

We would hold any animal of unknown ownership for a minimum of five days (per tn and ms rules).  After that we will make them available for adoption.  When the animals leave our shelter (adopted) they are spayed/neutered, micro-chipped, rabies vaccination and other vaccinations, heart worm test and temperment tested.

Let me know if there are any additional info that you need.

"We've had a problem with this for some time," Browder said.  "After talking to him [Boston] on the phone, he has sent—  And all the information is not in this letter.  I mean, he's willing to do cats, too, if we want to do cats.  Y'all can pretty well read through that.  I hope you have already read it.  But he's willing to do it on a per-animal basis.  They do have a van that can transport several animals at once, if we wind up with more than we can haul.  And it may be, that if you guys decide that we need to do this, that we have to build a temporary holding pen.  You know, if you catch one at four o'clock in the afternoon, you're not going to send anybody overtime down there to do that, that would hold one overnight, twenty-four, forty-eight hours, whatever.  That would be expensive, but—  I move that we go ahead with this right here to, you know, we've got people here, three or four meetings a year, complaining about the stray-dog issue, and here is I think an economical way.  We were going to pay a little better than twice that to another party to take care of this problem for us, and I move that we move forward with this right here and authorize Terry to make final agreement with Mr. Boston down at the CACHS."

Norris seconded the motion, which was then discussed at length.

"We will have the word 'someone' filled in with an official, right?" Frank Lacey asked.  "I would hate to think that just anyone could bring their animal down there."

"Well," Browder responded, "that's going to have to be some official.  Now you as an individual, if you want to take an animal down there, he'll take it."

"But," Lacey said, "I wouldn't want the city to be saddled with the responsibility—"

"Oh, no," Browder responded.  "Right.  It'll have to be through us, before we pay for it.  Sure.  It'll have to be a city employee, or an agent of the city in some form or fashion—"

Mayor Tommy Morris asked, "How much is it going to cost us to keep this dog for a night or two, plus, how many people we'll have to sent to Corinth, and how much is the travel expenses going to be down there just to get this one dog?"

"Well, now, one animal?" Browder responded.  "We can take one animal.  I mean, that's a trip to Corinth and back.  You're going to be paying the guy, to do something.  Like I say, I think we can carry them down there for $43."

Norris brought up a related matter. "Well, are we not going to begin to enforce the leash law, and write citations that would cover the cost of that?"

Browder then said, "I guess maybe I need to further my motion and say we need to publish this in the paper, you know, a couple or three weeks running, that Adamsville as of whatever date we get our final agreement in place with that Mr. Boston down here, you know, as of this date we will be enforcing the leash law.  If you value your pet, better make arrangements.  And it's something that I think will be pretty active off the front end, but once we do away with the stray problem, then I think it will be greatly reduced.  I'm not expecting to see a trip to Corinth every day, after two months or so."

Garrison joined in.  "Add that if you put the ad in the paper it will be that, you know, you said about, keep your pets up or, I mean, the situation is that you are going to be fined and cited into court and there will be a fine and you will have to pay it."

Browder admitted his uncertainty on that issue. "That's, like I say, that's, if we've got that, you know, I don't, I haven't read the leash law, lately.  I don't know exactly what we call for.  Maybe somebody else can tell me.  Do we fine them, right off the front end?"

"I think according to our charter, we can fine them," Thrasher said.

"We can?" Browder asked.  "Or we do?"

"We could," Thrasher replied.

"We've never," observed the mayor, which brought an immediate contradiction from Police Chief Bill McCall.

"Yes we have," McCall said, from the side of the meeting room.  "We've cited them into court, and we've paid a lot of $80 here for violations of the leash law.  The law says you keep them on a leash or in a pen.  That's it.  That's pretty plain and simple."

Lacey then brought up an issue that had been discussed at an earlier meeting. "I would like to see us go further with this and start some kind of registration for pets.  We can register your pets so that if your dog was picked up, it would have a number and we could at least try to contact you.  There will be times when an animal might accidentally get out, and it would be nice to contact—

"And there again," Browder interrupted, "I would think that, we, I know at one time had in place a way to register these animals.  I think that kind of goes into, you know, I think that's something that we could put in our verbiage in our paper ad and say, you know, if you want to do that, fine, but be advised that it's going to cost you to get that dog out down there.  You know, it's going to take you half a day to go get him, because he's going to be in Corinth, Mississippi.  You know, like you say, if you want to register your dog and put a number on him, that would be a smart move.  If you don't want to, then maybe you can go to Corinth and pick him up after we get him."

Lacey amplified on his idea.  "You could give them, you know, a three-month grace period.  Register your animal, you know, between now and then, now and three months at no cost.  After this period of time, to register an animal's going to cost, you know, $10, $15, whatever y'all say."

Browder said, "And after talking to Michael down there, he gave me a couple of options.  Now Corinth does it one way.  The city of Farmington, they do charge, they charge like a, not really, I don't guess, a fine, but a surcharge, that defrays the city's cost somewhat, of catching an animal and bringing it to.  You know, like I say, if it winds up being $80, then you know that gives us an extra $40 before we're even out a penny."

"I like that idea," Mayor Morris interjected.

"But, of course," Browder continued, "what we're going to wind up with, the problem that we're going to have, is not going to be those dogs that belong to Joe down the street that he loves like a child.  The problem is the strays that nobody takes care of.  That's where we're going to be out our forty dollars.  And I don't have a problem with that at all."

Garrison observed that the problem had to be dealt with.  "The state is going to make us sooner or later, anyway."

Browder mentioned one other consideration as the discussion ended. "I talked to Ronnie Neil about the situation, and that's about all— You can spend a hundred grand to run your own place to take them in, or you can contract with somebody that does that."

Browder's motion to accept the CACHS proposal was unanimously approved by a roll call vote.


Long Range Planning Retreat

At the board first-ever working session, which had been held the previous Thursday and was attended by all of the board members except the mayor, the commissioners had discussed holding a retreat, with an outside party to serve as a facilitator, during which the board members could discuss long term goals and plans for the town of Adamsville, and the retreat was placed on the agenda for the regular February board meeting.

When Mayor Morris read "Set time and date for long-range planning retreat" Monday night, Thrasher explained that the original proposal to hold an overnight retreat at the Pickwick Inn had been abandoned because several members had preferred to come home Friday night rather than stay at the Inn.  What Thrasher proposed instead was to meet at the Pickwick Inn on the evening of Friday, February 29, for dinner and discussion and then to resume the meeting the following morning at the Adamsville city hall.  Thrasher said he had spoken with Ronnie Neil of MTAS, who had agreed to serve as facilitator.

All of the board members were receptive, except for Mayor Morris, who asked, "Are we going to get like Willie Herenton's bunch, and travel somewhere all the time, when we've got a place here, a good place?"

Lacey spoke in favor of the meeting.  "I think it would be nice for us to get together in an area with a moderator that would take some of the personalities out of the conversation for us and give us time to set a five year goal, a ten year goal, a fifteen and a twenty year goal for the city, knowing that ten years from now those goals might change, but we would at least have a direction to go in, and it would determine, you know, are we for city growth, are we for maybe reducing our city limit size, or modifying our city limit size.  Are we going to have, you know, what kind of services do we want to have five years down the road, ten years down the road.  You know, what do we want to have to offer as our population changes, as it grows older, or are we going to invite new, younger people to move to our community.  I think this is what a long range planning session does, is it helps to establish kind of the direction that you'd like the city to go in.  And not just for today, but just kind of a roadmap for the future."

Garrison made the motion that the board hold the retreat on February29-March 1 as outlined by Thrasher, and she encouraged the mayor to attend.  Lacey seconded her motion, with the additional request that board members write down their ideas and proposals beforehand so that Neil, and the other board members as well, would be able to think about them beforehand.  "It would help us all," Lacey said, "and help the city to kind of keep going in the same direction.  We all have good ideas, a lot of things we'd like to do, we'd like us to understand what we can and can't do, and this is a good way.  There's a lot of things we might agree on that we could go ahead and be working on."

The motion passed on a voice vote, with the mayor alone casting a "no" vote.


Other Items

—Mayor Morris advised the board that the city had gotten back the title for the Hwy 64 West property, which had been the subject of considerable discussion since last summer, and Lacey immediately made a motion "that we get the property appraised and we list it for sale, with a realtor that Terry chooses."  Norris seconded the motion which passed without discussion by a unanimous voice vote.

—Lacey also made a motion, seconded by Garrison, "that we establish a parks and recreation board to report to the commission with responsibility for the parks.  And included in this recommendation I would like to ask that the following people be considered for the original membership: Debbie Moffett, secretary; Steven Lambert; John Liddy; Ann Hudson; and Paul Wallace Plunk."  After some discussion it was agreed that the board members should serve four-year terms, with one member coming up for replacement each year.  Thrasher was charged with deciding the order in which the original board members would go off the board.  The motion carried by a unanimous voice vote.

—Thrasher informed the board that "We've been transferring about seventeen thousand and change, and we need to raise that to twenty-four thousand for the next four months.  To get enough money in there to pay for the old water bond that's coming due.  We're just taking it out of one bank account and putting it in another bank account."  Lacey made a motion, seconded by Browder, that the transfer be approved, and it passed by a unanimous roll call vote.

—Thrasher reviewed several bids which had been received in response to the city's call for bids on a track hoe and recommended that the board accept the $36,076 bid from Williams Equipment for a Bobcat 335 and pay for it with a four-year lease-purchase agreement.  Lacey made the motion to accept that bid, Norris seconded it, and the motion carried on a unanimous roll call vote.

—The board discussed at some length the need to revise, update, and expand the town's website.  Norris expressed the view that the town needed a good website and he ran down a list of the things he thought it should contain.  Browder said that the website should also include a forms library.

—Thrasher then asked the board to consider going from the town's current "employer-paid only" retirement plan to a 401K plan, which would allow town employees to contribute to their own plans, which Thrasher said would substantially increase their retirement benefits.  The board, on a motion by Garrison, seconded by Browder, unanimously authorized Thrasher to investigate making the change.


Safe Routes to School

The last item on the agenda was the "Safe Routes to School," program, and Thrasher called on John Liddy, who was in the audience, for an update.

"We've had a couple of meetings with the engineering company, Griggs and Malone, out of Murfreesboro, they've done this before, they're doing it for some other counties in middle Tennessee.  Bill Griggs was here Tuesday morning, as well as Monique Hazelwood, I think, from Southwest Tennessee Development District, who's going to help us write the grant.  Bill has got a meeting scheduled this week with Debbie Brickles, I think, from the part of government that administers this grant.   I don't think I'm going to be able to go.  Maybe Terry can go.  Somebody, that for an initial meeting, but we're supposed to try and get all of our information together by the 26th.  I think what we need from the City Commission of Adamsville is for the board to pass a resolution saying that you want to use Southwest Tennessee Development District and Griggs and Malone in this, just so that, if this grant goes through and the city does receive this grant, that, you know, I think there's sort of been a history here maybe, of some people doing the preliminary work and not getting the work when the grant has gone through."

After some discussion, Lacey said, "I would like to make the motion that the board pass this resolution stating that we would appreciate, and work with Briggs and Malone and Southwest Tennessee Development, their working on this thing on behalf of the city of Adamsville, and we understand that if we should get this grant that they would be the ones that continue on through the completion of this project."

The mayor asks for a second, and then seconded it himself when one was not immediately forthcoming.  There was then considerable discussion about forms and letters setting forth the town's obligations to agencies which do work on grants that are not initially successful but are later granted after a subsequent application, and the meeting was finally adjourned without a vote being taken on Lacey's motion.



Town Board Meeting

21 January 2008

With two consecutive civil town board meetings under its belt, it looks like Adamsville may be dropping out of the "Dysfunctional Town Board Derby," leaving the field to Selmer ("Let's repeal the last two years"), Bethel Springs ("Let's lock out the mayor"), and Ramer ("God doesn't want the citizens to have a say").

That's not to say that the January meeting was all sweetness and light—Mayor Tommy Morris made an inexplicable one-man stand against the entirely reasonable (and ultimately successful) proposal that the board begin holding planning sessions the Thursday before the board's regular monthly meeting to review and discuss proposed agenda items—but the contrast with earlier meetings, where acrimony was the order of the day, was refreshing.


* * *

After the minutes of the December meeting were approved by unanimous voice vote (on a motion by Frank Lacey, seconded by Mike Norris) and the financial report was approved by unanimous roll call vote (on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Jeff Browder), Mayor Morris proposed that the board adopt a policy of approving the remaining reports with one vote, after allowing time for discussion.  A motion to that effect, made by Lacey and seconded by Browder, passed by unanimous voice vote.

In the first item of Old Business, "Hwy 64 West Property," Town Manager Terry Thrasher announced the latest in a string of hitches: "Just for a point of information, the check has not cleared.  We had a little problem, or the lady did, and they put the money, I don't really understand it, in the wrong account, and it was supposed to be handled a week ago today, and it never was really handled.  And today the banks are all closed, so we're going to jump on it again in the morning."

"Why has it not gone through?" Norris asked.

"Because there's not enough money in that account," Thrashed replied.

"She claims she put it in the wrong account," Mayor Morris amplified.  "And she's trying to get a pretty good sized loan.  I reckon until she puts that money in the bank and gets that land, the bank, I don't reckon, you know, can go much further.  That's my understanding.  Is that your understanding?" he asked Thrasher.

"All I know to do is start in the morning when the bank is open again," Thrasher replied, "and go down and talk to the banker.  The bank wasn't really concerned about it.  They seemed to feel it was a matter of getting the right entry made."


* * *

There was better news regarding the next item.  Utility Director Paul Wallace Plunk advised the board that treatment to control the odor problem at the Sewer Pond had been under way for three weeks.  Chemicals had been added twice weekly for the first three weeks and had now been reduced to once a week.

"It's working," Mayor Morris said, and Mike Norris said "Well, I've had a couple of people tell me that it was a lot better," before asking, "So, we're going to continue this forever?"

"You'll have to keep doing chemicals, yes, all the time," Plunk replied.  "But not a great amount."

Browder asked, "Do we have an idea of monthly cost of these treatments?"

"Not yet," Plunk replied.  "I've got another person coming tomorrow that has a different chemical which is cheaper than the chemical we are using, but I don't know if it does the same thing or not, until we talk to this person tomorrow."

Regarding this second chemical, Thrasher said "We've had some good recommendations on it, from towns in our area."


* * *

The next item on the agenda was the review of the city charter.  "You guys have been talking about this," Thrasher said, "and I got ahold of Ronnie [Ronnie Neill, of  Municipal Technical Assistance Service (MTAS)], to have an Adamsville City Charter review, which is to sit down with him and all the printouts of the various city charters, and the things that we've changed in our charter."

Thrasher mentioned possible dates for the review, and Mayor Morris asked, "Do we need to listen to him first, before we start any deciding what we want to do?"

When Dwana Garrison responded affirmatively, Morris asked, "Why?  Why couldn't each person in this commission go through it and see what they think needs to be changed, and then we could all get together and work that out before we call him?"

Garrison replied that the plan was for Neill to "get us all so we would kind of know, so that, like you said, when we would come away, then we would decide some things we want to do.  He was just kind of go over it for us.  We may, you know, miss that, if we don't have this first initial meeting with him then I think it might not be then as workable as it could be then for the second meeting, as far as—"

"In other words," Morris interrupted, "he could tell us what we probably need, and we can either disagree or agree to it, then.  Either way, as long as we work it out."

"Yes sir," Garrison agreed.  "Yes sir."

"It doesn't cost anything," Thrasher added.  "That's what we pay them their fees for….  I think it's going to take, like I say, three or four meetings before this comes out."

"Oh, it's going to take a year to get that done," Morris said.  "As long as you get in there for the next legislation."

"Well," Norris said, "he [Neill] knows our charter backwards and forwards.  And he can come in here and tell you what is out of date, that he would propose to change, I know.  I mean, there are several different forms of city government, and he needs to talk to us about that, so that we can decide which form of city government that we want to have."

After some further discussion the board agreed to schedule a meeting with Neill for 5:00 p.m. on Feburary 21.


* * *

Thrasher then updated the board on the status of the Charter Cable TV Review, saying that he had given everyone a copy of another letter from John Howell of Telecommunications Consulting Associates which contained "probably twenty references.  I contacted Selmer, Savannah, Waynesboro, and Henderson, and all of our neighboring towns think this guy hung the moon and turned the light out."  Thrasher said that TCA had performed a similar review for Selmer, and got "a little better than $7,000 back, of which he got thirty-four hundred and something dollars of it.  And Savannah people, Waynesboro people and Henderson people said that not only did he get them money back, but in some cases he rewrote their agreement with Charter and increased the fees, and—  I'm more impressed than I was.  And what he does, he comes down and audits everything, and if he convinces Charter that they owe us $10,000, when we get the ten thousand in hand, we got to give him half of it.  So we don't have to pay him any future payments.  I don't think we've got anything to lose."

"Sounds awful good to be true," Mayor Morris said, but the board agreed to go along with the proposed review.


* * *

The last item of old business was the Safe Routes to School program.  "If you remember," Thrasher began, "we told you about a meeting that John Liddy and I went to in Waynesboro.  We have set up a committee: John Liddy, the principal of the elementary school, the PTO president, a teacher, a businessman, a parent.  There's about a seven-member committee working on it.  They have already met one time, and it's been turned over to that committee.  They have a recording secretary.  And what they're going to do is start taking pictures and making observations, and they're probably going to come back to the city sometime in the future, hopefully in the near future, and they're probably going to want some money.  Now, the money probably will be for preliminary engineering work.  It may have to be something signed by a professional engineer.  Now the gamble is, if they go for this grant and get it, then the engineering fees I think can be paid out of the grant.  But that's— we'll just have to wait and see.  They've only had one meeting.  I don't know how far they're going or what's going to happen to it.  I just wanted you to know.  I just wanted you to know that it's the Safe Routes to School, it's a $250,000 TDOT grant, that there's no match for crosswalks, sidewalks…."

"What I think on that," Mayor Morris said, "if we do get that, just thinking of the grammar school down here, we ought to put another lane this side, and that way they could park on it and then have sidewalks walk to the school, too."

Garrison agreed: "I think that's a good idea."

"I think that would be the safest," Morris said.

"Talking about this sort of thing," Norris interjected, "what's the latest on this street over here that we talked about—"

He was referring to Hughes Street, the paving of which had been held up for months by a dispute as to who should be responsible for paying for the repair of the street, which is on property owned by the School Board but leased by the town of Adamsville.

Thrasher responded that nothing had been decide, but, he added, "Nobody's going to blacktop until spring, anyway.  So it's left that, I think the last word that they gave, they requested that we, that the city please go blacktop it."

"Well," Norris responded, "we asked them to cover half the cost, didn't we?"

"Right," Thrasher agreed.

"Did you get a response from that?" Norris asked.

"No," Thrasher replied.  "But the last conversation I had with Mr. Colt is, there's no blacktopping going to be done now until, what, Tommy?  April, May?  So we'll just have to wait.  No point in pushing to see what's going to happen, because it ain't going to be blacktopped until the weather gets above sixty degrees, and stays there."

"Well," Norris persisted, "looks to me like we could be getting some sort of agreement with them, one way or the other.  Why would we have to wait until April or May to get back involved with it?"

"I will call Mr. Miskelly [Director of Education Charles Miskelly] again, and find out if they think— Frank may know how it's going to set up any way."

"It hadn't been brought back up," replied Commissioner Lacey, who is also Chairman of the School Board.


* * *

Before Mayor Morris got into the agenda's new business, Garrison said that she had asked Bart Walls, of Askew, Hargrove and Harcourt, to come to the meeting and give the board a report on the downtown project.

Walls said, "I just wanted to come and touch base with you all and just kind of give you a little report on where things are at and how things are going on that project.  Things are progressing, although they are progressing slowly.  The right-of-way certification project has been a much longer process to go through than we all anticipated, and I've been working with Terry and Ken [town attorney Ken Seaton] on getting the initial contact forms from all the property owners, and I understand that we've got all the initial contact forms but two.  And so we, and I've been in contact with TDOT, and I'm waiting for them to sign off on some language on an actual easement, some easement language, so we can go ahead and start getting the easements with the property owners that have gone ahead and indicated that they would be willing to donate a construction easement for the purposes of the project.  So that's kind of where things are at.  The plans are done.  They have been for two months now.  We've just been trying to dig our way through this right-of-way certification project.  I anticipate, you know—I hate to give you an exact date because I gave you some dates before and they have all changed, it's just due to this process—but I anticipate sometime this spring going forward with an actual bid and trying to get this project under contract, and you'll start seeing things, real visible progress on it." 

After Walls concluded, Norris raised another item that had been discussed at previous meetings. "Before you leave old business, there's just one thing I wanted to bring up.  I've had quite a few complaints, and I guess I've got one, too, about the garbage pickup people.  They're tearing the garbage cans all to pieces.  We're getting lots of complaints."

Paul Wallace Plunk responded, "I talked with them last week and told them how many garbage cans that we had torn up in the last four months.  He was supposed to have sent somebody here last Thursday.  Nobody never showed up.  Too look—and I know, it's not the people on the trucks that's doing it.  It's their equipment that's doing it.  Because I followed the garbage truck around and seen what it does.  Sometimes it will actually throw the garbage can completely up into the truck.  The guy on it has to crawl up there and get it."

Norris had a suggestion on how to get their attention: "Let's don't send them a check one month—"

Thrasher agreed, saying that the town should determine "what our cost to repair is, and make them understand that that's being deducted from the next bill.  Those poly-carts are about ninety bucks apiece," and the city furnishes them to city residents.

After some further discussion, Plunk said that he would try again to get someone from the company to come down and look at the damage their equipment was doing to the carts.


* * *

"Four-wheelers riding on city property," Morris read, finally moving into the agenda's New Business.

Thrasher explained that "We're having some complaints and have observed the five acres that we was donated to the city down in Dickey Woods subdivision, that there's a lot of young people on all-terrain vehicles, 4-wheelers, riding around on that property.  And I just question the— I'm glad the lawyer is here, because TML [Tennessee Municipal League] frowns on it.  Of course, they're so picky that they frown on anything.  But I'm wondering if we don't have a liability there that we might not want to keep.  We might want to buy three or four signs and put them on that street in Dickey Woods, and one out on Elms Road, saying 'Don't ride on this property,' or whatever y'all want to do."

"What do you think, legal man?" Morris asked, turning to Seaton.

"I think that would be a good idea," Seaton opined.

"Think it would be a good idea," Morris repeated.

"Anybody got a problem with putting signs up there?" Thrasher asked, and no one did.

"I just hate to say to little boys and girls not get to ride," Morris said in a final comment on the subject, "but if it's a legal problem, we don't need it then."

Thrasher next reported that one of the town's water customers had run up a water bill of $918.74 in one month when a commode in a detached building was inadventently allowed to run for several weeks before it was discovered.  In the old days there was an adjustment schedule, which was raised a few years back. "But our question to the city fathers, do we want to adjust this bill?  What we do when we adjust this bill, you open up the door, and we're going to have to be able to do this for anybody else that want adjustment."

The board members discussed the adjustment policy at length before finally agreeing unanimously, on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Garrison, to handle future adjustment requests on an individual basis and to adjust this particular bill by $1.50 per thousand gallons.

Although listed under "New Business," the next agenda item—"Contribution to airport grant"—had actually appeared before the board at an earlier meeting, and after a brief discussion the board unanimously approved Lacey's motion (seconded by Norris) to authorize Thrasher "to write a check for whatever is left that they need to have, and that will be our part of the matching grant," up to $2,500.


* * *

The next agenda item—"Schedule planning session for commission"—generated the only disagreement of the evening.

"Well," Mike Norris began, "we've all talked about it, and, you know, most every other community that I know of has a planning session before the regular scheduled meeting.  It just gives us, gives the commissioners and the mayor an opportunity to get together.  Nothing is voted on, or anything like that.  It's just to review the agenda to be sure that we understand it.  That we don't come in, you know, blind-sided about something.  And it also gives us the opportunity to—  We don't have a short range or a long range plan for this community, and we need to be working on that.  Desperately.  So, I'm making a motion that we, every, I make a motion that, you know, every month, at the appropriate time that we agree on, that we have, you know, a pre-planning session, whatever you want to call it, the public would be invited to it.  There'd be no voting done, or anything like that.  It's just an opportunity for us to get together and talk, be sure that we understand what's going on.  That time can be— We've talked about a Thursday or Friday afternoon.  It can be pretty much any time that everybody wants.  But we need to do that.  You can't run this city on two hours a month."

Mayor Morris turned to Seaton and said, "What do you say, beagle?  Is it illegal?  Sunshine Laws?"

"Not as long as there's access and notice to the public," Seaton replied.  "If the public is able to attend and hear what's said, there's no problem with the Sunshine Law."

"But," Morris persisted, "you got to have, advertise it just like you do a regular city meeting, if you're going to do that.  Personally, I'm against it, because I put in a lot of hours up here anyway.  And I think— no more stuff than we've got on the agenda, I think we can work it out in two hours, easy.  I've just always had this feeling about these pre-meetings.  I never did like them.  I know when I first got on the city commission, the mayor and them would call a pre-meeting before the, at a certain house, or place of business, for, uh, and I said 'Under no circumstance.'  I said, 'The people need to know.'"

Thrasher then said that he had checked with MTAS and that the time and date of any such meetings would have to be advertised, just like regular board meetings.

"In other words," Morris said, "you're having two meetings."

Garrison pointed out that other towns in the area have sessions, and "their city meetings are smoother, they get more done for their city, because it gives people, because that first meeting, and I've been asking this for a long time, you can't make any kinds of decision on that first meeting.  We just need to hear each other's views, because what may be my opinion, by the time I leave the meeting, if I've heard other people's opinions, I may realize that the mayor's opinion is better, or Frank's opinion is better, or Mike's, or Jeff's.  That's what I know will help me, because getting hit down here sometimes on Monday night blind-sided, when you didn't know anything about it, and you've got to make a decision that night—"

Browder interjected another consideration: "It will give you a little, a little opportunity to do some research, you know, that might change your views on something between times."

"Exactly," Garrison agreed.  "And, I mean, we've got to do what's best for our city, the city itself, and our two thousand or so that's in here, and that's a big budget to be dealing with and having to ask to make an answer just like that [snaps her fingers].  That's one thing that I don't like.  You know, I like to be able to review it a little more.  Now that's just—  And if we done it the Thursday, you're saying, prior to—"

Thrasher responded, "I think that's the only way we could help y'all.  Like, in February the meeting will be on the 18th.  That's the third Monday night.  The only way we can get you guys an agenda and a set of minutes from the 14th.  And instead of bringing them to your house the evening of the 14th, my suggestion is, if you decide to have this meeting, is you come up here at 4:30, five o'clock, whatever you want to, and your agenda and your minutes will be here.  And you can sit down and discuss it and talk about it, make your notes.  Then, we will make our notes and change that agenda and get you the full package out like we do now, and you would get it on the 15th.  Which is Friday.  Which still gives you—  Now the agenda ought to look like what you wanted it to look like, because you helped set it up Thursday night.  Then Friday, you get it and you've got Friday night, Saturday, Saturday night, Sunday, Sunday night, and Monday, you come here Monday night and do your voting."

"Well," Norris added as illustration, "it's just like this agenda here [holding up agenda], there's not one word on hear about the beautification, I mean the street project."

"Right," Thrasher agreed.

"There was no call to talk about it.  But that should be on there right now, that should be on there every month and talked about."

Mayor Morris then asked, "Now, when we start this double meeting, we're going to have a lot of people thinking, 'What's going on, here?'

"Well," Thrasher responded, "I think if you choose to do this, we need to run it in the paper for the next two or three weeks and remind them every now and then until they get used to it."

Morris was unmoved.  "Well, I'll just have to turn it over to my vice mayor, because I will not be here for two meetings.  I spend enough time up here every day, every week, through the week.  There's no sense in it.  There's not that much on it.  I'd say, if this thing had 15 or 20 pages, then do it, but there's not that much.  And you're going, you're going to really upset the voters when you start having secret meetings."

"They're not going to be secret," Norris objected.

"Well," Morris replied, "they'll think it."

" I disagree with that," Norris said.

After some further discussion about the need to advertise the meetings (which elicited from Browder the droll observation, "Well that takes all the secret out of it, if you put it in the paper"), Mayor Morris repeated his objection to the additional meeting, saying "I just don't see where we need it."

"Well, the motion's on the table," Norris finally said.  "Anybody want to second?"

"I'll second," Garrison said.

Before the motion was voted on, Lacey said "I would like to make an amendment to the motion, and that is, as Mike mentioned, I definitely think we need to do.  I think we need to set a date in the near future, and I think we need to allow for four or five hours work, to a plan for the city of Adamsville.  A five year, ten year, twenty year plan that would take us out into the future, knowing that those plans can change three or four years down the road, but we will at least have a map, a road map to go on, and that would be, my amendment would be that we would have that, include that in there, and get a date set for that."

"Well," Norris responded, "I think we've got a tremendous amount to talk about and try to help manage, because you got a car plant going in here less than a hundred miles south of us.  It's going to impact us.  You've got subdivisions that are coming in, you know … do we have enough water?"

Garrison seconded Lacey's amendment, but before it was voted on Mayor Morris spoke up.

"Well, let me ask one question before we do this voting.  Question.  Legal.  [Turning to Seaton.]  You tell me, when the charter says that I will run the commission meetings, can they just move this, change this, without going through the legislature?  It's in our charter."

"Off the top of my head," Seaton replied, "I'd say the charter refers to a monthly meeting of the commission that's to conduct the city business.  Now the type of meeting that's being proposed here is not a meeting where actual business can be conducted in the way of actions being taken.  It's a proposal that there be a meeting in preparation for the monthly meeting.  And as long a compliance with the Sunshine Law is made, I don't see any legal problem with it."

"In other words," Morris said, "you don't think that pre-meeting, if they decide how they're going to vote or come in for the next."

"I don't put it that way," Seaton replied.  "I think the purpose of the meeting is for the commissioners to have an opportunity to find out what business is going to be presented and discussed at the monthly meeting, and I think that the purpose is, or the idea is that the commissioners will be better prepared.  And I see no problem with that.  I don't see any legal problem, if the majority of the commission wants to, votes to do that."

"And it does have to be taped," Garrison offered.

"Well," Morris said, "what I'm getting back to, as little business as we've got, why does it take two meetings to do it."

"Well, because, Mayor, there's— " Norris began, then he held up a paper.  "Look at the notes I've already made here tonight, that wasn't on here that I didn't know about, and I don't know what I would say right now, but, you know, I'm being told tonight that the check hasn't cleared on this piece of property.  Well, you know, what does that mean?"

"Well," Morris replied, "when it checks, when it clears and all we will tell you—"

"At the next meeting," Norris said.

"Yeah," Morris said. "Yeah."

"I don't want to have to wait until the next meeting," Norris replied.

"You don't have to know everything that goes on every day," Morris replied.  "It's not your job to know everything that goes on every day."

"It is when you're selling a piece of property that the city owns," Norris said.  "You know, and I'm seeing there's a letter here from Jones Motors saying that they're bowing out of the Garan Building that they rent there.  You know, that's another subject that we need to talk about, that's a whole different subject right there."

Mayor Morris then called for a vote.  Lacey's amendment to Norris's motion was disposed of first, with all the board members voting for it and the mayor casting the lone no vote.  Then the Norris's motion that the board meet for a planning session on the Thursday before each regular monthly meeting was passed by an identical vote—all the commissioners voting yes, and the mayor voting no.


* * *

There then followed a discussion of the city-owned Garan Building and various ways that it might best be utilized to maximize benefits to the town of Adamsville, after which Mayor Morris called upon Adamsville resident William Marts, who had asked to be placed on the agenda to discuss his concerns about traffic in Adamsville.

Marts held forth for eleven minutes about his disapproval of the driving habits of those who share the city streets with him, then he passed out copies of a one-page "Memo" which he then proceeded to read to the board:

Because of obvious disregard for established traffic laws that provide safety for those courageous enough to drive on the surrounding highways and city streets I decided to do some research as to why.  The fact is I find it very aggravating and disrespectful as well as being very dangerous to the Great City of Adamsville and the residents thereof!  BECAUSE I HAVE A GREAT JOY IN CALLING ADAMSVILLE MY HOME I GET VERY ANNOYED WHEN I DO MY BEST TO CONTROL THE SPEED OF MY VEHICLE WHILE ALMOST ALL TRAFFIC PASSES ME AT TEN (10) TO TWENTY FIVE (25) (MPH) FASTER THAN MY SPEED.

What I discovered was the City of Adamsville not afford to patrol all the street and roads within the city of Adamsville.  I can understand this.  Then I look at the number of traffic violations in a given month and it appears that the law enforcement is really doing a fine job.  SO WHAT IS WRONG.

IN INVESTIGATING FURTHER I DISCOVERED THAT: THE AVERAGE SPEEDING TICKED IT EIGHTY DOLLARS ($80.00) IN ADAMSVILLE AND IN SELMER THEN A FAMILIAR SCENARIO RAISED ITS HEAD AGAIN.  The fact is, everyone knows that the total road and highway mileage is beyond what can be monitored, with the current budget of the city there by presenting a natural and logical equation called CHANCE-IT.  The big rigs as well as business traffic accepts the fine of eighty dollars ($80.00) just part of COST OF DOING BUSINESS - SO ---- IN ORDER TO GREATLY IMPROVE HIGHWAY SAFETY AS WELL AS IMPROVING THE CITY'S IMAGE WOULD BE TO PUT TEETH IN OUR TRAFFIC LAWS BY AND I SUBMIT A PROPOSAL FOR RAISING THE DOLLAR VALUE OF SPEEDING TICKETS TO TWO HUNDRED SIXTY FIVE DOLLARS ($265.00) FOR THE FIRST OFFENSE.  (NOT ONE PENNY LESS!)  What this increase will do is 1.) remove the condition of CHANCE-IT, 2.) Create safer driving for all who use the streets and highways within the surrounding areas and 3.) Improve the image of the city of Adamsville to one of respect rather THEN BEING INDIFFERENT TO ENDANGERING HUMAN LIFE (OR WORSE)

THAT LAST STATEMENT SHOULD CAUSE CONCERN AS WELL AS PROMPT ACTION SINCE THIS IS PROVIDED AS NOTICE RELATING TO THE WELL-BEING OF ME AND MY FAMILY.

This is submitted with respect and with no malice.

William M. Marts

When it was explained to him that the fines the town could impose were limited by state law, Marts replied, "I think something's got to be done.  I was going to start here, but I look around and there's no problem here.  You people, your hands are tied.  They're tied.  And these people that are dictating are the ones I want to go after.  This should be administrated and not dictated.  In other words, an administrator, you come down, you talk to people, you review the area and say, oh, actually these people are trying to stand in the middle of the road to get their mail [several unintelligible words] actually I'll explain.  We gotta change this.  Well, that's what I'm going to try to do."

"More power to you, buddy," the mayor said, before addressing another person in the audience: "Did you have something you wanted to speak about?"

"I'm Marty Ganster," the man said.  "I know this has been brought up, probably many times before.  What can we do with the loose wild dog problem?  I mean, we have dog running all over the place"

"Well, that's a tough situation here in town," the mayor agreed, and Thrasher restated comments that he had made at previous meetings. "The SPCA said in this meeting, months ago, made us an offer, how much they would pick up each dog for us.  We agreed on it, and they got out here and they've got dogs up the kazoo.  Ain't room to put a mouse in there.  And so until they get some way to get rid of some dogs, there's no place for them to put a dog, if they catch a dog.  And the city doesn't have anything to do.  We don't have a kennel or a pen or anything.  So, I don't know what to tell you."

Police Chief Bill McCall said that, "if you know the owner of that dog we can write him an $80 ticket."

In the discussion that followed Garrison suggested registering dogs and Lacey suggested issuing tags, but no action was taken before the meeting finally adjourned.




Town Board Meeting

17 December 2007


Perhaps because of the season, Adamsville's December town board meeting was appreciably less acrimonious than meetings in the recent past.  The board members didn't exactly hold hands and sing Cum By Yah, but they did manage by and large to disagree without being disagreeable about it, which made for a nice change.

The board began by unanimously approving, in each instance on a motion by Frank Lacey, seconded by Jeff Browder, the minutes of the November meeting and the financial reports.


Police Report

During the discussion of the police report, Dwana Garrison asked Police Chief Bill McCall how many police were currently in the department.  Upon being told there were six, she then asked how many were in the department ten years ago.

"Seven, I believe," McCall responded.

Garrison, pointing out that "our town has grown quite a bit in the last ten years, and we went down in officers," asked the chief if he would ascertain what is the ratio of officers to population in comparable towns.

"I've got a break down of towns our size," Mayor Tommy Morris interjected, "and most of the towns our size have got 4.5 police officers."

Chief McCall acknowledged that he could use some more manpower. "Area-wise, I'll just tell all you board members, we're stretched.  We've got a lot of area to cover.  We try to cover every thing on each shift.  I require them to make one trip around.  We've got a lot of area to cover.  When you've got one officer on, he's out there on Meeks Loop and he gets a call here in town, it takes a while to get back.  We're pretty well stretched out."


BP Museum

Garrison informed the board that "tomorrow [December 18] we have Dr. Van Morris coming from the University of Tennessee, historic preservation, he heads it up, and it takes him for ever to get him to be able to come to this, and he said that one of the reasons he wanted to come is he thought it had really been looked over, and he was coming himself.  So I'm excited about that.  What he will do tomorrow, we'll meet over there, Debbie will come some time to see the museum.  He's going to look at stuff, and his team, and he'll tell us, Mayor, what's the most important things that need to be preserved, what's deteriorating."  Garrison explained "that we're losing monetary value of the items themselves that are there…. Plus they'll tell us where we can go to get the funding, hopefully some of it 100% in grants, maybe, to do some of this.  If not, it's just kind of deteriorating on its own, so I'm just really glad he's coming tomorrow."


Hwy 64 West Property Sale

After unanimously approving all reports, on a motion by Lacey, seconded by Garrison, the board next turned to a matter that has been a regular part of recent board meetings—the sale of property on Hwy 64.

Town Manager Terry Thrasher asked Town Attorney Ken Seaton to comment on an advisory letter he had prepared regarding the sale.

"I hope the letter was clear," Seaton said.  "I just tried to express that I think there needs to be an open discussion about the decision that it appears the commission is going to make in selling this property to [Brandi Graham].  As you know, there was a, what I interpreted to be an offer from another citizen here at the last meeting for $10,000, and the price that's been discussed, the sale price for Graham is $8,000, and my concern was that that might create some questions among the citizens in the community, that it deserved just a little discussion, and I think that that's not been openly done.  I'm not involved in the decision to sell this property to Brandi.  It's this legislative body that is here, wants to do that.  And I'm fine with it.  But I just, my concern was that there just needed to be a little discussion, public discussion, about the merits of selling to this particular company, and I think the public ought to be aware of those reasons.  So I wrote the letter.  I wish that there could be a little explanation given for everyone's benefit."

Mayor Morris argued that the Hwy 64 property was similar to property the city owns in the industrial park. "The way I see it, we do the same thing with the industrial park out here.  A person comes up and wants this piece of property, we don't put it up for auction.  I consider maybe this the same thing, that a person has offered money for this lot.  They're ready to build, and it's going to bring in a lot, I think a lot of sales tax, and maybe put a lot of people to work.  I don't see where there would be any, but I'm not a lawyer, where there'd be any conflict.  If it was, it would go back to our industrial park."  The Mayor observed that if the town takes to playing potential purchasers off against each other,   "You're not never going to gain nothing."

Seaton replied that "I'm not suggesting there's a conflict, and I'm not suggesting there's a problem.  The letter simply attempted to suggest that the public needs to hear that.  That the public, we don't, the public doesn't have to hear that.  The commission can vote on this sale, and there be zero discussion about it.  But I got a call, or two different individuals mentioned some concern to me about this, and I felt like the way to address those complaints and those concerns was for what you just said to be said at this meetings.  And that way anyone who's here, who has concerns or complaints about any decision the commission might make to sell this property for $8,000, that that's the explanation."
   
Seaton's letter also suggested including a clause in the sales contract by which title to the land would revert to the city if Graham did not have a functioning business in place on the site within twelve months.  The city would also retain $2,000 of the $8,000 purchase price.  Seaton pointed out that "that requires attention on the city's part.  If twelve months go by from the execution of the deed and the building's not completed, that there's an additional step that the city has to take, and we all need to be aware of that and remember that and not go to sleep twelve months from now if no building's there, because if thirty days go by our rights are gone."

"Thirty days?" Garrison asked.  "We only have thirty days—"

"Thirty days from the end of the twelve month period of time," Seaton explained.  "Now, that's open to discussion.  At the last meeting I think Terry was directed, maybe I was directed, to try to put something together along these lines, and this is what he and I came up with, and if the city wants to move forward with this transaction there needs to be a vote.  Terry and I came up with those numbers, and that amount of time."

Mike Norris then raised another issue.  "It was my understanding that—and I want to get past the price, I didn't agree with the price, but we want business to come into town, so I'll go past that issue—but it was my understanding that this particular potential land, or property owner here was supposed to present drawings, formal drawings, as to what kind of business that they were going to have, and how it was supposed to look and all that, and that we were not obligated to sell the property until we saw that and agreed on it."  Norris complained that all Graham had come up with was "a pencil drawing."

"She said that if we sold this land she would get the drawings," Morris said.

"Well," Norris replied, "that's getting the cart before the horse, in my opinion."

Thrasher then pointed out that "the city building and zoning and regulation rules state that before she builds it she has to bring in front of the planning commission a plat plan drawn by a surveyor or an engineer."

Norris persisted: "If she wants to put down some earnest money, we'll hold the land for her.  That's the way you would do it for anybody like that that wants to buy some property, and then let her present the drawings and such as to how this thing looks."

Mayor said he was concerned about the delay. "Well, I believe we might be miss something if we don't go ahead and give this girl the okay.  If she don't come up with them drawings, she can't build, so in a year it will come back to us.  What she's paying us is earnest money, and she can, if she hasn't done anything within a year, then we've got thirty days to file that and get the land back."

Browder then entered the discussion. "Well, if we sell her this property, she has got to come up with some form of drawing, like you say, that will meet our code before she'll be given a building permit, am I correct?"

Thrasher agreed, and Browder then remarked, "There you go," as though that settled it.

Norris did not agree. "Well, you don't have that in writing, and you don't have her signature on it.  If you sign that deed, she can do anything she wants to as long she builds within a year.  She can build a shack."

Browder persisted, saying, "Our motion was that she comply with the economic development board guidelines.  She has to meet our building code before she'll be given a building permit."

"Again," Norris said, "I say let her put some earnest money down, take an option on the land, and if she's serious, come up with a plan."

"Well, is that not basically what we're doing?" Browder asked.

"No, that's a warranty deed you're fixing to sign," Norris replied.  "I want to know what she's going to build, and what it's going to look like.  You know, she's fixing to build a truck stop where they're going to fix trucks and maintain truck, and it's going to get awful oily and awful greasy, and it could get ugly."

Lacey then raised another concern. "Are we in jeopardy here of discriminating against this individual, based on the way we do other city properties?  Do we require everyone that goes to the industrial park to present these in the past?  That would be my question."

"We usually give them away," Garrison remarked.  "But now we're selling it, because it's on the state highway, which is a little bit different."

Lacey said he didn't have a problem with the pencil drawing Graham had presented. "It's typical of what we see people bring into the bank requesting loans for, so I see this a lot and have to work through these issues that Mike is, I need more specifics, this that and the other, but you know you also have to look at it from the city's standpoint.  If we're going to require her to do more work than we have required other people, then we're putting ourselves out there, you know, for a discrimination lawsuit that we don't need to be involved in either.  Now—"

"Well," Norris interjected, "you're already discriminating because you have another person to offer more money than she did for it."

"After the fact," Lacey replied.

"You don't have a contract signed," Norris countered.

After some further back and forth, Seaton suggested that "maybe if the commission took some formal action tonight, maybe she would present this type of plan, this more detailed plan, that Mike would like to see, and maybe, uh—  If she's convinced we're going to sell it to her if there's an adequate plan or drawing or whatever presented, then maybe she'd do a better job of presenting, then maybe she'd do a better job of presenting the type of plan that Mike is looking for."

"Well, I'd be like her," the mayor said.  "I wouldn't spend a lot of money on a set of plans if—"

"That's what I'm saying," Seaton interjected.  "And maybe if she were more confident that the commission was ready to move forward, maybe she would do that."

Thrasher then reentered the discussion.  "Mayor, let me see if we can cut to the chase a little.  If you look under the reversionary clause that Mr. Seaton has put in here. Look down five lines.  'Provided within said one year period of time,' and install there a sentence that Mr. Seaton can word up for us, that the plat plan and building design must be approved by the Adamsville Planning Commission.  But get a sentence in here, and then we'll take this back to her.  She's expecting us to make a decision tonight.  If we make that decision, and Mr. Seaton can add up a blurb or a sentence in here, when we contact her, she'll read this, and she's got to approve it, too," he said, pointing out that "she hasn't signed anything.  So, verbally she says this sounds good to her, and she didn't mind the 25% 'restocking charge,' I called it in here.  But I'm just wondering why we can't put a sentence in—"

"Why do we want to do anything to it?" Mayor Morris asked.  "If he's wrote it up, and it sounds good, present it to her.  If she wants it, let's go with it."

"Well," Thrasher replied, "I'm just saying, for Mike and the planning commission and everybody's peace of mind, put a blurb in here that this has to pass the planning commission—"

"Maybe everybody would feel better about it then," Garrison interjected.

"The thing is," Lacey remarked, returning to his point, "my fear is that, you know, we're setting a precedent, that if you come here and apply to buy a piece of property from the city, or even just to get a building plan submitted, you're going to have to jump through all these hoops, and, you know, why not just go to one of the other local communities around here?  They're not going to make you do all that."

"Just right down the road," Mayor Morris agreed.  "They can put up a building and not have to get nothing.  We're hurting ourselves, tell you what we're doing, trying to get these—"

"Do we not have to," Browder asked, "when somebody builds something, I mean I thought that was the whole gist behind building permits and the whole nine yards, I mean, there are regulations already in place, through the building codes, for these things, are they not?"

"Yes," Thrasher responded.

"You know," Browder said, "if she's willing to comply to those codes, and part of that process is submitting a drawing that's going to show us what this place is going to look like, and it's going to meet the codes already in place, I'm kind of like Frank.  You know, if we're requiring one person to go above and beyond our code and the others aren’t, then I think we're putting ourselves in a bind.  You know, if we need to amend and tweak on our code, then we need to do that before we start enforcing it."

At last, Lacey said, "I make a motion that we proceed to put that blurb that Terry said, in that clause, provisionary clause, and that we approve this contract subject to that being put in there."  The motion, seconded by Garrison, carried by unanimous voice vote.


Water Study

Utility Director Paul Wallace Plunk then introduced Shannon Cotter.  "I told you last month that I would get somebody here from Barge Waggoner to explain this water modeling plan, and Shannon's here to take care of that tonight."

As indeed she was. "Thank you," Cotter said, as she launched into a long explanation of the need for and purpose of the water study.  "I think I've met each of you.  I met the new commissioner a couple of weeks ago at the Delta Regional Authority awards.  Congratulations on your Delta grant.  Congratulations on your CDBG grant [for an] elevated storage tank.  One of the benefits of getting your grants is there's some incidentals that have to come with it.  And one of those things, we've talked to Paul I guess, Paul, I guess when the application was done last February, the need for a water model to determine the exact location of where this elevated storage tank needs to go.  By ethics, and by being a good steward of state money, federal money, and your money, we cannot go out there and place an elevated tank without some sort of official water model.  And the need for that being, is, you already know it needs to be in the northern portion, because of where the congregation of you population is and the fact that you're using booster pumps as they stood today.  A water model can go into effect and evaluate the existing pressure, the existing users, and how they operate—how the system is operating altogether as a unit to determine where that tank needs to be, and how and what the elevation of the tank needs to be.  If you just go out there and set this tank, you could have several things to happen.  The tank may not fill properly, it may not give you the adequate pressure that you need for fire protection ….  It's a endless gauntlet of problems.  And based upon the data that the water department gave us, and we prepared your engineer report for your block grant application that we submitted last February, we began to realize real quick that the water study that McNairy County had done three years ago?  That may not have been the exact date, but on that water model map, or that water system map that they had, they had 'proposed location of tank.'  No specific location of the tank.  And it all hinged on a water line that McNairy County had applied for as well.  Unfortunately, McNairy County did not get that water line.  So once again, it's, y'all's situation is, much more important now to have a water model to ties these things together to make sure that you're not wasting your money, to put this tank in the proper location at the proper elevation.  And I don't want you to think that this is just something that we just come to you at the last minute and say here's an opportunity, let's go get more money.  It's not been like that.  We have talked with Paul about it since the git go, the importance of it.  And this is not something that once you do you won't ever use it again.  This is information that can be updated periodically.  Once Paul and his department has the factual information, it can be a good record-keeping quantitative type of study that gives you good concrete information, instead of just shooting in the dark and speculating about how something should be our how it should operate.  I submitted it to Paul in writing, it was eighteen-five [$18,500].  That was for the water model and a count for identifying the houses on the system.  Which once again is a map that y'all can use forever and ever and ever …. We told him once we got the okay from y'all it's something that could be finished in 60 days."

"Can I ask you one thing?" Mayor Morris asked. "This grant we just got.  For a water tank.  Could it be used for a ground-level tank?"

"If that's justified, yes," Cotter replied.  "It's just simply going to them and explaining to them why you would want a ground tank instead of an elevated tank.  I don't think they're going to sit there and say, 'Oh, no, you didn't tell us that in the application, we're going to pull [it.]'"

"Well," the mayor said, launching into a familiar theme, "what I'm looking at, we've got a problem before we ever start with putting up another water tank.  We've got to get the water from the field to our filtering plant.  We've got a grant to do the filtering plant.  All right, we need a, say, a million gallon ground tank out there by the filtering system so we can manufacture water, put it into this ground tank and put high service pumps on it, and then we'll have, pump it out into what storage tanks we've already got."

"Would that water model show that?" Lacey asked.

"There's various components of all that," Cotter responded.  "Will that specifically address that?  I don't know if Bryant has told Paul yes or no to that question.  Has that come up? That's not never been mentioned to me."

"It hasn't been presented to us," Plunk said.

"I'm the only one that's mentioned it," Morris said, then he continued.  "I tell you what we're really after, we're needing the storage capacity, and a ground tank would give us more high service pump function, and then we could work from this ground level tank to upgrading our other lines in the ground that's been there since 'forty-six.  But, see, we can't get no lower fire ratings because we can't, we haven't got the flow in our fire hydrants."

Cotter replied, "Now I do know for a fact that, let's say you don't do a tank, a storage capacity of some sort.  You have to get that done first.  If you have funds left over, then you can do something with your lines.   You can simply ask for that.  They're not going to let you stray away from a storage capacity for something new.  I do know that."

"I understand that," Morris replied.  "We need the storage.  But what I'm trying to get away from, too, is this high maintenance for these above ground tanks."

"That's understandable," Cotter said.  "But then you do have to have a maintenance contract on these and they have to be inspected every three years."

"Oh, yeah," Morris said, "we're paying $6,000 a month for a maintenance contract."

Browder then remarked, "There's going to have to be maintenance performed on a ground tank—"

"Well, yeah," the mayor replied, "but our men can do that.  It's on the ground.  Half of it would be in the ground."  Turning back to Cotter, he said, "That's something I'd like for you to look into, to give options, because, you know, anything we can do to—  Because we've got to, just like I say, there's no reason going out there and putting up an elevated tank if we can't supply it.  And we're just wasting our time."

Cotter made another suggestion. "Well, there's also a possibility, to interject this, but there's some pumps that are in the area of the northern part right now.  If the water model reveals that it needs to go on X road by Y road, there's a possibility that those booster pumps can be cut out and not even have to be used.  That's a maintenance issue, it's an electrical issue."

"But," Lacey asked, "this water model that's going to cost us $18,500 will show us, as a body of commissioners, the best decision that we can make—"

Shannon: "That is correct."

Lacey: "—for this area."

Shannon: "It takes out your opinion and my opinion.  It's based on concrete data."

"I'm not an expert on water," Lacey admitted, "but I would like to, as a citizen, and as a business man in town, to be assured that if my building caught on fire or my house caught on fire there would be enough water and pressure to take care of it.  And I think that's been a question in a lot of our minds."

"You're required by law to have a reliable water source and twenty-four hours storage capacity," Cotter said.

"And it would be nice if we got our fire rating down so we could—" Lacey began.

"That fire rating is what I'm after," agreed the mayor.

"But this water model will show all that, right?" Lacey asked, and Cotter acknowledged that it would.

Morris then introduced another consideration.  "I got a call from the county commissioners today, and they're going to apply for a grant again, you know, to try to get the money to close that gap, in the northern part of our system.  But it's left up to this commission if they want them to."

Thrasher explained that this particular grant had been turned down three years running, and there was some discussion about the possibility that other grant monies might not be utilized while waiting, perhaps fruitlessly, for that grant to be finally approved.

Morris then said, "I think we need to start to work these three places.  Work from the wells, bring us another line in from the wells, then we've done got the grant for the filtering system, and we've got this $500,000 to build the water storage tank."

Plunk observed, "I think the grant is to refurbish the existing filters, and also upgrade the controls.  It's not for new filters.  Am I wrong?"

Morris said he had been told "it was for new filters."

"I can tell you," Cotter said, looking through her files.  "Hang on just one second.  It's to remove and replace the existing pneumatic control system, it's to blast, clean, weld and repair and repaint existing pressure filters, and to remove and replace existing pressure media, excuse me, filter media, and the pressure filters, and to do the components related to those three things only."

"But it's not to add any more filters," Plunk said.

"That is correct," Cotter confirmed.

Plunk then raised a further complication.  "Well, storage is very important to the town of Adamsville.  Whether it be in ground, above ground, or wherever it be, because right now we have five subdivisions that's going in or already in.  One of them is inside the city limits, four of them is in the surrounding area of the city limits.  Those five subdivisions has 158 lots in them, and using the rule of thumb that engineers use for, 5,000 gallons per household, per month, that's, if they were all filled up, and houses on them, that's 790,000 gallons of water a month more that's going to be used, above what you're using now."

Garrison then moved that the board authorize Barge, Sumner and Waggoner to perform the water study and her motion, seconded by Norris, passed on a unanimous roll call vote.


Health Insurance

Thrasher reminded the board members that they had discussed insurance at an earlier meeting and had decided to wait until the end of the year to make a decision.  He said that the town is presently paying $339.61 per employee per month for health insurance.  That cost will rise to $360.92 per month if the town keeps its current coverage, which has a deductible of $1,500 and total out of pocket expense of $2,000.  Thrasher told the board that if those limits were raised to $2,500 and $3,000 respectively, "we could get insurance coverage for $327.72, which is about twelve bucks a month per employee less than we are paying now.  And that's basically a decision that y'all need to make."

Lacey asked who pays these premiums, and Thrasher explained that it is paid "by the city for the employee.  The same coverage is available is available for his or her wife or spouse, at the same cost."

Thrasher explained that the actual cost to city's thirty-three insured employees would not increase. "What we did a few years ago, when we did the same thing, raised the deductible, the city agreed to pick up and underwrite, when the employee goes over his deductible, which would be fifteen hundred, if he goes over it again this year the city would pickup that thousand dollar overage.  It has to be paid to the doctor, clinic, hospital.  It can't go to the employee.  In doing that, if we have five or less employees that go over their deductible, the city will be money ahead.  If six of them happen to go over it, we'll start losing money.  We've never had more than four go over it," and last year only three went over it.

"It's worked out good for us so far," Mayor Morris remarked.  "It's really saved us a lot of money over the years."

The town's insurance agent, Billy Max Majors, was in the audience, and he told the board that the only increase the employees would see would be in the co-pay for office visits, which would increase from $25 per visit to $30.

After the various board members had raised and discussed a number of questions among themselves and with Majors, Norris made a motion that the board adopt Thrasher's recommendation.

"And one good thing about this," added Majors, who had mentioned that one city employee was going to be undergoing expensive medical procedures shortly, which would cause an increase in the group rate, "is that it's guaranteeing this rate for another year."

In the further discussion, audience member John Liddy questioned whether the board had handled the issue in a timely fashion.  "I don't come to y'all's meetings very often," he said.  "There's not a really good football game on tonight, so I thought I'd slip up here.  But this is the third meeting that I've been to that y'all have had this exact same discussion.  And I think, Mike [Norris], a year ago, didn't you sit in, sort of outside the commission meeting and really get into it and figure something out and come back.  I mean, you got to make a decision, obviously, but long term, I mean that's why we elected y'all, is for you guys to roll your sleeves up and really jump into these things.  Not wait until the city commission meeting on Monday night at seven o'clock to say—"

"What would you like for us to do, John?" Norris asked.

"Well," Liddy replied, "you know, you're saying is there not another way?  Well, I mean, how about last week asking that question?  How long have we waited, and I understand—"

"Some of us have been asking that question," Garrison interjected.

"Sure," Liddy said.  "I mean, now you've got somebody in the hospital, and your rate will go up between now and probably when he gets out, so you've got to make a decision now.  But, I mean, that's why we elect y'all, to not wait until Monday night at seven o'clock—"

Liddy was interrupted in mid-sentence by Majors, who acted as though Liddy wasn't even there: "$327 nowadays for medical coverage is not high," he said, and the board members appeared pleased to have the subject changed from Libby's criticism.  "No, it's not," Mayor Morris said, as Norris agreed, "It's pretty cheap."

"I want to second's Mike's motion," Lacey then said, and the motion passed on a unanimous roll call vote.

Lacey then said, "I'd like to make a motion that we form a committee of maybe the mayor, one commissioner, Jimmie Ann, Debbie, Terry, and an employee, between now and this time next year to get with, you know, the insurance people, and come up with alternate plans for the city and present that, present those alternate plans to us for us to vote on, as opposed to just, you know, having one choice to choose from.  And that committee doesn't have to meet until three months prior to the policy being renewed, but at that time—"

Majors replied, "Well, we had Blue Cross representatives in, and she has given us about seven or eight options, and me and Jimmie Ann and Debbie and Terry got together and felt like these two options was the best of the ones she'd given us.  I mean they, I've got eight options here, but we felt like, for this group, a small group, 33 is a small group, really, that this was the best for the city at this time."

Norris then addressed Liddy. "John, to answer your question a little more, we did form a committee and researched this back in the summer, with Ann Hudson."

"And we done that in August," Majors said.  "And the only thing we were going to do in August, was to change our year-end policy.  We met with Blue Cross people, me and Ann and Debbie and Terry and Jimmie Ann and come up with those different scenarios, then approved it, and then the question was for tonight was to change the year end policy, year to year, so that we wouldn't have double deduction for some people—"

"The reason that we're even talking about this is because of the renewal date," Norris interjected, and Majors agreed.

"So," Norris concluded, "to answer your question: We did our job."

Norris then seconded Lacey's motion to form a committee, and it passed on a unanimous voice vote.

"Now when it comes time for that meeting to be called, we can just wait until then to pick the committee," the mayor said, and Garrison agreed: "That'll be fine."

"Am I correct in assuming that this committee is going to have performed their function and come back to us in September?" asked Browder.  "I just don't want us to let this slide back on the back burner and all of a sudden say—"

When the discussion showed some signs of reviving, Thrasher finally nipped it in the bud.  "Let's move on," he said, and they did.


Sewer Pond Odor

Norris informed the board that he had " had a couple of our citizens to call, or stop me and complain, and we've got one right back, two back here right now [referring to Charles Moore and Larry Flowers, in the audience] that are here, and that's what they want to talk about.  I have asked Mr. Thrasher about it, so I think that he's the one that needs to respond to that.  And maybe Mr. Plunk would be—"

Thrasher said, "Mr. Plunk would be better to address it, but we have got an enzyme chemical base company that's sending us, the mayor signed the check last week, the first part of last week.  We've checked with Parsons, and who else?  Two or three cities of our surrounding neighbors, they think this is the grandest thing since peanut butter.  What we usually do is put in, is it ammonium nitrate, or sodium nitrate?  When the weather changes from warm to cold, or cold to warm, the pond does what the experts say 'turns.'  Twice a year.  And when it does, when we start getting complaints, we pour this ammonium nitrate, it's not ammonium nitrate, it's fertilizer."

"It ain't working," Moore said.

"We haven't poured it in there yet," Thrasher said.  "We're waiting on the chemical.  The chemical that we're buying, we don't put as much in, and we put it in more regular, and it stops the odor, increases the BODs [dodecylammonium bentonite], and lets us do several things besides just stop the odor."

"Well," Norris asked, "can you not put anything in there right now, to stop the odor?"

"No," Thrasher said, "because if we put this fertilizer in there it's going to mess up our new chemical coming in.  We can't put it in on top of the fertilizer."

"That's the reason," Plunk agreed.  "Yes, we could have stopped the smell, but I've been working on this for two years.  Knowing, I've had a wastewater specialist in here from Georgia that looked at this lagoon, told us a year ago what we needed to do.  Nobody let me do that, and I said, okay, I'm going to have hands off, and when it gets to smelling bad enough somebody will let me do something."

"Well," Mayor Morris asked, "what was you wanting to do?"

"I wanted to what we're fixing to do now," Plunk replied.

"I didn't know nothing about it," the mayor said.
 
"I went to my superior," Plunk responded, indicating town manager Thrasher.

Norris then resumed. "I don't know how bad it is at y'all's place [indicating Moore and Flowers], but Kip Pettigrew called me, or cornered me the other day and said that it was all in his house, he can't get it out of his furniture, and he's really upset.  It's made him sick."

"My question is," Lacey began, "you mentioned a while ago five different subdivisions, with how many houses?"

"158 lots," Plunk responded.

"If they are fortunate enough to be able to tie into the sewer, are we prepared—" Lacey began again.

"We're not going to be," the mayor interjected.

Plunk replied, "Some of those would be."

"My question is," Lacey started again, "are we going to be able to more subdivisions, more businesses, if we do this?"

Thrasher responded, "If we get the DOB down, what's the other one that's 45, that we just barely meet?  There's two or three options that's been given.  One is clean out the old sewer pond, which means we've got to drain it, dredge it, doze it out, to pay the landfill cost, and hope that there's not a leak in it that we would have to put a liner in.  Then we could also go to aeration.  Aeration is expensive, and you pay electric bills for the rest of your natural life."

"Well," Garrison interjected, "if it's going to take the smell away, that electric bill might be worth it, I guarantee it."

Plunk said, "TAUD [Tennessee Association of Utility Districts] for several years didn't recommend doing this, but they do recommend it now, because it's been working for different people.  So TAUD now says, yes, you ought to do it."

"Well, let's give that a try, then," the mayor said.

"When's it going to come in?" Garrison asked.  "Do we have any idea?"

"It's ordered, and should be in, it might be in this week," Plunk replied.

"Now I know we have written a check for that," Browder asked, "but what's the amount of the check?"

"Fifty-three hundred dollars," Plunk replied.

"And how long a treatment is that?" Browder asked/

"That's about six months," Plunk said.  "Once you get it to the point that you want it, then you have to periodically keep putting chemicals into it, but not this initial dose."

"I think this is the cheapest way to see if it will work," Mayor Morris observed.  "If it don't work, then we'll really have to get into it."

Plunk said there was an added benefit.  "These chemicals also will do away with some sludge.  The only way you can get rid of all the sludge is dredging.  But these chemicals will cut down on maybe ten years of dredging.  It won't completely get it away, but it will prolong the time that you have to dredge."

Charles Moore spoke up again.  "My question is, it's sort of like your bathroom.  If you just keep adding air freshener you'll finally override the bad smell."

"Well," Plunk said, "that's what we had been doing in the past.  That's what's been done."

Moore continued. "You know that as soon as the air freshener dies down, you've still got the smell of your commode there.  That down there, it's been going on a long time.  I hate to, seems like y'all have got plenty of problems without mine here, but the thing about it is, I'm telling you, that's bad.  It's not something to talk about up here, I believe it's a law against that.  I'm telling you, if my septic tank run out on the top of the ground down there until it stunk the neighbor up the road out, I think there's a problem, and I think I could get it solved, by calling the health department.  That can't be good for you.  My customers are complaining about the scent they're smelling when they come in my business.   People drive all the way from Jackson to buy a chain saw, and when they get there, 'What in the world have you done down here, man?'  Now that's pitiful.  And this has been going on, like you said, for two years.  I've complained lightly.  I'm making a formal complaint tonight.  I think it's time something's done, and not air freshening."

"Well," Plunk insisted, "we will, I'm telling you, we have started.  We have started and we—"

"In other words," Moore asked, "I should see a difference in two or three weeks?" 1235

"When we get those chemicals in there you should, yes," Plunk replied.

Moore persisted. "When these chemicals are put in, it's going to solve the problem?"

Thrasher came to Plunk's assistance.  "The first day you would get with the chemicals would be a decrease in the odor.  What we will do, because of the odor, instead of putting it in, is we'll get in the boat and go out here and spot 'em, and stir it in, and speed the action up.  Now, from the time they get in the boat and put "X" scoopfuls in "X" spots, so when the odor goes away, I can't tell you.  But he says the first thing you'll notice is a lack of odor."

Moore had another complaint.  "And another thing about the sewer system that goes down there, when the city hired all them gravel trucks to go down there, they broke our sewer line.  And I've had to call them down there different times, to ream it out, you know.  That sewer line is broke in there, where it goes into the road.  I was out there the last time they done it."

"That's news to me," Plunk began.  "That's the first I've—"

Moore continued. "The employee that reamed it out told me about it and he said, 'we need to fix that one of these days.'"

"It's never come to my attention until now," Plunk insisted.

Garrison says she's frustrated that the employee didn't report the problem, and then said, "Well, we'll get a work order on that ASAP, and you know the other is coming in, Mr. Moore."

But Moore wasn't finished.  "Here's my concern.  I'm fixing to spend a lot of money down there at them buildings.  I've bought the buildings down below it, and I'm wanting to move to this other building.  But if it don't get no better, I'm ready to sell that and buy property somewhere else.  And that's not a threat; that's just a fact.  I'm not going to keep smelling that junk, because I'm too old to smell it."

At this point Moore was joined by Larry Flowers. "Well, I've been there since '91.  I've got the same problem he's got.  A customer come in from all over, get out of their car and there just, you know, like this.  I've called the city in the past and it's just like, 'Well, yeah, we know.  That just happens so often, you know.  It turns over.'  But I'm glad you're doing something now, but it's a shame that Mr. Plunk mentioned this a year ago, there was a chance to do something, we didn't get on it then and do it.  If everyone here had lived down there where I live and had to stay there every day.  And like I say, the furniture just absorbs it.  I bought an indoor air freshener that just runs 24 hours a day trying to take the odor out of it.  It gets inside the shop, I means it just hangs up there.  It gets in my bed.  It's just pitiful."

"The problem is," Lacey said, summing up, "it's always stunk.  It's always going to stink.  We've just got to learn how to manage the stink."

Plunk said, "All we've done is put a little nitrate in it twice a year, to keep the smell down.  And that will take care of the smell, but it won't take care DOBs and these other things that these chemicals will take care of besides the smell."

"We're going to give that a try," the mayor said.  "Let's move on.  We’re going to work on that, Charles."


Money to Airport

Thrasher reported that he had gotten "a call from the Selmer mayor [David Robinson].  The airport has gotten fifty-something thousand dollars in grant money, and they have to match it, and they don't have any money, according to the Selmer mayor.  And the guy that knows David said he didn't know anybody over here, and David said, 'Well, I'll call somebody for you.'  They want us to give them some money to help them match the grant."

The grant in question was a ten-percent matching grant in the amount of $55,000, which was to be used for completing the fencing of the airport, the matching portion of which would be $5,500.

After some brief discussion, Norris made a motion "that we provide half of the grant, or the half of the match," but his motion died from the lack of a second.

Lacey then said, "I would like to make a motion that we authorize Terry to negotiate the best deal for us to ensure that other communities are included and pay up to half."

Garrison spoke in favor of the motion, "Because we're going to use it, more than likely, more than anybody else, since we're the next biggest municipality in the county."

Russell Ingle, from the Independent Appeal, then said, "I talked to Chris Tull a week or so ago about this and he shared with me that if these improvements or additions were not made they could face federal sanctions and possible closure until they were done."

"I want to see us help the airport all we can," Lacey said.  "I want to be sure that we don't commit to more than we need to, but we commit what we need to.  And I think we ought to give Terry the authority—"

Thrasher said, "I'll try and get a hold of Chris and find out."

Browder seconds motion, which passes on unanimous roll call vote.


Cable Consultant

Thrasher told the board that he had just been contacted by a cable consultant who claimed that he could save the town some money. "This guy called me, and then faxed me this information.  I really think my suggestion would be, since I just got it after the package went out, is that this be tabled until next month and that y'all have a chance to read through it.  This guy did a lot of work for MTAS and TML on the deal with AT&T and cable franchises, and he's got a deal where he will come in and check what we receive from Charter as our franchise fee and show us ways that we can get more money out of it.  And the problem I see with it is if he shows you that they ought to have paid you three thousand more dollars a year for the last five years, that's fifteen grand, he wants half of it.  So you're paying that, betting on the come, that you're going to get the same $3,000 for the next time.  And I feel like that his savings ought to be taken out of our future savings, not what he saves us in the past.  But I would think that you guys ought to look at this, and we ought to table it until next month."

After a brief discussion the board voted unanimously, on a motion by Browder, seconded by Norris, to table the matter until the next month's meeting.


MTAS/TML Ordinance/Charter

Browder reported that "Through our education seminar that we attended a month and a half ago, or so, everybody knows that our charter is nearing in on twenty years old.  And we were speaking with Ronnie Neal, he had offered his services, to come down and go through the charter.  I feel that we really need to do this, to bring our charter into a better compliance with the way we are now doing business.  I feel like our ordinance book, our codebook needs to be brought up to snuff.  And I make a motion that we invite Ronnie Neal to perform the services he talked about and to go over our charter and our ordinance book to make sure that we are doing what we need to be doing."

Mayor Morris asked if it costs anything, and Browder replied, "I don't think he charges us anything."  Thrasher explained that Adamsville was a member of MTAS, and the dues covered the service.

Thrasher suggested that the consultation not take place during the town board's regular meeting, "because you're talking about a long period of time," and the board agreed that Thrasher should work a time for a special meeting with Neal.


Finally ...

Before the mayor could adjourn the meeting, Thrasher spoke up again.  "I wanted to bring one other thing to y'all's attention.  John [Liddy] and I went to Waynesboro and heard about a 'safe route to school program' that TDOT has available for $250,000 of no-match money.  So what I think that what we need to do is try for one of those, because we've got a lot of traffic congestion over at the schools, and I think we ought to get Mr. Liddy on this committee and be thinking maybe a school principal, a teacher, chief of police—"

Lacey said, "I make a motion that we authorize Terry to form that committee to pursue that grant."  Norris seconds, passes unanimously.

The Mayor tried again to adjourn the meeting, but Charles Moore had a question about replacing a sign that had been blown off his business.  Thrasher explained that if it was a non-conforming sign which was being replaced, then the sign would have to be approved by the zoning board and be in compliance with zoning regulations before it could be replaced, but that Moore would only have to pay one $25 fee.

And then the meeting was finally adjourned.


Town Board Meeting

19 November 2007

Editorial Comment

It's been a good year for Frank Lacey.  Earlier this year he was elevated to the chairmanship of the McNairy County School Board, and earlier this month he was elected to a seat on the Adamsville Town Board.  Then, just over an hour into his first town board meeting Monday night, he was elected vice mayor (albeit with a marked lack of enthusiasm by his fellow aldermen), and just a few minutes after that he was enthusiastically promoting himself for a proposed new seat on the McNairy County Economic Development Board.  (Were the office of Emperor of the Universe to come open tomorrow, there can be little doubt who would be the first to offer—magnanimously, of course—to assume the mantle.)

It is far less certain, however, that what has been good for Frank Lacey will be good for either the McNairy County School System or the City of Adamsville.  In his eagerness to promote his own interests, Lacey has put himself in the position of being unable to fully perform the duties of either of the elective offices he now holds.  On the one hand, as a member of the McNairy County School Board he is obliged to fairly and impartially promote the interests of all of the county schools.  And on the other, as an alderman (and, now, vice mayor) of the City of Adamsville he is obliged to put the interests of the City of Adamsville (including its schools) before the interests of the other municipalities in McNairy County (including their schools).  Since he holds both positions, Frank Lacey cannot fully perform the duties of either without violating his obligation to the other.

At Adamsville's November town board meeting, Lacey appeared to think that he could solve the inevitable conflict-of-interest problem simply by refraining from voting on issues where his two offices overlap.  He participated fully in the discussion of the dispute between the City of Adamsville and the McNairy County School Board over the paving of Hughes Street, just as he participated fully in the November School Board meeting regarding providing financial support for a new field house at Adamsville High School while other schools in the county are suffering from a shortage of classrooms.

His mere participation in those discussions inevitably influenced the debate, particularly in light of his position as School Board Chairman and, now, Adamsville vice mayor, and merely refraining from voting does not cure the problem.  The ethical dilemma into which he has placed himself cannot be met by merely recusing himself from voting: he must completely excuse himself from any participation whatever of any issue where the interests of his two offices overlap.

And when he does this, he deprives each of his two constituencies of their right to be fully and fairly represented by their elected officials. The people of McNairy County have a right to expect every school board member, and especially the board chairman, to participate fully in all of the board's activities, and the people of Adamsville have the same right to expect the same of their aldermen, particularly their vice mayor.  Lacey cannot do either without committing an ethical breach.

Lastly, it is specious and naïve, if not actually intellectually dishonest, to argue that Frank Lacey—or any other public official, for that matter—has the wisdom and character to rise above these matters, and that we ought not to let pesky little things like conflicts of interest bother us.  Any community—or any nation, for that matter—which is willing to wink at such infringements forfeits the right to even pretend to be free, democratic, and self-governing.  There is no place in a democracy for our "betters" to be exempted from the rules that govern the rest of us.


* * *


The one bright spot in the November meeting of the Adamsville Town Board was provided by McNairy County Mayor Jai Templeton, who gave the board an articulate and informative update on economic development in McNairy County, which included the welcome news that Adamsville would soon be given a permanent seat on the McNairy County Economic Development Board.  Although Templeton acknowledged that his presentation, which came a little more than half way through the two-hour meeting, had gone on longer than he had intended, it provided some welcome relief in an otherwise contentious meeting.


Convention Center—I beg your pardon, "The Marty"

Earlier, Alderman Dwana Garrison had brought up the first matter of serious discussion.  "I'd like to ask something about the community center, Mayor, if I may?"  She pointed out that the building was in some need of repair, with the wallpaper being a particular concern, and Debbie Moffett drew attention to the serious lack of storage space.  Aside from these long-term problems, Garrison also thought that something needed to be done in the way of decorating the center for the upcoming holidays.  "I make a motion to spend no more than $500 to spend on outside and inside holiday stuff for the community center," she eventually said, and the motion, seconded by Alderman Mike Norris, passed unanimously.  Newly-elected Alderman Frank Lacey then chided Garrison for referring to the building as "the community center."  "Don't we need to call it 'The Marty," he said to her in the admonitory tone familiar to regular attendees of school board meetings.  "We are calling it 'The Marty,'" Garrison responded.  "You kept saying 'the community center,'" Lacey said, condescendingly.  Garrison, to her credit, let it pass.



T-21 Grant

Mayor Tommy Morris then moved on to the next agenda item.  "Report T-21 Grant.  Thrasher," he intoned.

"I think Commissioner Norris probably would be better at this than I was," Town Administrator Terry Thrasher began.  "He bird-dogged this pretty well.  We had a meeting with a lot of the downtown merchants, I don't remember exactly how many was here, we did sign a sign-in sheet, and several showed up.  Regarding signing a, what was that called?  A temporary easement?"

Town Attorney Ken Seaton responded, "What they signed was a, some kind of a, an initial report.  That's not the right term."

"It's an agreement that they signed stating that they will, it asks them to either donate their construction easement or that they have elected, they want compensation for that construction easement," Alderman Mike Norris explained.  "The DOT requires that they sign that agreement so that the process can be started.  But.  I bring everybody back up to date.  We've discovered, I guess through the DOT, there was a bit of a problem with the, with where the right-of-ways were, and we had to get a, the DOT required us to get a construction easement signed by every property owner that was involved in the street project.  So we had a meeting with the DOT, and they instructed us on what to do.  And one of them basically suggested that we have a meeting with all of the property owners that we could gather up together and try to do this at once.  So we did, and we had a pretty good turn out.  We wound up and had eight or ten out of forty property owners that signed, several that took these agreements home and said they would bring them back.  I don't know if any of them have."

"Some have," Thrasher said.

"Okay," Norris continued.  "So, the process that we have to go through before we can proceed any more with the project, is that Mr. Seaton has to give us a title opinion on each property, and then once that is in order then, assuming that we have the agreement signed by all the property owners, and that should happen, a—is it a deed, Ken?  It's not a deed.  It's an official agreement about the construction easement.  Right? Am I saying that right?"

"Ah, we don't know yet," Seaton replied.

"It will be a deed," Norris said.  "It will have to be recorded.  This is a temporary construction easement for a period of three years, and it begins when the construction begins.  At the end of three years, or whenever the project is completed, whichever comes first, then the easement is terminated, and all that reverts back to the property owner.  The property owner is not giving up any property, anything like that.  All they are doing is giving the right to the city to do the construction.  And the easement says that the city will do the construction and then return that area back to, into as good or better condition than it was when we started.  So, that's basically where we are right now.  And we have to complete that before we can go any further.  So we're working on that, diligently."

"I'll give you this comment," Norris said, later in the discussion.  "I've had a couple of comments from some of the business owners.  And we were told this by the engineers.  They say when this starts, you're going to have some real interest from the business owners, and the fact that when they see that things are beginning to happen, they're going to begin to look at their business physically and say, well, you know, I believe I could do this, you know, and make mine look a little better.  I've already had two tell me that.  So there's beginning to be some interest, some positive interest generated."

Seaton observed that the work on the title opinions was proceeding well.  "We're far enough along.  We've got them all done.  We don't have them all typed up.  The uncertainty about this process is there has to be TDOT approval at different stages, and there will come a point in time when, I think where the engineers are now there is still some uncertainty about exactly what form these property owners are going to be in at the time, and when that happens, I think the plan is maybe, he'll give us a little input from TDOT before a decision is made about that, and when we get to the point where all the individuals have signed the form we end up using, then that document, the document we're in the process of trying to get folks to sign right now which confirms that they've been told about the different rights that they have, and the title opinion will all go to TDOT.  When we get all the forms, two different sets of forms signed by everyone, the title opinions will go with those forms to TDOT for approval.  So, the answer to your question is, we can get the title opinions done in just two or three days probably, which will, they're not needed yet."

Alderman Jeff Browder said, "Right.  And that's the reason I was kind of wondering.  We're looking at some time in the spring at the very best.  I had had a couple of people express their concern that this was going to start in the middle of winter, or something."

Seaton replied, "I'm afraid there's some uncertainty about the different positions TDOT might take about a problem with it that might, I don't see this moving as fast as we hoped.  I hope I'm wrong."

"We were hoping to start it some time in January," Norris said.

Mayor Morris opined that the "contractors won't start until March, by the time you got everything ironed out."



Hughes Street

The next agenda item was a familiar one: "Paving Hughes Street."

"Y'all ought to have a letter from Charlie Miskelly in your package," Thrasher began.  "I don't know where we are on this.  It's been brought up, talked about, cussed about, long enough, I think.  Frank can probably add more light on this.  It has been discussed that the school board and the county would pay half and the city would pay half, and then I got a call from the principal that he was instructed by, I think, Mr. Miskelly to get busy himself on doing the job.  He had one bid in hand and wanted me to give him some contractors' names, and I did.  And I haven't heard any more from him.  And Mr. Miskelly caught me at a meeting and says, 'Where are we?' and I said 'We're further along than we were.'  And I said 'Write a letter to the city commission, whatever you want to ask them.'  You have that letter in your hands."

After reading the letter, Norris remarked, "It sure sounds like they're wanting us to do all of it."

"That's the way I read the letter, too," Thrasher observed.

"Is that what they're wanting to do, Frank?" Norris asked.

"The way the school board understands it," Lacey began, "the City of Adamsville has that property leased, and it's a lease agreement that is renewed every year, and I don't know if y'all have kept up with the school board meetings, but they're like everybody else, stressed for money, trying to find a way to do everything that they can do, and if they were leasing the property today, they would lease it with the understanding that you maintain the road.  So, the school board's position is that since we have the property and the road, we should take care of the road.  But, again, I think, what Mr. Thrasher says is true.  I think, you know, this letter was just to get the conversation going, so we could find out what they were, what the city was going to do, versus the school board could do."

Lacey then gave the board a history of the situation. 

"The principals over here, ever since I've been involved in local politics, have asked that that road be paved.  There's a lot of traffic, there's a lot of flow that goes through there.  And, of course, it belongs, at first we thought it belonged to the county.  Which if it belonged to the county, well the county pays.  And when Tom Hill was the county road commissioner, for four consecutive years he promised to pave it.  He never did.  With this new county road commissioner, Harvey Neal Smith, he now has determined that it's not county property.  It belongs to the McNairy County Board of Education.  Which the McNairy County Board of Education has no way of, uh, we're not a revenue, we can only spend what's given to us.  We can't generate funds.  So we have no funds to do it from other than budgeted funds, and of course the schools, as most of y'all realize, need a lot of money spent in a lot of areas, and if the city didn't already have the property leased, I don't think it would be any question, the road wouldn't get paved because the school board wouldn't have the money to do it.  But since the city has the property leased, that's why we're asking you to pave it.  I don't think that if the city leased the property that there'd be any question."

"May I say something?" Seaton asked.

Though it was not his place to do so, since Lacey (who later claimed to be "a student" of Robert's Rules of Order) was not presiding over the meeting, Lacey gave Seaton permission to speak. "Yes," he said.

"Didn't I look at that lease and inform you that it was just a year-to-year lease?" Seaton said to Lacey, who nodded.  "I think I pointed that out in a meeting," Seaton said to the board at large.  "Somebody came back to me and said that the city, in support of the proposition that the city ought to pay it.  And that was something we discussed at a meeting.  And, yes, the city has it leased, but we're at the mercy of the school board as to how long it's leased."

After a few brief comments, Garrison asked, "Well, should we go back and say, okay, let's do a five-year lease, and we'll go ahead and pave that road?"

"I think that's what they're wanting you to do," Lacey replied.  "I want to be very careful, because I don't want to confuse my position here," he said, before proceeding to do just that.  "You know, I think it's the City of Adamsville's responsibility to decide what they want to do, and make an offer.  I think the school board would be very favorable to any help or any offer.  If you wanted a longer lease, I don't think that would be a problem."

Norris said that he didn't see what a longer lease would accomplish, then Seaton said "The only reason we brought it up was because the school board representative came to me and pointed out, well, the city has it leased and therefore the city ought to pave it.  And my response to that was, the fact that we have it leased is insignificant, because it's an annual, one year extension, and that's the extent of the lease."

Lacey then jumped back into the discussion.  "I think, as far as the city goes, this shows where we have, in our future we need to be looking at property for a park, that we won't have to be at the mercy of somebody else."

"We're running a bigger parks and recreation program than we have property to run it on right now," Browder interjected.

"And, you know," Lacey continued, "in the short run, I think any kind of consideration would be, if y'all say, no, we don't want to do anything, then again, I would reiterate.  If y'all have kept up with events of the last few school board meetings, you know, as applies on this board, a board member only has one vote, and I don't know, I would hope that we would continue to lease it to the city as long as the city needs it.  But I wouldn't want to speak for the other board members."

"Well, are there not some plans to build another school and increase the size of this one?" Norris asked.

"There's plans," Lacey replied.  "There's plans, but there's no action been taken.  We have a building program."

Norris said, "The reason I'm asking that is if they were to do that would that road disappear if they add on to that?"  Lacey shook his head, no.  "That road would stay there?" Norris asked, and Lacey nodded his head, yes.

"We need to make a decision here—" the mayor began, but Browder interrupted.

"I want to make one more comment.  And, just like Frank says, if you keep up with what's happening at the school board, I don't, to me, when I see this letter, this is not a request from the school board, this is a request from Mr. Miskelly, and if you keep up with him, he's gone the full distance, I think, for Adamsville school on more than one occasion, and I just want us to bear that in mind before we make a decision."

Mayor Morris then resumed. "Well, one of the things we could do, I think, is give them a proposal for what we will do.  Something, I've always been against paving other people's property and streets, but why don't we say that we'll bear half the price, our half of the cost?  Because we did, we spent more than $5,000 on the soccer field."

"That's why I'd hate to see this taken out from under us," Garrison said

"I don't think it will every be took out," Mayor Morris said, "unless they need it for a school addition."

"And who's going to benefit there, if they do that?"  Browder asked.

"Our kids," Garrison said.

"Exactly," Browder replied, then he said "I make a motion that we offer to halve the cost with the school board."

"I think it's a legal question," Seaton insisted.

Mayor Morris said, "Give us your opinion."

"I don't know whether you ought to pave the street or not," Seaton began.  "All I was saying was, was that it has been suggested to me that because we had it leased that ought to be significant toward the question of whether or not we pave it.  And it's not.  Because the lease—  unless the school board wanted to give us a ten-year lease, or, I don't know.  It's not that big of a deal.  I'm not criticizing anybody, but the school board was trying, not the school board, a representative of the school board, was trying to make out that because we had it leased, we ought to pave it.  It's ours.  And the indication was that that's going to go on indefinitely.  But that's not the way the lease reads, and that's the only point I was making….  The point is, the thing I want to stress, is the representative of the school board was trying to make that out to be a big deal, that we had it leased, and it's not."

Norris then seconded Browder's motion that the city offer to split the cost of paving Hughes Street with the school board.  Garrison then asked that the motion be amended to include the provision that the school board give the city a five-year lease, and her amendment, seconded by Norris, passed unanimously, with one exception: Lacey, after having participated extensively in the discussion of the issue, made a big point of saying, "I'm going to recuse myself from this vote."



City Property on Hwy 64 West

Mayor Morris then called the next item on the agenda, "City Property on Hwy 64 West."

Thrasher began, "You have a piece of paper in your packet showing what the person that wants to try to put a business on the property on the south side of Hwy 64, going down Carroll Hill.  You were made an offer on it last month, took it under advisement.  This is a picture of what they want to build on it.  A decision needs to be made either, to do whatever y'all want to do.  Sell it to this person or whatever."

"I don't want to do it," Norris said.

"Do I hear a motion that we sell it to this person?" Morris asked.

"May I ask one thing first?" asked Garrison.  "I see Jackie Forsythe here.  His property backs up to that property.  Would that have a problem with you?"

Forsythe replied that he has no problem with it, and remarked that the property is zoned commercial.

Morris then repeated his request for a motion, and at length Browder complied.  The motion, though, died for want of a second.

At this point Albert Paul Bazzell, from the audience, said he would like to make an offer on the property, saying "I'd be willing to give ten [thousand dollars] for it."

"What are you wanting to put on it?" Mayor Morris asked.

"We're going to put a business, a store, a merchants store.  And it would be, you know, a nice building and all that."

"The only thing I've got a problem with on all of this," Morris said, "it's just like our industrial park out there.  We try to work with everybody….  And this lady—what's your name?—Brandy?  She come up here, and they've got a pretty good drawing of what they want to do, and it looks like it could be a great asset to the city of Adamsville, sales tax wise, property tax wise.  Because it's three buildings they're going to put on it, paved, 120-foot dock over.  I don't know—how big a building was you planning on putting there?"

"About fifteen hundred square, fifteen thousand square foot," Bazzell replied.

"May I say something here?" Garrison asked.  "I think that we ought to have put it up for sale, because I know I've got two other standing offers of $10,000, because they said they didn't know that it was even for sale, that it was the city's or that it was for sale.  So, I understand Mr. Bazzell's coming in here, because you probably didn't know about it before then, did you?"

Bazzell confirmed that he did not.

Garrison continues. "That's what I'm saying.  So now it's kind of like we've opened the opportunity, we might could get some more offers."

"How did Ms Brandy find out about it being for sale?" Lacey asked.

"I contacted the city," Brandy Graham replied from the audience.

"Can I make a recommendation?" Norris interjected.  "If the city wants to sell the property, which is fine, I think we ought to get an appraisal on it, so that we know what the property is really worth."

"We tried to sell it before," Mayor Morris said, "for twenty-five thousand, the man that had it, that gave it to us, tried to sell it for twenty-five thousand, and we never got the first bite on it.  And so we've had it up for sale, but she was the only one that ever come in to us."

"Mayor, may I address the commission?" Thrasher asked.  "I think that we, uh, y'all need to keep in mind that the Industrial Development Board gives the property, or has to this date, all that's accepted it, two or three acres, or whatever anybody thinks they need to put in a business.  But there's stipulations on that sale, on that gift.  That they will build a building of a certain type, with a certain look, and they will be building in a certain period of time, and they will have a business operating with X employees.  Maybe it's two, it may be twenty.  But I think the city ought to follow the lead that the Industrial Development Board has started, and not sell it to a speculator who will give us $10,000 for it and sit on it for two or three years and sell it for $25,000.  I think if it's going to be speculated on, it ought to be the citizens of Adamsville doing the speculating."
 
"But whoever buys it," Thrasher continued, "has to buy it as this lady has proposed on her drawing, or these other people, that they will draw up something and say, 'This is the building, and it will look like this, and I will be operating a business within so many months with so many employees.'"

"Well," Garrison interjected, "this is not a site proposal, it's something drawn on a piece of paper.  It doesn't tell us what the outside is, it doesn't tell us any of that.  I think we said we wanted a site proposal."

Garrison said she was concerned about selling the property without the public first being aware that it was available, especially not for just $10,000.  "Ten thousand or fifteen thousand is a big difference from twenty-five thousand, I agree, and somebody come and put a business in there to generate tax dollars and generate people coming to town, but also in the meantime have it nice, attractive coming into our town, because as you come up Carroll Hill it's one of the first thing you see coming up through there, you know, and I just want to make sure it's the right thing."

The mayor said, "If we keep fighting people that wants to go into business over here we'll never get businesses."

After some further discussion Lacey asked, "If we took Jeff's motion and put in the verbiage that Terry just said, to add stipulation to all that, Ms Graham or whoever, would they be willing to, they might be willing to make the same offer, we could get something built, like the industrial board does, guarantee to employ a certain number of people.  I've been on record before with this board saying I do not think it's our position as a city to own property.  We're to get property, where property is given to us, we're to put it back in the hands of somebody that's going to generate tax dollars for us.  I do think we need to have a plan, and there needs to be some stipulations based on it.  I wouldn't have a problem at all with a motion that was worded to include that verbiage that Terry said."

"But," Mayor Morris said, "we need to show people that we're ready to work with them, and all.  Can't just keep putting them off, you know."

Jackie Forsythe raised another consideration: "It doesn't make any difference to me, because I don't really butt up against that, but any kind of a business there would look better than a red clay gulley.  You come up the hill and you see a red clay gulley, and a bunch of old scrub trees and stuff.  I don't see the city setting on a piece of property just because they're wanting to get more money off of it.  And you've got by-laws, and you've got ordinances as to what businesses have got to look like, so it's already there.  Go with it."

Browder added yet another consideration.  "And a comment on the elected official academy that we went to, this is a service business, and they tell us that 78% of the businesses that are going to make it are service industries.  That manufacturing is on the way out, and service is on the way in.  That would be a decision for Brandy to make, whether she would want to comply with the economic development board on putting a business or not.  I don't want us to say, on the one hand, we want business in our town, and be so difficult that people don't want to even attempt to put their business in our town."

After some further discussion, Mayor Morris said, "I'd even be, I'd even, my view, I'd even be able to give this one [indicating the property on Hwy 64] away to get a building and taxes and everything on it.  Because it didn't cost us nothing.  I called the man up, he gave it to us.  He brought the deed down here and Terry said, do you want it.  And you know, we've mowed it, and we're not getting anything out of it.  It's costing us to have it.  Y'all are saying, you ought to get some money out of it, but that’s the, up to this board."

Lacey said, "I think, I think, I would like to make a motion that we give Terry authority to negotiate a deal with Ms Brandy based on the sales price and the economic development and the industrial board guidelines as to how to use property there.  I would anticipate that that includes verbiage that says there'll be a viable business there within a certain period of time and all that."  He concluded by saying, "if you can't negotiate we'll find someone that will comply with those terms.  But we need to sell it, we don't need to keep it."

Browder then seconded the motion, which passed unanimously, but that was not the end of the matter.

Carolyn Bazzell observed that she and her husband had offered $10,000 for property which the city had earlier been willing to sell $8,000, "and then you set there and you say that you need to show it to the public and all that.  I don't understand that."

"Now, what?" Mayor Morris asked.

"If somebody made a motion to give 8,000 and then you have somebody to give ten, and then y'all sit there and y'all say, well we need to show this to the public, and then you turn right around and somebody else is give more money for it, and then you're just wanting to go ahead and do that, I mean, you go right back to the question that he asked while ago, why did we not show this to the public?  I don't understand that.  I fail to understand."

"We've had it down there for four years for sale," the mayor replied, "or longer than that, I guess.  We even had a sign up on it once, didn't we, Terry?"

"We had a for sale sign on it?" Garrison asked

"Right after they gave it to us," Thrasher said.

"I ain't never seen one," Mrs. Bazzell asserted.

"I hadn't either," Garrison agreed.

There was some cross talk, then the mayor said, "But we've been, you know, we've been working with Brandy, and, you know, y'all come up here at the last minute—"

Mrs. Bazzell then asserted that people had no way of knowing what was going on "if you don't bring it out to the public. We ain't got no shopper no more for anybody to read and find out the city of Adamsville business.  It's just that we heard it through the grapevine that it was for sale, and we're interested in putting in a business and I come up here to ask about it, and I ain't had nobody to even talk to me about it after I asked about it, and I don't think that's right.  I mean, I'm just one person, but I don't see it."

Garrison agreed.  "I understand, Mrs. Bazzell, because, see, that's why I didn't agree to let it be sold last month.  Or that I asked not to, because I didn't know we had it out there for sale either, and I thought it needed to be put out there on the block and let the people know about it.  And like you said, us not having a local paper here so things aren't, you know, not everybody has the internet, that tunes into internet news, but, and I'm one of those that don't, but … I guess it's a good thing, but I agree.  I felt like if we had a piece of property, and I know what commercial property is selling in town.  I know what property sold up the hill from it.  If it's selling at $10,000 an acre, how can we let three and, three acres and some odd, three acres and something else go for as little as $8,000.  That's why I'd asked for a site proposal plan.…  This is what we got back.  It's not really what I expected.  I expected it to be a little differently.  Because … I understand where you're coming from, because I'm having a hard time I've had with it, too.  I still feel like, but, you know, we gave her the thirty days.  You know, you didn't know about it.  I was blown, I mean, last month, we didn't know about it, or at least I didn't, I don't know how many of y'all other ones didn't know about it.  It was brought up that night that Ms Graham, you know, was offered to buy it.  I didn't know it had been done.  I think we need more things put out on the table than they are.  Which, a lot of things happen like that, quickly."

"Thank you," Mrs. Bazzell said.

Lacey then joined the conversation. "If the city does get property in the future we need to be sure that we do have it marketed the right way—"

"Exactly," Garrison interjected.

"—work with the West Tennessee Economic Development to get people in here because we need business."

Garrison added, "And we need to put signs on it that say City Hall and a big number, who to ask for, and it to be followed up with."

"Let's see," Mayor Morris said, "how many people did we show that to?"

Thrasher replied, "Seven or eight or ten.  Who knows?"

"Two, is what—" Garrison began.

"More than that," Morris said.

"She knew about it," Browder said, indicating Brandy Graham.  Then he turned to Thrasher and asked, "What did she do, call you and ask you if you've got some property?"

Thrasher indicated that she had. "What we zeroed in on, of course the first place we looked at was the industrial park.  And then the more we talked, the more it got into, she needed a more visible place, and I think that's the way Mr. and Mrs. Bazzell, the industrial park, they're aware of it, in fact I showed that to them, but feel like, and maybe it's probably so, they want more visibility.  The visibility in the industrial park is very limited.  Particularly because the park runs back off the road and around, and there are only like two places that you could see it from the highway.  And the highway traffic on 22 is not nearly what it is on 64."

"Well," Mayor Morris said, preparing to move on to the next agenda item, "we'll see how it turns out."




Planning Commission Member

"New Business," Morris read from the agenda.  "Appoint Planning Commission Member.  Last time we brought it up, there wasn't a vacancy.  I jumped the gun on it when I brought it up, and we need to appoint a planning commission member.  I recommend that we appoint Jeff Browder.  He said that he would serve on it, with the planning commission. Do I hear a second?"

Lacey seconded the motion, then Norris remarked, "Well, I thought I was elected last time."  [See the report of the 15 October board meeting, below.]

"Yeah," Garrison agreed.

"There wasn't a vacancy," the mayor answered dismissively.

"Then why was it brought up?" Norris asked.

"Well, I don't know," Morris replied.  "I just made a mistake.  I've made one or two in my life."

"When do we get to discussion?" Garrison asked Thrasher.  "Right now?"

Thrasher agreed.

Garrison said, "My discussion is that Mike has worked, not that Jeff hasn't, and I don't have a problem with either gentleman being on there, I just think that Mike has been working hard, putting in lots of hours on this downtown project, the beautification of it, and going to all the meetings, and I'd hate, and Ann would, you know, Ann's not a commissioner anymore, but Ann would, that was her seat that was being taken, and I know that, you know, not saying, Jeff, that you won't do a good job, I'm sure that you would, but I just thought since Mike has put in, and I know that he would like to see this thing all the way through, cause he's went to different cities, they've taken different pictures, him and Sarah, they've went and, you know, done a lot of studying on this downtown project, and….  There's my discussion."

On his own behalf, Norris said, "Well, I also tried to do some things in the way of seeing to it that in general we enforce our ordinances more and that sort of thing.  I think that's more to do with the planning commission.  I'd like to see some things changed there.  And it takes time to do that. If the commission doesn't feel that I am capable of doing it, well that's fine with me."

Browder then said, "Well, Mayor Morris asked me if I would be willing to serve, and I told him that I would be willing to serve.  I'm not, that's not in any way saying, Mike, you're not capable or anything else as far as I'm concerned.  I'll do what I can to help this town."

"Any more discussion?" Morris asked.

"I sure didn't know all that other had taken place," Lacey said, referring to the fact that Mayor Morris had attempted to put Browder on the planning commission at the previous month's meeting, but had failed when the board appointed Norris instead.  "But now the planning commission, it is the board that handles zoning issues, planning and zoning?  So, it's not, I wouldn't think it would be the same as the downtown beautification—"

Garrison said "I hate that we jerk something from out from underneath Jeff, and Mike, because he was appointed, it was approved last city meeting."

"Well, that's all right," Norris then said.  "Let Jeff serve."

"I don't think, I just didn't think that was right," Garrison said.

"Call for a vote," the mayor said.

"Number one," Norris then said, opening up another old wound, "the mayor can't make a motion, and he tried to make a motion.  Somebody's got to make a motion."

"I can make a motion," Morris asserted.

"No, you can't," Norris replied.

"I can," Morris insisted.  "I've got a vote."

"You've got a vote," Norris agreed, "but you cannot make a motion.  One of the commissioners has to make a motion.  That's in accordance with Robert's Rules."

"We operate under this charter," Seaton then said, opening up the city charter.  "It's not what Mr. Deal says," he went on, which generated laughter from those who had been present at the October meeting at which local minister Michael Deal had held forth at great length about his prodigious memory and superior knowledge of how public meetings were to be conducted.  "The charter is what controls this body.  In a conflict with Robert's Rules of Order, this charter controls."

[Unaccountably, Norris picked up his cup and left the room as Seaton was speaking, creating some question about how seriously he took his own assertion.]

"Well," Browder said, "I think what the charter states is that the meeting is to be held on that platform."

And, Seaton said, the charter treats the mayor "as if he's a commissioner."

"So he can make a motion?" Garrison asked.

Seaton replied, "In my opinion, without studying, how he's got the right to make a motion."

Lacey, who was not present during Michael Deal's performance the previous month and was evidently unaware that he was taking on the Deal role himself, then informed the group of his own superiority in such matters.  "And as a student of Robert's Rules, Robert's Rules has two Robert's Rules.  There's one for large meetings and one for small meetings.  Small meetings, bodies like this, less than two or three hundred, they're operated completely different set of Robert's Rules."

[It was at this point that Norris returned with his cup, having missed Lacey's performance as a Michael Deal stand-in.]

Mayor Morris observed that "if we operated by Robert's Rules, these people out here [indicating the audience] couldn't speak."

"And," Browder injected, "those of us who attended the education session there a couple of week-ends ago have a brand new shiny copy of Robert's Rules of Order if anybody needs to see it."

In the audience, Jack Forsythe raised his hand.

"Did you want to say anything?" Mayor Morris asked.

"Yeah," Forsythe replied.  "Back several years ago, back in the eighties, we redid the charter for the city of Adamsville, and I was on that committee.  And the state House of Representatives had to ratify our charter by its acts, so whatever the charter says is as good as law, and it supercedes Robert's Rules."

Mayor Morris then asked again for a vote, whereupon Garrison asked for a restatement of what was being voted on.  When the mayor explained that it was his motion that Browder be appointed to the planning commission, Browder himself said, "I think what, before we vote, I think I'm going to rescind my servitude on that board.  As far as I'm concerned, my—"

"I don't want it either,"  Norris said.

This opened up yet another round of discussion about whether the motion could be withdrawn or tabled without being voted on, which ended when the mayor insisted, "I want to call for a vote" on his motion to name Browder to the planning commission.

In that vote, Morris was the only one to vote "aye."

He then said, "Now, does somebody want to make a motion to approve somebody else?"

Garrison responded, "I'd like to make a motion then that we go back to what it was last meeting when we had nominated Mike Norris to be put on the planning commission."

Lacey seconded the motion, and in the voting that followed all the aldermen voted "aye" and the mayor cast the only "no" vote.



Vice Mayor

"Motion carried," Morris announced, then moved on to the next agenda item.  "Next, Elect Vice Mayor.  I make a motion that Frank Lacey serve as the vice mayor.  The next two years that I'm in office I believe I can work real well with him.  He's right across the street from city hall, here, and I think most of people that's in city hall, if they need to talk to him about something he'd be right there.  Do I hear a second?"

The mayor's question was greeted by a long period of silence, which the mayor himself broke by repeating his question.

 "Do I hear a second?"

Another pause ensued, to be broken finally, and tersely, by Norris, who said, "Second."

"Any discussion?" the mayor asked, and his question was greeted by more silence.

"Call for a vote," he then said.  "All in favor say Aye."

After another pause, Norris finally said "Aye," which was followed by an "Aye" from the mayor, then more silence, which the mayor finally broke by asking Lacey, "You're not going to vote for yourself?"

"I'd rather not have to," Lacey replied.

Browder then voted "Aye," and the mayor declared "Motion carries" without calling for the "No" votes and ignoring the fact that Garrison had not cast a vote.

And so it was that, exactly one hour and twelve minutes into his first town board meeting following his election. Frank Lacey was proclaimed by Mayor Morris to be "the vice mayor."



Economic Development

Mayor Morris then introduced McNairy County Mayor Jai Templeton, who reported on the consolidation of the Economic Development Board and the Chamber of Commerce and announced that he as county mayor and Selmer Mayor David Robinson had each agreed to give up one of their two appointees, giving one extra appointee to the Chamber  of Commerce and the other to the city of Adamsville, with the Adamsville position to be filled either by the mayor himself of his appointee.  Templeton reported that a number of highly qualified individuals had applied for the position of Director of Economic Development and would be interviewed on November 23 and November 26, and he expects the successful applicant will take office at first of year.  He also said that the plan was for this person to hire the person that will handle the chamber of commerce functions.

"We think it's important, that once the people come together, that we have somewhat of a long-term strategic planning session, that we brand ourselves.  I mean, we've been hit pretty hard, we all know that, in the past year, with the loss of a major industry, two tragic events that put us in the national headlines, and it seems, unfortunately, if the D.A. has his way, that we're going to find ourselves spending another spring and summer, probably, in the national headlines, and that's not positive for McNairy County, under no circumstance.  It has caused us a lot of embarrassment.  I know for a fact it has.  We've had a tier one supplier who came and toured the county, and their last comment was, 'Well, we have other opportunities and you all suffered a lot of bad publicity.  Now that's pretty hard for the county mayor, when he couldn't change anything that happened, to have to listen to.  But you have to accept it, and I put myself in their position and I guess if I'm making the call to make that kind of investment, I guess I would have done the same thing and moved on."

"Were at the doorway of great things in West Tennessee because of what went on down there in Tupelo.  And I know folks in state government that are upset because the state of Mississippi landed that plant and they didn't get it in Chattanooga.  And I'm sorry for them, and their state careers, that they didn't make that happen.  But the fact of the matter is, we're in McNairy County, right next door to it, and we need some attention, and hopefully they're going to begin to do that."

When Templeton concluded his remarks, Frank Lacey said, "Mayor, I think it's wonderful that the board has recognized Adamsville for our contribution, and I would like to state, for myself, that Adamsville, that we in Adamsville businesses would really like to get more involved with what goes on in the county, and I think our county, and the surrounding counties, that's where the future lies."

Not surprisingly, when Mayor Morris asked, "Does anybody want to serve on the board?" Lacey immediately gushed, "I would love the opportunity—" but before he could crown himself with yet another set of laurels Dwana Garrison said she, too, would like to serve in that position, and she suggested that Lacey already had enough on his plate, what with being on the county school board as well as the Adamsville town board.

In the discussion that followed Mike Norris abruptly stated, "I'll serve on it," and Morris said "As far as I'm concerned" the position was Norris's, "if he wants it."



Lien on Property

After dealing swiftly with the next agenda item—Thrasher put it on the record that the Sun Dial in front of city hall is on loan from Cheryl Chambers (of Flowers and Friends) and will remain her property should the city ever decide to remove it from its place in front of City Hall—the board then spent ten uncomfortable minutes discussing a lien.

Thrasher explained that "Mrs. [Evelyn] Enlow is selling, or sold, or trying to sell her property, and the city has a lien on that property due to a clean up we performed several years ago, and I think the title can't be cleared, or the house can't be closed until that lien is cleared up or done something with, and the family asked me to put it on the agenda, and you might get it addressed by some, Mrs. Enlow or the family."

Garrison then explained that Mr. Enlow had refused to clean up the property, so the city had to do it for him.  She said that she had gotten some calls asking that the city forgive the lien.  Seaton asked why the city should do this, and Garrison said that Mrs. Evelyn basically felt that the lien was the result of a dispute between her husband and the city, to which she was not a part, and she didn't think it was fair that she have to pay the lien. 

"Well," Mike Norris observed, "it's unfortunate, but that's what the ordinances call for, you know, as a last resort, and if you forgive this, then you're going to set a precedent, it seems to me like.  There's no use in having the ordinance."

When the mayor asked City Attorney Seaton for his opinion, Seaton said, "I think this board spent a lot of time and energy and effort for many months dealing with this problem, trying to avoid the problem getting to the point that it did.  I think we complied completely with the law.  I understand probably while that was going on Mrs. Enlow hated every minute of it and wanted, and her daughter's there shaking her head, and it wasn't y'all's fault.  It was—"

The daughter remarked that he "was a hard man to deal with in the best environment."

"Well," Seaton continued, "he felt strongly that that was his property and he could do what he pleased about it and nobody could tell him what to do.  And that's the way he felt, and I think that's why the problem snowballed like it did and ended up having to be resolved the way that it was."

"Well," Evelyn Enlow replied, "I think this should have caught up while he was still living where he could have took care of it."

After further discussion the mayor asked, "What does this commission want to do?" When there was no response, he said "Evidently, we're not going to do anything." And went on to the final item on the agenda.



Water Study

Public Works Director Paul Wallace Plunk advised the board that the state was requiring the city to produce a "water modeling plan for the city to see what actually was needed," and that he had received an estimate which put the cost of the study at $18,500.  "What they're going to do is model this whole system.  In other words, it's a study of the whole system.  It's going to tell you what you need, where you need it, and why you need it."

This led to a ten-minute discussion of the water system and various grants and proposals regarding it, during which the mayor at one point remarked, "We're studying this town to death."

Garrison argued in favor of various studies, and Thrasher observed that anything the city does will have to have state approval, and state won't approve it without an engineering study.

There was considerable disagreement among the board members regarding what the various grants and studies are for.  The mayor insisted, as he has done at earlier meetings, that the best solution to the town's water problems was "a million-gallon ground tank," while Browder argued that what was envisioned was actually an elevated tank.

After further wrangling, Plunk said he would get "a representative back down here for the next meeting and explain all this to everybody," and, that being the last of the agenda items, the board member began to gather up their papers in expectation of adjournment …



One last, sad, chapter

… which expectation turned out to be premature.

"Tommy, can I say something?" asked Katherine Hamm from the audience.

"Yeah," the mayor replied without enthusiasm.

"I've got a paper here," Hamm said, "and I'd like to know why, that I was not told, that my next-door-neighbor was a sex offender."

"I didn't know it," Morris replied.

"Well, it's on the internet," Hamm said.  "And I was not told by nobody that she was a sex offender.  I have grandkids, everybody in here's got grandkids.  Would you want your grandkids next door to a sex offender?"

"No, I wouldn't," Morris replied.  "But I didn't know she was down there."

"Well, she is," Hamm asserted, before launching into a list of other complaints.  "And she's also, she's got an alcoholic living with her, he makes seven to eight trips a day to Sunrise for two quarts of beer.  And there's, this is including the rescue squad, back in August, I called, and my husband did, 911, for me, because I could not move, I could not walk, or anything.  He called 911.  The rescue squad did not respond.  They didn't, they said that they didn't respond to strokes, which he didn't know if I'd had a stroke or not.  I couldn't walk, I couldn't do anything.  Okay.  The ambulance from Selmer comes.  Terry [Thrasher] pulls in my driveway.  I don't know if he thinks I had the plague, or what, but he did not get out of his vehicle to check to see if I'm still living or if I'm dead.  He sets there until the ambulance gets there, then he leaves.  Okay.  This lady here, they have had drugs, and everything else.  One of them had a panic attack.  Right there they are.  [Meaning that the 911 folks arrived immediately.]  Carry them to the hospital.  Three weeks ago, one, had two quarts of beer, took some Xanaxes.  They was right there.  Carried him to the hospital.  If he was able to walk to the ambulance, he didn't take that many Xanaxes.  Only thing that was wrong with him was he was drunk.  They've got not one cat, they've got four.  They're using my flowers as cat-litter boxes.  I'm tired of it.  Something has got to be done with them cats.  Because I've got to take my flowers in the house, this winter, and I'm going to smell all of that.  And if anybody thinks that's funny, I'll bring them to y'all, and y'all can deal with it."

"I don't want 'em," Morris responded.

"Well, I don't want the smell in my house," Hamm repeated.  "But I don't like this, living next door, and not knowing nothing about it."

"Did you know that she was there?" Morris asked Police Chief Bill McCall, who nodded affirmatively.

Lacey then remarked, "I think if she registers, that's all that she has to do."

"She's not registered," Hamm insisted.  "The last place—"

McCall said, "She's a non-violent offender, convicted in 1995 in Mississippi, and she remains on our Tennessee registry for four more years.  After that she's scot free."

"Well, why wasn't I told?" Hamm asked.

"It's not mandated that we tell anybody," McCall replied.

 "It is in Memphis," Hamm said.

"It's not in the state of Tennessee as I understand the law," McCall replied.  "They have to report to us—"

"Would you want your grandkids living next door to it?" Hamm asked, and when McCall indicated that he wouldn't like it she responded, "Okay."

"But," McCall continued, "you can't mandate where anybody lives, either.  The only thing you can't do is within a thousand feet of a school according to the Tennessee Code."

Hamm persisted. "Yeah, but if your grandkids is there, and they're playing—"

"I agree with you," McCall interjected, "but I didn't write the Tennessee law."

"—and they're outside playing, you've got to stay with 'em, 'cause you don't know what she's goin' do."

"That's one of those unfortunate things," McCall said.  "But I agree with you 100%, but we don't write the Tennessee laws.  They did.  We just go by what they say.  She's in compliance.  As a matter of fact, she used to not be in compliance until she was made, by the TBI to move.  She used to live right down here on Adams Street, across from the school."

Hamm then moved on to her other complaints. "Well, like I said, I don't mind one cat, but when it comes to four, and they don't feed 'em, and they come to your house to get something to eat, for water, and then you've got to put up with all this other, I don't go for that.  And, like I said, there's, he knows, he pulled in my driveway, and I don't know if he thought I had the plague, or what he thought, but I could have set there and died, and him sitting right there in my driveway.  And Larry went to the door to get him to come in.  He wouldn't come in.  So I give up on the rescue squad.  From now on, if I have a problem, if I have any stroke, if I can get to my vehicle, I'll get to my vehicle.  I will not call 911 no more.  That's all I've got to say."

"I'd like to address that," a visibly agitated Terry Thrasher said to the mayor.  "I do not remember being in the driveway and him inviting me in.  But let me tell you something.  I am a first responder."

"I know that," Hamm said.

Thrasher continued. "There's paramedics on the ambulance and EMTs on the ambulance.  I am not going in to treat somebody when a paramedic's there."

"They was not there," Hamm insisted.

"Well, then you're going to have to be more specific to tell where I was setting at," Thrasher responded.  "And let me tell you something else.  It's called the voluntary rescue squad.  If you go home tonight, anybody in this room, and dial 911 and they page this bunch out, there's no obligation for them to come at all.  They may be out of town, they may be on vacation, they may be at the river fishing, but just because they didn't come some time when you called, you've got no complaint, because it doesn't cost you a penny.  If that pager goes off and they all decide that they're in their jammies and don't want to get up and get out of bed, that's as legal as they can be.  They do not have to come.  Whether you call 911 or not doesn't make any difference to me, lady.  But we do the best we can with what we've got.  If you don't want to call us, that's just one job that we don't have to go out on."

"Well that's one job you won't have to do," Hamm said.

"That's all right with us, too," Thrasher replied.

"That's one job you won't have to do," Hamm repeated.

"Good."  Thrasher said.  "We've got plenty of work to do without you."

"Yeah," Hamm responded, before adding, "Some of you don't."

And on that sad note the long and disheartening meeting finally came to an end.




Town Board Meeting

15 October 2007

After enduring ten minutes of condescending insults from a local minister who made the extraordinary claim that he had memorized Robert's Rules
Order, a book of more than 200 pages [see the story immediately below for full details], the Adamsville Town Board was finally able to get down to business Monday evening.  The minister in question, Michael Deal, hung around long enough to disrupt the meeting several more times before his zeal for public meetings apparently petered out—shortly after being told by Adamsville Town Attorney Ken Seaton that "This board does not need legal advice from you."

But even the departure of Deal, who no doubt runs Mt. Sharon Presbyterian Church in strict accordance to Robert's Rules of Order (whose entire contents—all 30,000-plus words—Deal twice told the board he had committed to memory), did not make for smooth sailing for the dysfunctional town board, which managed to finish the marathon meeting (which lasted more than two hours) on a characteristically acrimonious note.

Reports

City Manager Terry Thrasher gave the financial report, saying that "we're 25% through the year, our revenues look good as far as the expenditures.  We've got about two places where we've spent what we've allocated this far in the year.  We're dragging behind, of course, in the gas revenues.  That's going to happen until people start turning on some heat.

"The reports from the state department of revenue, they came in today's mail.  We received a little better than $40,000 from McNairy County.  Last month we had $37,000.  And last month we had $7,900 from Hardin County, we got $6,700 this month.  So one's up and one's down."

The financial report was approved on a unanimous roll-call vote on a motion by Ann Hudson, seconded by Jeff Browder.

There being no questions on adjustments or building permits, Mayor Tommy Morris moved on to the police report, asking if there were any questions on it.  There being none, the mayor remarked that it looked like it was "pretty light."

"Yeah," responded Police Chief Bill McCall, "but don't hold your breath.  I'll load you up next month already.  We had a lot stolen last month and recovered a lot this month."

Dwana Garrison remarked to the chief that "I haven't seen the radar thing out lately."

"I'm nearly ready to but it back out," McCall replied.  "I've been holding off because we've had a lot of thieving going on here lately and I didn't want nobody wrecking my little speedometer out there.  I just ain't got enough nerve to put it out with all this stuff going on right now in the last two weeks."

On the public works report Mayor Morris remarked that water use was down, and there were no comments on the parks and recreation report.  When the mayor asked for comments on the BP Home & Museum report, Garrison remarked that "the last two weeks we've had a big influx of numbers.

Browder then moved to accept all reports and the motion, seconded by Garrison, passed on a unanimous voice vote.


Special Events Insurance Policy

Moving on to old business, Mayor Morris called on City Manage Thrasher to address the issue of the city acquiring a special events insurance policy for parades in the City of Adamsville.

"Mayor, I've contacted a couple of insurance companies, and I've talked to TML (Tennessee Municipal League), and a couple of other cities that are having the same problem that we are, and the best bid I got for a 24-hour, or something like that, million dollar special coverage was $566.83.  But this agent says we don't need to buy this insurance, that the tort limits that are set by the state and our coverage under TML doesn't cause us to need this insurance.  That we supposedly have enough coverage through our policy with TML that we don't need to buy a special policy."

Thrasher pointed out that Milledgeville has cancelled its Christmas parade for this year, then he said that "one of the big problems that the insurance writers have is the throwing of candy, and it makes a difference in the policy.   And if there's horses," he added, "and four-wheelers."

Thrasher said that he and Police Chief McCall had discussed the matter and had concluded that the city should "outlaw[] horses that are not hooked to a wagon or some kind of float, and we don't have four-wheelers in the parade any more.  But the one thing we have been doing is allow people to throw candy from various and sundry vehicles.  They say that the candy, if it's going to be thrown at all, needs to come at the end of the parade where there'd be no traffic coming up."

Morris said "I think we need to decide here, then, whether we want to buy extra insurance or not," and his view was that "it don't sound like we need to."

Browder agreed, then added "a couple of things I could say.  Change the candy throwing, and depend on TML and the tort limit to keep us in the clear."

Attorney Seaton observed that "I doubt that you're going to get a policy that's not going to have" some exclusions.  But he agreed that "the candy throwing issue" was "the big thing that everyone whose thought about this has considered."

It was at this point that Michael Deal, having gotten his breath after his earlier harangue, again injected himself into the meeting.  "Could I ask a question to the chief and the attorney?  What is the city's liability for [Hwy] 64's blocked off, if there should be an emergency and someone could not get through?"

Mayor Morris chuckled and said "Gonna have to ask somebody else besides me," to which Deal snapped, "Well, that's why I'm asking the chief and the lawyer.  What would be the liability for the city?  Because I've wondered about that in small cities.  I think it's a question worth—"

"To tell you the truth," McCall responded, "I can't answer your question."

Thrasher then said, "Well, actually, if I might address it, we've talked about this a lot because I work fire rescue, and we usually put our emergency vehicles at the front of the parade so that if something goes haywire" they are not tied up in the parade.

McCall then added that there are alternate routes established to avoid any such problems.

"Okay," Deal said.  "Well, I was thinking more in the nature of an individual who would not be an emergency personnel, but you might have an extremely sick person in a car, not able to get through."

"Thank the Lord we haven't had to deal with that problem," McCall replied.  "It may be one we need to look at."

"Well," Deal said, "that's a possibility."


Industrial Park Sign

The last item of old business was the industrial park sign.  Thrasher presented the board with a mock-up of a proposed sign, with which the board members were singularly unimpressed.  After several minutes of generally disparaging remarks, Thrasher said "You don't have to make a decision.  That's the first thing I got, and the only thing I got.  Y'all can hash it out or think about it or table it, whatever you want to do."  Browder suggested that they "try again," Mike Norris, said "let's just wait," and the mayor said, "Well, you all think it over."


Non-Agenda Discussion of Street Project

As the unenthusiastic discussion of the industrial park sign petered out, Norris said, "Terry, don't you think we ought to give a little report about the meeting we had today with TDOT on the street project?"

Norris then did just that.  "We met with TDOT today in Jackson because they are requiring us to get a construction easement thing from each property owner in the area where the construction will take place."  Norris said they had been told what forms needed to be completed "and how we have to go about it," then he asked if City Attorney Seaton had been told "to get started on the title opinions."

Seaton said that he needed the plats, then Norris continued.  "What we'll need to do, and I think we would do, is to call a meeting of those property owners, have them in here and have the map and everything and show them, you know, what's going to happen, and give them the opportunity to donate their construction easements.  They are not giving up property.  All the DOT requires is a construction easement for a period of three years, and then they're done.  If the property owner doesn't want to donate it, then he can be compensated.  There is a formula that you can use that, where it comes up with a number that they can be compensated for.  It's not a lot of money, but we would have to do that.  So, we've got to get all those signed, recorded, and a deed on each one of them.  It's quite a bit of work, and we're going to have that done before we can proceed any further."

It was at this point that Michael Deal, the self-proclaimed expert on Robert's Rules of Order, addressed a question directly to Commissioner Mike Norris.  (Deal did not indicate just where in Robert's Rules of Order it says that a member of the audience is free to ignore the presiding officer of a public meeting and engage in a colloquy with a member of the commission.)  "Mike?  Are you going to have appraisals done on it, too?"

"No," Norris responded.  "You have to have an appraisal, but it doesn't have to be, I understood him to say it doesn't have to be a real appraisal."

At one point in the discussion that followed, Deal again attempted to horn in without addressing the chair.  "I've done a lot of condemnation work—" he began, only to be overridden by Attorney Seaton, who was becoming noticeable annoyed by Deal's interjections.  "There are two different easements," Seaton explained, one which would allow the city to actually construct something, such as a sidewalk, on someone's property, "and that's probably where the compensation issues might come up.  It would be my position that any compensation that someone might claim they are entitled to would be a very limited amount of money.  We're talking about a few inches in some situations, we're talking about a situation where there's been a sidewalk there.  So I wouldn't go into this volunteering, but compensation is going to be an issue.

"Now this title opinion job is a big job," Seaton continued, "and I'm afraid we might run into some problems," especially if the city finds that a minor has an interest in any of the property in question.  After some further discussion Seaton said, "Well, I'm just afraid we're going to run into some, what you know you might think are some minor problems, but when you start talking about clearing up a land title and addressing those kinds of issues—"

Norris interrupted to suggest that "you might need to call DOT and have some conversation with them, because I think this construction easement is a means of eliminating the problem, with where exactly the easement line is, and all that."

Seaton replied, "What's this guy [referring to Michael Deal] is talking about is making sure we have the legal authority by easement to use someone else's property for a sidewalk.  If they're going to be, I don't like to use the word 'nit-picky' about it, but—"

At this point Robert's Rules of Order expert Michael Deal interrupted the City Attorney to address board member Norris.  "Mike?" he said loudly.  Norris told him to "hold on just a minute," and Deal responded, "Sure."

Seaton then repeated that title opinions would be a major job, especially with the number of opinions required.  "Thirty-seven, you say?"  Norris replied, "About thirty-seven," and Thrasher said, "Between thirty-seven and forty."

There was then some discussion between the board members about how other municipalities have handled similar situations, then Robert's Rules of Order expert Michael Deal again interrupted loudly, once again addressing a member of the board rather than the presiding officer.  "Mike?  Are they talking about a permanent easement or—"

"No," Norris responded.

"Okay," Deal replied.  "Because a temporary easement, I don't mean to muddy the waters, but I've done condemnation appraisals for years, and I know what the DOT requires.  If it's a temporary easement, then they can go on that property in the time of construction, but it must be left exactly the way it was, you can't.  So if it's a permanent easement, it means they can use the portion that they are taking indefinitely, and, uh—"

Norris interrupted to say "He described it as a construction easement for a period of three years."

"Okay," Deal replied.  "That's a temporary.  Then it's going to have to be put back the same way."

"Well," Norris responded, "It's going to be better than it was before."

Deal then began to pontificate, "Under condemnation law, and this is general condemnation law—" when he was abruptly interrupted by City Attorney Seaton.

"We don't need him giving this commission legal advice.  Period."

"What's that?" a startled Deal asked, apparently astounded that anyone would object to him generously providing guidance to the board.

Seaton had clearly had enough.  "I said we don't need you giving this commission legal advice."

Deal huffily responded, "I'm not giving you legal advice," completely ignoring the fact that his exact words had been, "Under condemnation law, and this is general condemnation law …."

Seaton wasn't having any of it.  "You're making statements about what the law is."

Mayor Morris began knocking on the table, and Deal gave a dismissive laugh.

"Let's give our legal department authority to check in on all that as to what he has to do," the mayor suggested.  "Everybody agree to that?"

"Sure," Norris said.  "We have to get it done.  We can't go any further until we get that done."

"Get on with it, then," Morris said.

Seaton said that it might take three or four weeks, which the mayor said would be "okay."

Shortly afterward, self-acclaimed Robert's Rules of Order expert Michael Deal departed.


Non-Agenda Discussion of Hughes Street

Following a query by Norris about the status of the street paving program, Thrasher offered an update of the Hughes Street situation.  "The last conversation that I had was with the school board members, who said that they had decided that the 99-year lease was all they were going to be able to do.  They would not deed us the street, any more than they would deed us the ball field, because of future possible expansion of the school system, and that they thought the best thing to do would be to share the cost 50-50 with blacktopping that street.  And I said, 'Send me something in writing,' and I have not received it."

Norris asked who he had talked to, and Thrasher replied, "Frank [Lacey].  He contacted me."


Christmas Parade

Garrison then brought the discussion back to the Christmas parade.  "This is October.  Has anybody agreed to take the parade?  Are we having a Christmas parade or not?  I just think that needs to be addressed, and can we address that at this point?"

In the discussion that followed it was established that the parade's previous sponsor, the merchants association, was now defunct.

"I'd hate for us to be without a city parade," Garrison said, and Mayor Morris agreed, saying, "I'd like to see it, but I don't know who'd put it on."

Garrison said she'd be "willing to try to do my part as a commissioner and as a citizen, but you know I can't do it by myself," and Browder said "I think one thing we could look for help as far as legwork and stuff would be Adamsville schools.  I know there are several organizations out there that I'm sure if we asked would be willing to help with part of it."

"What about the arts council?" Thrasher asked.  "I don't know how active they are."

"Not very," Norris said.  "About half of them have moved away."

Finally, Debbie Moffett of the parks and recreation department spoke up.  "I suggest have the parks and recreation do it this year, and we'll see how it operates.  If it doesn't—don't think that we do a good job—then we'll see if an organization will take it."

"Sounds good to me," said the mayor, to which Garrison added, "Amen."


Offer on City Property

Thrasher informed the board that the city had received an offer to purchase approximately four acres of city property on Hwy 64.  The previous owners of the property had had it listed for some time at $25,000, and when they were unable to sell it they donated it to the city.  Thrasher said that he had been approached by people who wished to put in a Brandywine Tire distributorship and were looking for land on which to locate the business.  Thrasher showed them the property on Carol Hill, and they offered to purchase the property for $8,000.  "I said, 'Make an offer.  Put it in writing,'" and they did.  Thrasher said "They're going to distribute commercial tires nationally" and "will be servicing tractor-trailers and so forth" within six months.  Ultimately, the business will employee six people, and they would like to start construction in mid-November.

Norris remarked that the offer was "a little low," and Garrison agreed.  Mayor Morris observed that the property is not the best, then added that "We don't have a penny in it, except for moving.  We need to look at how much sales tax it will bring in."

Garrison asked "if we ought to see if there's anybody else out there that's interested in buying it that would give more."  She agreed, though, that "we need the business.  We want the business in this town.  We need the sales tax dollars."

"Nobody else is making an offer," Browder observed.

After further discussion, Browder moved "that we check into legal concerns and come back at the next meeting" and make a decision on the offer to purchase.  His motion was seconded by Norris and approved by a unanimous voice vote.


Resolution to Prohibit Cops from Public Assistance

Thrasher explained to the board that police officers are being asked to provide emergency and medical services for which they are not trained, which potentially produces liability for the city, "so we just need a resolution … that we won't do that any more, and Bill [Chief Bill McCall] will instruct his officers not to do that any more."  Thrasher explained that this will ensure that police officers call on appropriately trained personnel when they encounter such problems.  "We just need a motion and get it in the minutes that you guys are saying that we understand, and we will instruct our police officers not to do what they're not trained to do."

After extensive discussion Hudson moved "that we initiate a policy that our policemen, when answering a public assistance call, only perform duties in the realm of their expertise," and the motion, seconded by Browder, passed by unanimous voice vote.


Flu Shots for Employees

Thrasher explained that the city used to pay for flu shots for city employees, and that employees were asking that the city resume the practice.  "So I've checked around and the best price I can get is twenty-five bucks per person."  After considerable discussion Thrasher said that if the board would approve paying for the shots, "I'll find a place for them to get shots," but the board moved on to the next agenda item without taking any action.


D.A.'s Opinion on Linda Walker

Thrasher said that "everybody's familiar with" the case of Linda Walker, who has been accused of misappropriating government funds.  "Anyway, our local D.A. has a conflict of interest, so he has given it to the Hardeman County D.A., and this gentleman called me the other day and his suggestion is that we've got probably $3,275 that's been absconded, and there's about $5,100 that the state comptroller can't account for, but nobody knows that it was took.  It could have been … old tickets that we just put off and put off and put off.  That may be part of that $5,100.  But the D.A. doesn't believe that we can do it, that we can get any of it, that there's nothing we can do about it.  We received a bill from the state comptroller's office for $3,844.  So our total out of pocket is $7,119 and change.  And he says there's probably no way to get this lady any jail time.  She's got a clean record.  This is her first offence, and he wants to go after the money, and if she pays restitution to the city of Adamsville to the tune of, say seventy-one hundred and, say, twenty bucks, then they'll probably offer her diversion."

Attorney Seaton says that it's the D.A.'s call, though "we can tell him if we don't like it."

"Another thing," Thrasher then said.  "If we push it too far in the corner, that the judge would be real likely to give here a five-year payment time, and it would take at least five years to get our money, and he [the D.A.] said 'I don't want to do that.  I want to go for a lump sum payment at the front end.  You get all your money.'  It's up to you guys," Thrasher concluded.

Mayor Morris asked "why are we paying all these bonds to bond these people when we can't get nothing for the bonds?"  Norris agreed: "Why don't you get the money from the bonding company and let her pay the bonding company?"

In the discussion that followed, Thrasher argued in favor of agreeing to diversion in order to secure immediate repayment of the money, which led City Attorney Seaton to remind him of his role in this matter.  "What you're doing here, Terry, is making a report to this committee of what the D.A.'s plan is to deal with this case.  I guess it would make him feel better if you called him back tomorrow and said, 'This is fine.'  But is it fine for her to not even have a conviction?   If it is, call him back and tell him it's fine.  If it's not, then don't call him back and tell him anything.  You're going to get your money whether you, this commission, is okay with her getting diversion or not.  But I don't think, my personal opinion as a citizen of this town is that it's not okay for her to get diversion.  She might get it, whether we like it or not, but it's not okay with us.  And I wouldn't call and tell him it was okay."

Morris asked Seaton to explain what diversion meant, then he said that they had always done this in the past and let them get away with it, and "Are we going to continue to let this go on?"

Seaton responded that, "It's not up to y'all," it's the D.A.'s call.


Appoint Planning Commission Member

"All right," Mayor Morris said, moving on to the next agenda item.  "'Appoint planning commission member.'  I talked to Jeff [Browder] and he said he would accept it."

Hudson spoke up.  "I feel that—this is nothing against you, Jeff, but I feel that Mike [Norris] needs to be on that committee, because I feel like he's got a passion right now for the way this town looks, and trying to make it better, and I'd like to nominate Mike to go on the committee."

When the mayor persisted, Thrasher said to him, "You appoint the civilians, the commission appoints—"

"The commissioner [member]," Hudson finished for him.

Thrasher explained.  "You [the mayor] are automatically on it, and the commission appoints a commission member to serve on the planning commission.  The rest of the planning commission is appointed by the mayor."

"Who came up with that?" the mayor asked.

"It's in the charter," Thrasher replied.

After several minutes were spent reading through the relevant charter passages, Browder seconded Hudson's motion that the board appoint Norris as the commissioner's representative on the planning commission and the motion passed unanimously.


Appoint Beautification Committee Members

"'Appoint Beautification Committee members,'" the mayor said, reading the next item on the agenda.  "I thought we already had them."

"Well, Mayor," Thrasher replied, "you've got eight members on this committee, and two of them's terms have expired and two of them haven’t been to a meeting since I've known them.  So we need to appoint four people to this committee to fill it up."  He said he had been given the names of eight possible new members and that all but one had signified their willingness to serve.  The seven names were Mildred Pettigrew, Alpha Raines, Danny Henry, Reva Majors, Janice Ross, Camille Littlefield, and Patricia Smith.

After Thrasher read the names, Garrison said, "I'd like to nominate Ann [Hudson] for it."

After some discussion about how to select four new members, Norris said, "Why don't you put all of them on there?  What's the problem of having them all on there?"

"The charter says how many members is there," Thrasher replied.

"I mean," Norris responded, "you're talking about some pretty talented ladies right here that can do a lot.  You put them gals together and they'll get something done."

The mayor asked if four could be named as members and the rest named as auxiliaries, and after some discussion, including other potential candidates, Norris added his support to the idea and moved to "add as new members Alpha Lane, Patricia Smith, Jane Henry, and Mildred Pettigrew," and add the rest of them as alternates.  Garrison seconded the motion, which passed on a unanimous voice vote.


Garbage Rates

Thrasher advised the board that the city had received notice of a 2% increase in what it pays for garbage collection, and he said "we need to pass that on."  After some discussion the board voted unanimously, on a motion by Browder, seconded by Norris, to raise the garbage rate by 20 cents to cover the increase.


Report of Equalization Board Changes

Thrasher told the commissioners "you've got two letters in your packet, and if you'll look at them close, one of them says 'June 2,2007, Equalize Property Tax Rates.'  The next one's dated October 10, 2007, and it says 'Revised Equalized Property Tax Rate.'  You look on the first one, the second line down, the rate for McNairy County portion for the city is .8243, Hardin County portion is .744.  Well, when this came out I brought this report to you guys and explained to you what they explained to me.  That was supposed to bring in the same amount of money that we received last year with the last year's taxes.  But the board of equalization did a reappraisal in Hardin County and miscued, because when we got to figuring out the actual income that would be generated with these tax rates we were $17,000 short.  So we contacted the board of equalization, and many phone calls, and nobody has ever admitted doing nothing wrong.  But we got the letter dated October 10, and if you'll look at that one the Hardin County portion is .8142 and the McNairy County portion is .9016.  So, these two numbers will probably yield what we collected last year.

"So, what we need is a motion to accept the revised state board of equalization tax rates for Hardin and McNairy Counties.  And, like I say, this was not our mistake, that was the equalization board."

In the discussion that followed, Thrasher explained that "the homeowner in each county should pay this year the same amount of money that he paid last year," when "the tax rate was .89 in both counties."

Browder made a motion that the board accept the revised tax rates.  The motion was seconded by Norris and passed on a unanimous voice vote.


Non-Agenda Discussion of Animal Control

At this point Kay Nunnally arose and asked if she could address the board.

"I used to be a former member of the humane society and I'm a board member of the SPCA and, being a business owner, I've had people dropping animals off at my store because someone is saying that all you have to do is make a donation of food or something like that and you can just drop your animals.  It's time for the city to step up to the plate and take care of the responsibility they're supposed to take care of, because it is a Tennessee statute that animal control is supposed to be a part of the city's business, and they're not doing it.  Y'all said you would sign something with the SPCA, but nobody wants to sign that paper and give us money so we can fund what we do."

This drew a heated response from Thrasher.  "I beg to differ with you.  That article was passed by this city commission to enter into that—"

"But y'all ain't signed it," Nunnally said, interrupting Thrasher.

"Nobody's ever presented it to us," Norris said.

"The last time that," Thrasher began, then he started over.  "The little lady that drives the horsey wagon, she said that y'all were not ready to do that.  If you bring me a copy of that, we will do something."

After further heated exchanges, Thrasher returned to this point, saying that the lady had told him "We're not ready yet, because we don't have room to pick up any dogs."

Nunnally replied, "We don't have any room," to which Thrasher responded, "Well, then, how are you going to enter into an agreement, if I call you to pick up a dog and you got no place to put it?"

"Y'all have to provide it for the citizens," Nunnally said. "so y'all need to figure out what to do.  That is a state statute."


Ann Hudson, Farewell Remarks

As this was Hudson's last meeting as a commissioner, she had asked to be placed on the agenda to make some farewell remarks.  "I just wanted to tell the board and everybody here and all the employees and everything that in the past six years I've learned a lot.  I've learned that you've got to have a lot of patience, because people just think you can run in and do something, and you can't.  You have to go through proper channels, and, anyway, it's been a learning experience, and I have enjoyed working with the employees and the other commissioners and I just wanted to say thanks, and I'll keep you in my prayers, and if there's anything that I can do to help, just let me know."


Department of Dead Horses

At this point, roughly an hour and forty-five minutes into the meeting, with all the agenda items having finally been covered, the mayor was preparing to adjourn the meeting when Thrasher said, "Mayor?"

"What?" Morris responded.  "There ain't nothing else on my agenda."

"Well, no," Thrasher replied, "but I need to get—  What are we going to do about this?  Didn't you [addressing Browder] have a travel thing you wanted to bring up?"

"I did," Browder replied.  "I'm sure you've got it there."

"Y'all need to put these thing on the agenda, you know," the mayor said.

"We need to start following that," Norris agreed.

"I've had it here for a week and a half," Browder said.  "It should have been on there."

"Well, what is it?" asked Norris.

"You have to have a request to travel," Thrasher responded, "to attend training for elected officials."

Browder explained that he wanted to attend a training session for elected officials which had been rescheduled from last year to this November 2-3.

The mayor then said, "All you have to do most times is bring it and let me look at it, 'cause it flat says in here—"

"Tell me where that is," Hudson immediately said.  "Show me."

And with that the commission began twenty-odd minutes of ritual dead-horse-beating over the subject of travel authorization, with Hudson, Garrison, an Norris claiming that the mayor had no authority to approve or disapprove travel requests, the mayor claiming that he did, and City Attorney Seaton saying that the problem with the travel ordinance "is that it doesn't define what an authorized traveler is."

The mayor, who had provided the commissioners with copies of the travel ordinance in advance of the August town board meeting, took the position that the ordinance gave the mayor authority to approve and disapprove travel requests.  "Mayor Moody got that passed.  He thought that was being abused at one time.  He got that passed.  He was the mayor, was the one supposed to okay all the travel."

Hudson kept arguing that the language in the ordinance ("The chief administrative officer of the city or his or here designee shall be responsible for the enforcement of the travel regulations") only gave the chief administrative officer the power to enforce the regulations, not to approve travel requests, and she repeatedly accused Morris of denying travel requests that where made before he advised them of his intent to enforce his interpretation of the travel ordinance.

Thrasher and Norris suggested that the city administrator, rather than the mayor, was the chief administrative officer of the city, which would mean that the enforcement powers belonged to Thrasher, rather than Mayor Morris.  However, as City Attorney Seaton pointed out, there was no city manager in 1993 when the ordinance was adopted.  "What's your title," he asked Thrasher.

"City Administrator/Recorder," Thrasher replied.

"There was no city administrator," Seaton said.

"No, but there was a recorder," Thrasher responded, as though that settled it.

"I don't know who is the chief administrative officer of the city," Seaton replied, "but I'm inclined to think the city mayor."

Not surprisingly, the mayor agreed.  "The mayor," he said.  "It's in there.  The mayor—"

"Where does it say that?" Norris demanded.  "Nowhere in there does it say that the mayor alone can approve or disapprove travel."

Seaton kept insisting that the problem with the ordinance was that "there is no definition in there, no means for a person to become authorized to travel," which really did nothing to address the dispute regarding whether the mayor had authority to approve or disapprove travel requests.

Norris contended that all the problems regarding travel authorization had been worked out at the special October 5 called meeting.  "We had a meeting on the 5th of October to address this situation.  The mayor left.  He didn't want to be a part of the meeting."

"It was illegal," Mayor Morris interjected.

"He said it was illegal," Norris continued.  "I don't agree with that, but, anyway, we went on and met as a commission.  And we don't, I think, necessarily dispute that there needs to be some preapproval for travel.  Now I was not aware that there is a preapproval form, which we have to use.  I was not aware of that.  Okay?  We all agreed that in the future that we would bring a form like this to the meeting and whoever needed to go some place, and vote on it as a body.  Okay?  So, the reason for the meeting was that, we talked, there was a conference in Chattanooga on tourism.  We all talked about it.  The mayor is aware of that.  Nobody wanted to go, so I volunteered to go, and so I went.  I got back and turned in my expenses, and the mayor got it and said  he would not sign the check for my salary—  for my mileage.  He has signed the check for the credit card, which to me means that he is accepting my expenses.  But he still has not signed my check on my mileage. 

"Now, I have discussed this with Ronnie Neal at MTAS at length, got some information from him, and he has called his attorney in Nashville, today, and the attorney's said that it's in the mayor's best interest to sign the check.  Now, if he is not willing to sign the check, we have two other people here that can sign the check—Mr. Thrasher and Debbie.  Now, if he don't want to sign the check, that's fine, but they can.  I don't make a habit of making these trips, but, you know, somebody else wants to go, fine.  But we need to be about our business in attending these conferences.

"So, I've got all the information right here.  If you'd like it, you're more than welcome to read it, but this is what I got from Mr. Neal today."

Browder then said, "All I have done is what I read the travel policy to say. I've brought my forms before the travel to be approved or disapproved.  That's all I've done.  There are my forms, filled out."

"Well," Norris said, "I'm sort of stuck in the middle, but I didn't do that.  And I want to apologize to the mayor and the commission because I didn't do that, and I'll do that in the furture.  But I'm still stuck here with this, and I'd like to resolve it one way or the other.  Now we voted the other day in the commissioners meeting, called, to pay my expenses.  Now, if you don't want to, fine.  We're in a meeting that is legal now, so I'd like for you to vote on it and approve it."

Seaton said, "I think that needs to happen."

Mayor Morris then read part of the charter that pertained to emergency meetings, whereupon Norris said the October 5 meeting was not an emergency meeting, it was a special called meeting.  "But it don't matter," he continued, "because, okay, if it was an illegal meeting throw it away.  But we're in a legal meeting now, so let's vote on it."

Hudson then observed that preapproval had not been insisted on in the past and "this hasn't come up before.  Why is it coming up now?"

"Because we're traveling quite a bit," the mayor responded.  "We're traveling, we're spending a lot of money."

Hudson then argued extensively that the mayor was applying his new rules retroactively, and the mayor insisted that he had given the commissioners notice.  "Y'all got it in your packet, that the mayor had to approve each travel."

"That's just not true, Mayor," Norris said.  "You do not have the right to approve or disapprove travel by yourself.  You do not."

"Well, I'm glad y'all—" he began, then he said, "I've got it in writing."

Attorney Seaton cut through the ensuing squabble by saying, "You know, let's get past this.  If the commission wants to vote to reimburse Mike for taking that trip, y'all need to vote on it, and y'all need to come up with some policy that addresses this problem and follow it and move on to other things."  He then returned to his point that the ordinance doesn't define how someone becomes an authorized traveler, whereupon Norris asked, "Do you have a copy of the minutes of the special meeting?"

"No," Seaton responded, tersely.

"Well," Norris said, "you ought to get a copy of that, because we addressed every bit of that."

Seaton replied, "Well, there's some concern about whether adequate notice was given for the meeting, and I think you ought to clean it up by voting on it tonight, or next month, or whenever, and deal with the reimbursement issue and—"

Garrison interrupted.  "May I make a motion that the commission vote on reimbursing Mike Norris for his travel expenses to and from the seminar, is that what you're saying, Ken?"

Seaton replied, "It's my understanding that y'all voted to do that this last meeting.  There's a concern about the notice that the public was given.  The position could be taken that that action was illegal.  The sunshine law is vague, but evidently, according to the newspaper, some lawyer has given the opinion that there wasn't adequate notice, so my suggestion is—"

Norris then interrupted.  "You know what?  Forget about my check.  Just tear mine up.  That's okay.  I really don't want to pursue this any more.  I don't need the money.  I think it is not right.  I think the mayor is doing wrong.  I have documents here that says that if he don't want to sign the check that this commission can make another resolution and we can change who signs the checks.  Not just these, but any of them."

"I don't think you can do that," Mayor Morris stated.

"I have it in writing," Norris replied.

Seaton said, "Mike, what I am saying, the basis the mayor could have for not signing the check is the notice that was given for the meeting."

"That's fine," Norris said.  "Just forget my check.  What I'd like to address—  This is what I'd like to address.  In the future any travel expenses that we have to do, that anybody should submit a form like this prior to their needing to go at an official meeting to have it approved or disapproved by this commission and the mayor.  The mayor cannot approve or disapprove travel by himself."

"I think you're wrong," Morris said.  "It's in the ordinance."

Browder then said, "Well, it appears to me that what we have in our travel, our personnel policy that this came out of and that expense report that you filed when you returned came out of, haven't got anything to do with the ordinance.  Looks like we're going to have to make those two books coincide with each other before anybody knows what's going on.  That's what I'm doing, is doing exactly what our travel policy instructs a person to do, is fill this form out right here."

Hudson eventually made a motion that Browder, Garrison, and Norris all be authorized to attend the November 2-3 sessions in Selmer, whereupon Mayor Morris said, "I think if them three are going, and if they'll come back and report, you won't hear much from me.  But it's just going, and we get these bills, is where I come in there."

"I gave you a full-page report on the trip to Chattanooga," Norris said.  "Did you read it?"

"I never seen it," Morris replied.

"It was behind my expense report," Norris said.

"I never seen your expense report," the mayor then said.

Norris then asked, "How can you approve it or disapprove it if you didn't even look at it?"

Norris asked Thrasher if he had given the report to the mayor, and Morris responded "No" before Thrasher could answer.

"Yes, I did, Mayor," Thrasher said.  "You haven't seen that check?"

"I've seen the check, yeah," the mayor said, "but I didn't see nothing back here."

"That's the package the way I got it," Thrasher insisted.

"Well," the mayor said again, "I didn't see it.  The only thing I seen was the bills from the credit card."

In the ensuing crosstalk, Hudson could be heard observing, "These Robert's Rules of Order completely went out the door!"

Finally, Garrison seconded Hudson's motion that the three commissioners be authorized to attend the November 2-3 session and it passed unanimously, as did the long, long, long awaited motion to adjourn.



Local preacher uses pretext of offering a prayer to lecture mayor and board on how to run meeting

15 October 2007


At its September meeting the Adamsville town board had voted to revive the practice of opening each meeting with a prayer, but when Michael Deal of the Mt. Sharon Presbyterian Church stood up at the beginning of the October meeting of the town board, it was not as a humble supplicant to the Creator.  Instead, Deal hijacked the public meeting and spent ten minutes telling Adamville's mayor and town board that they were a bunch of incompetent clowns.  Deal claimed to be qualified to do this because—as he said twice, with a completely straight face—he had memorized Robert's Rules of Order.  A remarkable claim, inasmuch as Robert's Rules of Order is more than 200 pages long and contains something in the neighborhood of 30,000 words.  Nevertheless, Deal put forth this extraordinary claim as his justification for pointing out the transgressions of Adamsville's elected officials.

[It was unclear who had arranged for Deal's presence at the meeting—city manager Terry Thrasher said the following day that he didn't know who was responsible, though he thought it might have been Commissioner Dwana Garrison, since she was the one who had made the motion to reinstitute the practice of opening with a prayer.]

Instead of praying, as he rose to his feet Deal said, "I want a minute or two of your time to preach and pray, too."  He told the board and more than a dozen spectators that he believed that God had ordained government to provide services to the people, and that he understood that we have to have politicians to run government.  But….

"I've seen so many times when it seems to me that by virtue of being a politician you have the right to engage in character assassination and calling your neighbor names.  That's not the way God intended it, folks.  In fact, a lawyer asked Jesus one time, to try to trap him, 'What's the great commandment?'  And He said 'Love God with all your heart, mind, and strength.'  And immediately He paused and He said, 'Love your neighbor as yourself.'  And we claim to live by the Golden Rule, of doing unto others as we would have them do unto us."

[In Mark's gospel the question is asked by "a scribe," while Matthew and Luke call the questioner a "lawyer."]

"The first time I came before this body was about two weeks, maybe longer than that, before I became a citizen of Adamsville," Deal continued, "and I have to tell you that when I left—I haven't said this to anybody—I want to say this to this commission, I'm saying to you what a lot of people think.  I'm saying it to you as a citizen of Adamsville and as a minister of the Gospel—I was shocked at the way the meeting was conducted.  No order, no one having, seemingly, any understanding of Robert's Rules of Order whatsoever.  According to your charter you're supposed to conduct your meetings in accordance with Robert's Rules of Order.  And I tell you, I know that document quite well, because a lot of years ago I had to memorize it.

"I had to memorize it," Deal repeated, driving home his unique qualifications with this claim to have super-human powers of memory.

"It bothers me when I know that people in Savannah and people in Selmer are making fun of the way our government is being conducted.  Now, this is not easy for your delicate ears, I realize that, but that's what's going on.  I'd like to be proud of our government here, and even though I haven't been here that long, I'm still a citizen.  I pay taxes.  I'm part of this community, and I plan on being a part for a while, unless you decide to run me out."

"It just kind of sickens me to the bone to know that you elected officials are conducting yourselves in such a manner that people outside this community are laughing at us.  And that's what's going on.

"Let me just say one or two things, and I'll give the prayer, okay?" he said to the dumbfounded board, before lecturing them on the finer points of Robert's Rules of Order.  "Any chairperson of any committee, of any group, regardless of what it is, per Robert's Rules of Order, cannot make a motion, you cannot second a motion, you cannot enter into the discussion of a motion, and the only vote you have is with a tie vote."

"So, what I am saying to you, Mr. Mayor, as someone who knows Robert's Rules of Order, if you are the chairperson of this committee, your only function is to carry on this meeting, to take motions, dispense of those motions, to ask for discussion of those motions, and that's it."

When Mayor Morris attempted to speak, Deal overrode him: "Wait a minute!  I have the floor.  Let me finish.

"Whether, whether you engage, whether you want to follow Robert's Rules of Order, that's okay," Deal barged on, somewhat incoherently, before regaining his stride.  "What I'm saying to you is this.  And you can take this as a joke if you want to.  But I can tell you as an outsider who's just come in, you have not made the people of Adamsville proud by your actions and what you've done on this committee.

"We are a government of the people, by the people, and for the people," Deal pontificated, "and you should be carrying out programs here for the people of Adamsville, and stop your petty bickering and name-calling.

"Now that may sound like a strange prayer, but I felt like, as a citizen of this community, when I was asked to come, that was going to be part of my prayer."

Then, seven minutes after the mayor had asked him to say a word of prayer to start the meeting, Deal finally got around to it.  "Let us pray.

"Almighty God, I pray that what I have said has been pleasing to you.  I pray for these leaders of this city of Adamsville.  We're a small city, but yet our government is supposed to function like the governments of the large cities, and of the states and even of the nation.  We are a representative government.  Father, open their ears and allow them to hear the voice of the people.  Help them, Lord, to realize that they owe to one another total respect, and they owe total respect and accountability to those who helped put them in office.  I ask you to bless them, bless their decisions and everything they do.  In the name of Christ, amen."

At this point Mayor Morris made the understandable mistake of thinking that the "amen" signified that Deal was finally prepared to allow the town board meeting to proceed.  "Before we go any further," Morris said, "I'd like to say that this committee years ago voted to give the mayor a vote."

"You can't do that by Robert's Rules of Order," Deal exclaimed.  He then resorted to condescension.  "Mr. Mayor, listen.  I'm not questioning your authority as mayor, but what I'm saying to you is that under Robert's Rules of Order any chairperson of any committee of any group can never be given the authority to vote, to make a motion, to second a motion.  All you can do—  Now, if you don't want to be the chairperson, then somebody else needs to.  I'm just telling you that if you want to abide by Robert's Rules of Order, and Mr. Mayor, respectfully, I would say to you that if you do not understand Robert's Rules of Order you need to have an unbiased third party who will sit here and make certain that your meetings are being conducted in accordance with those rules, so that it will be conducted properly.  They cannot give you that authority under Robert's Rules of Order."

Deal refrained from suggesting to the mayor where he might find such an "unbiased third party," oh, say, someone who had committed all 200 pages of Robert's Rules of Order to memory.  And Deal's awe-inspiring interest in the operation of Adamsville's government did not prevent him from leaving the meeting long before it was over.

[A complete report of the real business of the 15 October town board meeting will follow.]



Unofficial election results

7:46 p.m., Saturday, 6 October

In Saturday’s municipal election for the town of Adamsville to fill the two alderman seats presently occupied by Ann Hudson and Dwana Garrison, newcomer Frank Lacey led the field with 267 votes and Garrison came in second with 197 votes.  Finishing in third place, with 179 votes, incumbent Alderman Ann Hudson will leave the board at the end of the year.

A total of 475 ballots were cast, with the following results (voters could vote for two of the six candidates):

Harvey Durham, 113
Dwana Garrison, 197
Ann Hudson, 179
Frank Lacey, 267
David Orman, 22
Scotty Pugh, 151

These are unofficial early returns.




Special
Town Board Meeting

3 October 2007

Town Board Defies Mayor

It may have been "the best day" of Commissioner Dwana Garrison's life, but it was far from being the best day in the life of the City of Adamsville.

The occasion for Garrison's comment, voiced during a special called meeting at Adamsville City Hall on the late afternoon of October 3, was Mayor Tommy Morris's abrupt departure from the meeting he had called to order only minutes before.

As the mayor left the room Garrison said loudly, "Thank you, Mayor.  Good to see you."

"Good to see you," the mayor responded from the hallway.

"Yeah, thank you sir," Garrison said as she turned to the press, smiling broadly.  "This has been the best day of my life.  Y'all just don't know how happy I am."

Morris had begun the meeting by saying that discussion would be confined to the subject of "city travel cost" and that "no other business will be conducted as this is an illegal called meeting."

Commissioner Ann Hudson immediately objected.  "I think we need to rephrase the introduction because you said this is an illegal called meeting, and it is not illegal."

"I'm the mayor," Morris responded.  "I can say what I want to say."

"Okay," Hudson replied, "but I still say that we need to—"

"Well, you can do that after I leave," Morris interrupted.

Hudson responded, "No, I'll do it now."

Mayor: "Well, it's not going to go in the minutes."

Hudson: "Yes it is."

Mayor: "No it's not."

Hudson: "Well, okay, you can say what you want and I can say what I want.  [Turning to the others:]  This is a legal called meeting, is it not?"

Norris: "Yes."

Mayor: "No."

Hudson: "Why?"

Mayor: "Only legal called meetings if for emergencies.  This is not an emergency.  This could be discussed at the next meeting."

Mayor Morris then asked, "Do I have a motion to adjourn?"  There was a long pause, during which no one said anything, then the mayor said "I don't see a motion.  Well, ya'll can have the meeting," and with that he got up and headed for the door.  It was at this point that Garrison shouted out her cheerful goodbye.

With the mayor's departure, control of the meeting fell to Commissioner Mike Norris, the vice mayor, who said, "Well, the reason that I wanted to call the meeting is because I have an expense report that I turned in as a result of a trip to attend the governor's conference on tourism and hospitality.  We all talked about this, as I remember, and I said I would go.  Nobody seems to have objected to that, and somebody needed to go.  Commissioner Garrison went also, but she was sponsored by the Pusser Foundation …."

Garrison interrupted to say, "Since the city would not pay for it," which led Commissioner Jeff Browder to ask her, "When did the city say it wouldn't pay for you going?"  Garrison then admitted that she had not in fact asked the city to cover the cost. "I was scared to ask, after the last meeting that I brought it up, whenever I was trying to get, you know, whenever I brought up the thing about wanting somebody from parks and recreation, and the foundation had to come back and pay mine because I was too scared to ask for the mayor, after I got jumped so bad, I was scared to ask, to be honest with you."

Norris then said, "Well, let me finish.  All I'm here for is that my expense report says that I am owed $197 for mileage, and that's what I would like.  That's all I am here for."

Hudson then asked that the ordinance regarding travel policy be read, and Norris read the following: "In the interpretation and application of this ordinance, the term Traveler or Authorized Traveler means any elected or appointed municipal officer or employee, including members of municipal boards and committees appointed by the mayor or the municipal governing body, and the employees of such boards and committees who are traveling on official municipal business and whose travel was authorized in accordance with this ordinance.  Authorized Travelers shall not include the spouse, children, or other relatives, friends, or companions accompanying the Authorized Traveler under this ordinance."

"Okay," Hudson said, "and I think the mayor was under the impression that he was supposed to approve, before anybody—"

"But it doesn't say that anywhere in here," Norris interrupted.  "It does say this: It says 'The Chief Administrative Officer.'  Now, I question whether that is Mr. Thrasher or Mr. Morris.  Personally, I think it's Mr. Thrasher, because he is the City Administrator, and I think it would be his daily duty to be responsible for the enforcement of these travel regulations.  And that's what it says.  Nowhere in here does it say that the mayor can approve or disapprove travel expenses. 

"Now, with all that said," Norris continued, "let me try to use a little common sense here.  I decided to run for commissioner and be elected so that I could do something for my community.  It certainly was not because of the money.  You know, $100 a month doesn't go very far, so it sure wasn't for that.  It's because I love this community, and I want to see it prosper, and I see a lot of things that could be done here if we put effort into it.  And that's why I have from time to time tried to put some effort into attending these conferences, that are learning experiences.  I haven't even been in this position for two years yet.  So I'm still learning, and I meet people, and, uh, you know, so it's, we've got to do that, folks, if we're going to help this community move forward.  Somebody's got to be out here, attending these things, I mean, we brought back some good stuff from this particular conference that we didn't even discuss yet.  But…
   
"I took three days out of my life, my business sat still for three days, I'm a small business person.  There's only myself and my wife that run that business, and if we're not there that business does not run.  So, it cost me some money to take the time to go on this trip.  And it cost a whole lot more than $197, I'll assure you of that."

Norris then spoke about what the town charter had to say about the relative positions of the mayor and the council.  "The charter says that the mayor, he is the honorary executive member of the city government.  He has a seat, a voice, and one vote.  No veto power.  So do the commissioners.  They have a seat, and they have one vote.  So as a unit, we're five people.  Majority rules.  I have talked with MTAS, and you can be dissatisfied with people in your group, but when it comes right down to it, whenever you need to get something done, the vote of the commission rules.  It doesn't matter what the mayor says.  He can recommend.  He can submit.  But he can't force anything on you.  You, the four of us, have the right to either vote in or vote out something."

"Well," Hudson said, "what I've read also, in the charter, is that the mayor has the responsibility to make sure receipts in travel are turned in.  That is his job to make sure he gathers all the receipts to cover any travel expenses that are reimbursed.  Now, he does have the responsibility to do that—"

"Well, the chief administrative officer does," Norris said.  "Who is that?"

"But, anyway," Hudson continued, " I do not find anywhere that it's his duty to authorize, I'm like you [Norris], I agree.  And, I'm just going to make a motion that Mike's expenses be reimbursed, along with the proper receipts, for this amount that he's requested."

"It's mileage," Norris clarified, before Garrison seconded the motion.

Councilman Jeff Browder then observed that "all this can be easily taken care of if we simply follow the procedures" outlined in the ordinance, which he then rapidly read through.  "I agree 100%, Mike.  You should have been there.  I wish I could have been there."

Hudson chimed in, "I wish I could have gone."

"It's a good thing that you went," Browder continued, "but all this turmoil, I think, could be alleviated had we followed procedures."

This drew immediate contradictions from both Norris and Hudson.  "I don't agree with that," Norris said.  "No, I don't think so either," added Hudson.

The exchange then got testy, with Norris beginning a sentence with "I agree about—" only to be interrupted by "No, no, no—" from Browder, to which Norris responded "Well, let me finish," which prompted a loud "Look here—" from Browder.

"Let me finish," Norris repeated.  "You said yours.  Let me say mine.  I think you're right about getting pre-approval, but now do you really think he was going to pre-approve it?  I don't think so."

"I don't think it's up to him to pre-approve it," Browder said.

"It's not," Hudson agreed.

"Well, who is going to approve it?" Norris asked.

"The commission," Hudson replied

"You're going to bring every one of them before the commission?" Norris asked.

"Certainly," Browder replied.  "It's spending money.  I don't see any problem with that at all.  If I need to go, or if I feel like I got a need to go, what is the hindrance of filling out a form saying this is where I'm going, what it costs to register, it's going to cost this to stay, bring it to the meeting the month before you go and say 'I'd like to do this'?"

At this point Garrison, who had at several other points attempted to draw attention to her dust-up at the August meeting [see the report of the 20 August meeting, below] which was abruptly ended when Garrison's own shouting match with the mayor led to the walk-out of Norris and Hudson, lectured her fellow councilmen on the importance of getting along.  "We don't need to be walking out on any more meetings," she said.  " I'm sorry, but it's my meeting, too, and y'all stay with me or I'll stay with you or whatever we do, and if anybody has had any reason to walk out I sure have had a lot of them.  But I've tried to hang on, because I've tried to do what was right. I brought the documentation [to the August meeting] and said, 'Here, I want this please to happen,' and it wasn't for me, it was for somebody else in our department so they could go learn.  But yet I thought I'd done the right thing by bringing it to you all and asking you all to vote.  I was told by people here in city hall that they were afraid to ask him, which was the mayor.  And that's why I brought our travel plan to do so.  So from now on, I guess that's what we're all going to do.  And since we're here doing that, is it out of line for me to ask if the commission if Teddy Hughes can go to this thing on our parks and recreation?  He's assistant director."

"You can't ask that now,"  Hudson replied, "but you can at the next meeting.  Will that be too late?"

Garrison said the conference wasn't until November.

"I've got one that I'm going to in November," Browder said.  "I will have my forms filled out and ready the next meeting for the commission and the mayor to either approve or disapprove."

Everyone then agreed with Hudson's suggestion that they all start using the necessary forms and submitting them for approval by the commission, and the motion to approve Norris's $197 mileage claim was unanimously approved on a roll call vote, whereupon the special called meeting was adjourned.


After the meeting

Asked after the meeting why it had been necessary to convene a special meeting, Garrison said, "The reason was because they just signed the checks, the mayor refused to sign the checks on travel expenses for Mr. Norris to attend the Tennessee governor's conference on tourism."  Pressed on why this could not have waited for the next regular meeting on October 15, she said, "They felt it was necessary, because, to get the checks signed and get the bills sent off in a timely manner, is my understanding."  She then added, "I think it was because we needed to get the checks sent off because of the way they signed the checks and when the mayor refused to sign the check on Monday, that's what caused this meeting to be brought then, and it needed to be sent off due to these, or other bills, too, that you [Norris] incurred."

"No," said Norris, who was standing beside her.  "I went to the conference, and I did not get approval.  I've done that before.  The mayor is on a tyrant [sic] about what he feels like he should govern.  Okay?  Which, I probably would give him a little slack on that, but now, you know, this is the second time I've done something like this this year, and it's just like I said, you know, we don't have anybody going to these conferences, and we need somebody going, and so I went."

When told that that still didn't answer the question of why it had to be handled at a special called meeting rather than at the regular October meeting, Norris replied, "I don't know.  I just felt like calling it. That's just personal opinion, from me.  You can call a special meeting if you get three of the commissioners sign on the dotted line."

Norris said that the mayor "didn't think it was an emergency.  It probably wasn't an emergency.  There again, you people know we've got friction here.  I'm just sort of tired of sitting around and letting stuff like this just go by.  You know.  He doesn't intimidate me.  I'm not scared of him.  I don't know what's going to, if he doesn't sign that check, I'm going to take it to a higher authority.  I don't need the money; it's the principle of the thing.  He's just putting his thumb down on everybody."

Asked about the specific language in the charter regarding called special meetings, Norris found the relevant section.  "Well, it says, 'The commission shall meet in a special session on written notice of the mayor or three commissioners if in their opinion the welfare of the city demands it.'  So we're to a point where I feel like it's in the welfare, the interest of the community here to try and stop it."  He said that all four of the commissioners signed on for the special meeting, "'cause they're fed up with it, too."

Norris also mentioned that "the mayor sent out a letter to every registered voter here in town.  Have you heard about that?"  At least one registered Adamsville voter was left out: "We didn't get one," Hudson said.  "I've been to the post office and I haven't gotten one."

The letter which other registered voters evidently did receive contained two sheets of paper.  The first was a handwritten note which read: "I would really appreciate it if you would vote for Frank Lacy and Scotty Pugh for the 2 new commissioner seats.  I believe both to be highly qualified.  I need some help to get the things done that needs to be done, instead of pet projects.  Thanks, Tommy Morris, Mayor."  The second was a typed sheet addressed "TO ADAMSVILLE VOTERS" and signed "CONCERNED CITIZENS FOR A CHANGE."  It read, in its entirety:

"This letter is in answer to an ad in last weeks Independent Appeal.

"Randy Rinks was responsible for acquiring the stoplight in town not as stated in the paper.

"The City of Adamsville has not received a grant for a water tank.

"The downtown project is still on hold due to some irregularities in the grant.

"It is known that a Pusser Corporation has been formed to handle the finances of Pusser festivities and receives proceeds, while city employees are used to help promote the festivities.

"What happened to the "Biggest Little Town in Tennessee?"  Now we have a man with a stick.

"Our mayor needs commissioners that work for the good of the city, not meet in secret before meetings and decide how they will vote.  He has no cooperation from the present commissioners, please think about this when you vote October 6.

"Successful business, operated (restaurant) buildings & equipment was reposed and foreclosed by the banks."

Norris had a final comment about the letter.  "None of that's true," he said.  "None of that's true."


Town Board Meeting

17 September 2007


The Mayor's Endorsement Ad

For the second month running, it was a non-agenda matter which generated the most attention at the Adamsville Town Council meeting September 17.  At the end of regular business, when Adamsville Mayor Tommy Morris asked if anyone in the audience had anything to say, Independent Appeal staff writer Heather Atlee addressed a question to the mayor and the commissioners: "Do you think it is ethical for a mayor or commissioner to personally endorse city candidates—"

"Yes—," Mayor Morris immediately interjected.

"—in the general election," Atlee concluded.

"—I think that," Morris finished.

As they were both speaking at the same time, Atlee had not heard what the mayor said.  "Pardon?" she asked.

"Because it's my right," Morris responded.

(What gave rise to this odd exchange was an ad the Adamsville mayor had placed in the September 12 edition of the Selmer newspaper.  On October 6 Adamsville will elect two commissioners from a field of six candidates which includes two incumbents, Ann Hudson and Dwana Garrison.  Morris's ad did not name either of the incumbents and alluded to them only indirectly.  "It's time to elect two new Commissioners," the ad read one place, and in another, "We have four new people who are running for two seats on the board."  In the ad Morris observed that he has two more years to serve as mayor, "then that will be it."  The ad then states "For my last two years I wish you would vote in two new Commissioners I could work with.  My last six years have been rough, everything I tried to do for the betterment of the city the other four commissioners would vote against it.  Please elect two new commissioners who will work for the interest of the citizens of Adamsville and not personal pet projects."  Morris specifically endorsed Frank Lacey and Scottie Pugh, calling them the best qualified and saying "I believe I could work very closely with these two.")

After several seconds of silence, Atlee asked another question: "How important do you feel any candidate, how important do you think it is for them to come to commission meetings?"

"The candidates?" Morris asked.

"Yes," Atlee replied.  "Before they are elected."

"It's not important.  Most people don't.  Most never have.  You didn't, did you, Jeff?" Morris said, addressing the question to Commissioner Jeff Browder, who does not come up for reelection until 2009.

"I was barely a resident before the election," Browder said.  "No, I don't know of many people that ever come to them."

"I did," said Commissioner Ann Hudson, one of the two incumbents who is running for reelection.  "I came several months before I started to run."

"I did also," said Dwana Garrison, the other incumbent who is also in the race.  "I think you have to educate yourself….  You don't know what you're getting into.  It's not a one night a month deal.  If you think it is, and if you are wanting it for the title, you're looking up the wrong tree.  You're going to get a whole lot more."

Hudson agreed.  "You need to orient yourself with the way things are done, and not just come in and expect, I don't know what you expect if you don't attend the meetings."

Though no one mentioned it, neither of the two candidates endorsed by Mayor Morris was present at the meeting, but Dave Orman, one of the two "new" candidates that Morris had not endorsed, was there, and his wife Angie told the mayor and the town board that she was "very, very offended" by the mayor's ad.  "Because a lot of people don't personally know him, so how can you make a judgment call that two people are going to make the best city commissioners without knowing somebody?  You know, I mean, that's very offensive."

"I've got the prerogative to say what I want," Morris responded.

"Yeah," Angie Orman replied, "but you don't know him.  That's why I took that offense."

Dave Orman told the mayor that he was "kind of bothered" by the fact that the ad only named four of the six people in the race.

"It's your privilege to be bothered," Morris replied.  "I've got my rights.  I served my country to get my rights, and I'm going to say my rights.  And I've always said them and I'll continue to say them.  What I think.  They may be right, they may be wrong, but I'm going to say them."

"Well, I respect that, Mayor," Orman said, ending the discussion on a high note.  "I certainly respect your rights."

The last word, though, came from Commissioner Browder, just before the meeting actually ended.  "I've got one quick thing to say before we adjourn," Browder said.  "I'm speaking entirely for myself.  [That] ad was put in there by one individual.  It doesn't have anything to do with the commissioners, or this commissioner that's not up for election.  That's an individual thing."


Christmas Parade

Although it, too, was not on the agenda, the Adamsville Christmas Parade was discussed at length.

"Are we going to have a Christmas Parade, or not going to have one?" Mayor Morris asked, "because we've got to do something about the liability.  We don't want to wind up like Selmer is about to get into."

The board members and town attorney Ken Seaton discussed a number of liability issues, including automobiles, trucks, 4-wheelers and horses.  "It's not the horses," Adamsville Police Chief Bill McCall remarked, "it's the people that are riding them."  McCall was particularly concerned about "stunting" by vehicle drivers, but he observed that "Anything is going to be a potential liability.  At least we can tone it down some so that we can control it, bercause if we don't it's going to get plumb out of control.  Everybody that's got a truck wants it in the parade."

Mayor Morris said "I think the main thing we have trouble with is parents not watching their kids.  They go down to one end of town and they go to the other end of town and the kids runs after the candy."

Chief McCall immediately agreed.  "That's the biggest thing that my department has seen these past years as a danger.  Santa Claus, yes, maybe he could throw candy, but other people are throwing candy in the parade and that can be a real danger," because the kids run out into the parade route to get it.  "Santa's fine, because our units are behind him all the way.  They're going to keep the traffic back," he said.  "But the main thing right now is candy-throwing in the middle of that parade, not at the end of it."

Hudson asked, "Do we give people that are in the parade, do we give them a list of things they can and cannot do?" and Commissioner Mike Norris wanted to know "Do you have them sign any kind of a form of responsibility?"

City Recorder Jimmie Burks said "We just have the form you fill out.  It just describes what you've got in [the parade].  It does not have any actual rules."

"I'd say that's what you ought to put the rules on," Norris said, "and something about themselves being liable for anything that happens."

Attorney Seaton said, "Well, that form wouldn't take away the city's liability of the city otherwise had liability."

Norris asked whether the town could "buy a one-time insurance for one night, to cover a parade?"

"You'll have to talk to the insurance man back there," Seaton said, indicating insurance agent Harvey Durham who was in the audience.

"Yes," Durham said.  "You can buy an event policy.  You might ought to consider an umbrella policy, but you're going to have to have an event policy before, to cover that, to pick up any umbrella that's left over after a law suit such as Selmer's got."

Mayor Morris asked Durham to check into such a policy for the town.


Hughes Street

Attorney Seaton updated the board on the situation regarding title to and paving of Hughes Street  At the August meeting the board had asked him and city manager Terry Thrasher to get with school board attorney Craig Kennedy to arrange for the school board to deed over Hughes Street to the city of Adamsville, in return for which Adamsville would keep the street paved.  "That was the condition that the commission talked about concerning the pavement of that road."  Seaton said that he had talked to Kennedy several times about it, and that on Friday Kennedy "made some comment to me like, indicating that the school board was out of the mood to make the city a deed to the street."

Seaton said that Kennedy had told him, "Now you know there's a 99-year lease to the city."  Seaton said he had not realized that, and Kennedy promised to get him a copy of the lease.  Seaton said that he had since looked over the lease, which includes the provision that "either side can terminate the lease with 30 days written notice.  It does say, if it is needed for school purposes.  The lease can be terminated at any point."  The city pays one dollar a year for the lease of the property, which includes the old football field.

Commissioner Browder speculated about the reasons for the school board's hesitance about deeding the property over to the city.  "They might be thinking if they deed that to the city and they [later] want to make an expansion over there then they don't have that property."

Parks and Recreations Director Debbie Moffett added some support to Browder's theorizing.  "We did try to purchase the old football field from the board of education" three or four years ago, "and the thing they told us at the time was they might have to expand the school system out and they'd hate to let any of the land go at the time being.  They might have to build that up with the school."

"But in any event," Seaton said, summing up the situation, "we're not making any progress getting the deed."



Other Business

• Public Works Director Paul Wallace Plunk reported that the water situation is about back to normal after the long hot summer, except for a large number of leaks.  "There were some big ones," he said in response to a question from the mayor.  "Thirty on service lines, and fourteen on main lines."

• Parks and Recreation Director Moffett reported 190 participants in the junior pro football program, and 50 cheerleaders as well.  In addition to the ten football teams, she told the board, the department also has fifteen soccer teams.

• Regarding the one item of "old business" on the agenda, Mayor Morris asked city recorder Jimmie Burks to update the board on the upgrade to the Enville Water Pump Station.  Burks said "All y'all need to do is approve this bill getting paid.  Y'all agreed for us to do that, but you did not make a vote on it, and it's spending money so we have to have a vote."  Garrison moved that the $10,368 bill be paid, and the motion carried unanimously after a second by Hudson.  "We haven’t had a complaint from Enville since we got that station up there," Plunk advised the board, and Browder observed that it was "money well spent."

• Garrison asked the board to consider reinstituting the policy of opening city meetings with a prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance.  "This would set our hearts and our minds and maybe put us in a better, it would set the tone for better conduct, and better good mood, and would put our hearts and minds in the right places."  Garrison explained that the board used to do this but the practice had "got lost along the way."  Hudson moved that the practice be resumed, and the motion, seconded by Norris, passed unanimously.

• The last item on the agenda was "Sexually Oriented Businesses," and Commissioner Norris explained that an "adult" store had opened in Crump "and I just wonder if everybody is aware of that."  Crump did not have an ordinance in place, "so they couldn't prevent it, and I got all alarmed today.  I though we had some [ordinances] here, but I didn't—"  "We've got a good one," Mayor Morris assured him.  Norris continued, "I just wondered if we might want to try to help Crump, you know, because if they don't do something about that there'll be another one show up, and another one and another one.  I guess that's what concerns me as much as anything."




Town Board Meeting

20 August 2007


Meeting ends abruptly

The August meeting of the Adamsville Town Board ended abruptly Monday night when two of the board members walked out, leaving the board unable to conduct business because of the absence of a quorum.

“You know,” Alderman Mike Norris said as he gathered up his papers, “I’m not going to sit here and listen to this.  I’m done.”  And with that he departed, followed closely by Alderman Ann Hudson.  As Alderman Jeff Browder was absent, this left only Mayor Tommy Morris and Alderman Dwana Garrison—ironically, the very people whose escalating argument had led to the exodus of Norris and Hudson—and, as town attorney Ken Seaton told the mayor, “Without a quorum you can’t take any action.”


A calm beginning

The August 20 meeting had begun without any hint of the fireworks that were to come.  The minutes were unanimously approved without discussion (on a motion by Hudson, seconded by Norris).  The mayor then introduced the budget, saying that “We’re 8% into the year, and everything looks okay.  We’re above revenue on about three points, above expenditures on one, but nothing to worry about.”  The financial report was unanimously approved, on a motion by Garrison, seconded by Hudson.  One item on the police report caught Hudson’s eye: “What’s this assault on an officer?” she asked Police Chief Bill McCall.  “That was a drunk lady that didn’t want to go to jail,” the chief explained.


Water problems

Inevitably, the continuing drought was the object of considerable discussion (it was to come up again, later, as a part of the angry exchange which brought the meeting to a premature close).  Hudson asked Water Supervisor Paul Wallace Plunk to “update us on the water situation, the problems we’ve been having.”

“We’re holding our own,” Plunk said.  “Nineteen straight days we’ve pumped over a million gallons a day. Normally we’d use about 800,000, so we’re up about 200,000 a day.  We’ve asked for lawn watering to stop, and all this.  And some of it stopped, and some didn’t.  Out in the rural area I know they are still watering.  In town there wasn’t, but I know there was outside, because when the rain came you could tell the difference.”

Hudson also enquired about the interruption of water service in some areas, which Plunk explained was the result of some blown fuses causing a water pump to kick off.  Norris asked about cloudiness in the water, and Plunk said “That’s air in your line.”  Mayor Morris said the problem would ordinarily be cured by flushing the line, but with the water shortage that could not now be done.

Town Manager Terry Thrasher informed the board that the water department was producing substantially more water this year than last.  “We’re three million gallons more we’re pumping now than we were a year ago,” which led the mayor to express his views on what the city needed to do to deal with potential water problems in the future.

“We need to top start improving our water system, like take the main things, like from the well to the pump, and make sure we’ve got plenty of water there, and then from the filtering plant, make sure we’ve got plenty of filtering.  When we get those two items straightened, and knowing we’ve got the water, and then we need to look about putting” in a larger storage tank.  “I recommend an underground, a ground tank.  We can build a million gallon ground tank a lot cheaper than you can put a million gallon tank up in the air.”

“We’ve got a lot of plans,” he continued.  “We kind of started that a little bit today, and we’ll keep you informed of what we come up with, what we recommend.  We’re going to be out of water.  Just like, the main line, it’s too small.  It was put in in ’46 or 7.  I worked on it.  It’s an old cast iron line that goes up and down the street here.  We need to by-pass that line some way to go and feed the tanks, so that we won’t have this drag on the water system.  You’re looking, I’d say, over a period of ten years, maybe to do this, you’re probably looking at 10-15 million dollars for what we need to do.  And that’s where we’ve really got to plan it out, because we’ve got all these subdivisions and things going in around Adamsville, it’s going to drain our system.  If we don’t do something we’re going to wind up saying, ‘No, you can’t have no water…’.”

“We’ve really put it off too long,” he continued, remarking that Paul Plunk had recently came across a letter written in 1998 addressing the town’s water problems.  “It was hid, or put back,” the mayor said of the letter.  But the problem could not be ignored any longer, he said.  “We’ve just got to the point where we’ve got to do something, and it’s going to take a lot of money.  We’re hoping, you know, that we can work some grants in, but if it don’t, then we’re going to have to bite the bullet and borrow the money to do a lot of this.”

After some discussion of other city reports (the horse show scheduled for August 18 was rescheduled to October because of the heat; attendance at the Buford Pusser Home and Museum through July was up 78 people over last year—“Sales look good,” remarked Pusser’s daughter, Dwana Garrison), Hudson moved that all reports be accepted and the motion, seconded by Norris, passed unanimously.


Downtown project

Mayor Morris then introduced Bart Walls, an associate with Askew Hargraves Harcourt and Associates, to report on the Adamsville Highway 64 Beautification Project.  “I’m happy to report to you tonight,” Walls said, “that we have the plans finished and we will be submitting them this week to TDOT to begin TDOT’s review process.  I put together a schedule that begins this week and goes all the way through the end of construction.”

Walls then passed out the schedule, which showed construction beginning the first week of January and ending the last week of June.

Mayor Morris asked “Why would you want to start the project on January 2nd?”

“Well,” Walls replied, “basically, I know the town is anxious and ready to get going on the project.  We could certainly put the project off, and start closer into springtime, but that’s going to put your completion date later into the summer.  It’s probably not the best time of the year to start from a weather standpoint, but you’re not going to have a lot of dirt moving and things like that, and some of the work can be completed in those first couple of months, and then as the weather starts getting a little bit better, if this summer is any indication, hopefully …”

Several board member chimed in with comments about the weather, then the mayor said “That’s what I was concerned with.  You know, we tear up the town there, they go down through there ripping up everything, and then what businesses that is there is going to be hurting.  And if their front is tore up for all winter long— I’d rather … I don’t know how the others feel, but I’d rather give them a later date.”

Alderman Norris pointed out that “the majority of the people park in the back of the stores,” which should minimize the disruption, and Walls said they could still go ahead on getting TDOT approval and then hold off on bidding the project until later in the year, “but the longer you wait to bid, the more expensive the project is going to be.”

Mayor Morris responded, “I wouldn’t want to hold off on the bidding, but to hold off on the start date until we see how the weather is going to be,” to which Walls replied, “Well, unfortunately, the way petroleum prices are, contractors are having difficulty getting their vendors to lock prices in on different items, and asphalt, for example, the price on asphalt is changing daily.  Piping is changing daily.  Used to, a vendor would lock their price in for 60 days, and since the hurricanes in New Orleans and Texas you can’t get prices locked in more than a week.”

Morris reiterated his principal concern, saying “We just want to make sure that we don’t shut down any businesses, you know.”

Walls replied, “We have put in the specifications as well that access has to be maintained to all the businesses at all times.”  He added, “We do have a better situation here, in that most of the businesses that are in the project limits do have rear access to the businesses, which we don’t generally have that convenience.”

Alderman Norris asked about “Right of Way Easements Acquisition,” for which Walls’ schedule showed a completion date of October 19, 2007.  “Going back to the easements.  Who’s going to handle that?”

“Well,” Walls replied, “originally we didn’t think we were going to have any right of way acquisitions.  We thought that everything, and I think the town thought this as well …”

Mayor Morris interrupted to say “I didn’t.”

Walls continued, “ … we thought that the right of way was the front of the building.  So, I think, we’re gonna work with the town to accomplish getting the easements obtained, rather than doing it all ourselves.  Because we didn’t put that in our contract initially, so…”

Garrison interrupted: “Is it all on one side, or on both sides?”

Walls said, “I think on the north side we’re talking about [gestures] that much.  Just a few inches.  Because the building fronts just barely vary on the north side.  On the south side I think we are talking about a few feet, and we did talk with TDOT and they said that it is not necessary for the town to actually own the right of way, that you could obtain an easement, and they’ll give us the easement form, with the proper language in it that we can use to go to each of the property owner and …”

Norris: “Now you’re going to come back to us, when you’ve got that form, and …”

Walls: “Yes.  TDOT will come back to us, once they’ve reviewed our plan.  They’ll sit down with us, they’ve told us that they’ll tell us exactly what we need to do to get those easements.  And then we’ll just tackle it together.  Mike [Norris], you and I will go knock on all the doors.” [LAUGHTER.]

After Walls’ departure the board spent a few minutes discussing property cleanup before turning to landscaping projects, which Town Manager Terry Thrasher said were essentially on hold.  “I could not see us putting a lot of shrubs and flowers out here when we wouldn’t let anybody else water their lawn or stuff.  And I can’t see we’re going to do it until the weather breaks.”

The board then discussed, without reaching a conclusion, putting up a sign at the Copeland Industrial Park, and then turned to the issue of street blacktopping which engendered considerable discussion.  In the end the board voted unanimously, on a motion by Norris, seconded by Garrison, to accept a bid of $60,548 submitted by Redmon, who had satisfactorily completed paving projects for the town in the past.

The board also unanimously passed, on a motion by Hudson, seconded by Garrison, the second reading of the 2006-2007 budget and tax rate ordinance.

After that, all vestiges of unanimity (and civility) vanished from the meeting room.


Meltdown

It was a most unlikely agenda item—“Parks & Recreation meeting – September”—which gave rise to the brouhaha which brought the meeting to a premature close.

It started as Dwana Garrison was describing two upcoming conferences which she wanted town employees to attend.  Ann Hudson had just asked Garrison how much the conferences would cost, when Mayor Morris interrupted.

“Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait just a minute,” the mayor said.  “Did y’all read the packet?” he asked, referring to materials which had been sent to board members which included the town policy on approval of expenditures.  “This was in your packet?” he asked Garrison, referring to the expenditure policy.

“I’ve read that, yes, sir,” Garrison replied.

“I’m the one that okays the travel.  The city commission don’t okay the travel.”

Ignoring the mayor’s statement, Hudson then asked Garrison “How much money are you talking about for the seminars?”

“Probably less than $500,” Garrison responded, also ignoring the mayor.

The mayor, however, brought the discussion back to the town’s approval policy.  “I was wanting to put it down here and discuss it without anybody here, but being as you’re bringing this other up …”

Garrison interrupted in a loud voice, which got louder as the “discussion” progressed.  “Well, please, by all means, bring it up.”

The mayor resumed, holding up the town ordinance, “If you read this—“

Garrison interrupted, saying “I did read it.”

“We have got some that don’t turn in all their receipts and all,” the mayor said.  “According to this right here [holding up the document] I’m supposed to okay every travel, everywhere that anybody travels.  And also—“

Garrison interrupted again. “I don’t think that has anything to do with it.”

Mayor: “—and also, when you go to like these trips—“

Garrison interjected a loud “Yes, sir.”

Mayor: “—your city is not supposed to pay your companion, or your wife, or anything—“

Garrison interrupted again, in an even louder voice.  “Yes, sir, I know that.  But you also know that you see in here legally that you are supposed to pay mileage.  Do you know how much mileage would have been if we were to charge you for mileage?  It would cost the city a heck of a lot more money—“

This time the mayor interrupted, “You don’t see what I’m saying—“, only to be interrupted in turn by Garrision, who said, “Yes, sir.  I do.  I know what you’re doing.  You think you can—“

Mayor: “I’m trying to save the city money.”

Garrison: “No. No.  You’re just wanting to do it to prove your point, Tommy.”

“I’m going by our ordinance—“ Mayor Morris began, before Garrison cut him off.

“Let me just do this,” she said.  “I’ll just resubmit my things and charge you for the mileage I went on the thing for.”

There was a considerable amount of cross talk among the board members, then the mayor attempted to bring the discussion back to the ordinance.  “I am the one.  If you’ll read that right there.  I am the one that okays every—“

Garrison interrupted once again, getting increasingly personal.  “You know what?  I brought it up at this meeting tonight on something that I thought was being nice.  I didn’t know you were pet-peeving about one of these here—“

Mayor: “Well, you read it.  You read it at home over the weekend.”

Garrison: “I sure did read it, but I thought you were the other pet peeve when you didn’t want them to sign their check because of the extra meal.”

Mayor: “I didn’t say extra meal.  I wanted to see the receipt that they went for.”

Garrison: “Ah, they went for the meal.  And then I sent the receipts down here.  Mayor, if I nit-picked everything you do, we’ll be here until—“

Mayor: “You already do.”

Garrison: “No, sir, but I will if you would like for me to from now on.”

Mayor: “Go ahead.  Do whatever you want to do.  You’ve done it.  You’ve done it for six years.”

Garrison: “No, sir.  Nine years.”

Garrison then took another line of attack, asking the board “You know who’s still watering over there?”

The mayor asked,  “Where?”

Garrison: “Who’s watering it, who’s watering it at your house?”

Mayor: “Yeah.”

“Yeah, and we’re supposed to have no watering going on, and now the mayor is watering at his house,” Garrison said.

“Well, you know why?” the mayor asked.  “I’ve got a pump in the lake out there.”

Garrison replied, “Do you?  I do too.  But at least I’m not getting out there throwing it in everybody’s face.”

“I’m throwing it on my yard,” the mayor responded.  “‘Cause I put the pump in,  And it ain’t costing the city one thing.”

Garrison then abandoned that tack and returned to an earlier point, saying that she brought the seminars up because she thought they would be beneficial to the town.  “But I didn’t know that the mayor was going to pitch a fit about that.  I thought he was talking about something else.”

Somewhat desperately, the mayor tried to get back to the ordinance, saying “You need to come to me first—”

Garrison interrupted again, saying  “I’ve tried to come to you first, and it don’t work that way.  You threw it back in my face.”  She then turned away from the mayor and addressed Terry Thrasher directly, telling him that she would contact him in the morning, and “I want to know exactly whatever receipts was left out, because I brought every receipt that I know of that I needed to bring”

The mayor said “I didn’t see them when I signed the checks.  And just like these trips, I can see, maybe one commissioner going, or—“

Garrison interrupted again, raising her voice almost to a shout to drown out the mayor, “Okay, let me tell you, do you know how many places there are, and how many seminars there are?”

Mayor: “—don’t need to go to.”

Garrison: “You don’t know, because you haven’t been, sir.  You’ve been—“

Mayor: “I’ve been before you every thought about being on this—“

Garrison: “Yes, sir, but you’ve not been in the last forty years—“

Mayor: “It ain’t been forty years.  I ain’t been on—

Garrison: “Twenty years.  You wouldn’t know.”

It was at this point that Alderman Norris decided he had had enough.  “You know, I’m not going to sit here and listen to this.  I’m done.”

His departure, and that of Alderman Hudson, brought the shouting to a close.  After a few moments of uncomfortable silence the mayor tried to proceed with the agenda, but Thrasher pointed out that the board no longer had a quorum, and city attorney Ken Seaton observed that “without a quorum you can’t take any action.”

“You can read,” the mayor said, and Thrasher then read through the rest of the agenda: “Wednesday, August 29, in Jackson, there’s a super allies meeting about economic development.  The meeting will run from 10 ‘til 2 and they’ll provide somebody lunch.  It’s something about economic development, and I put it in everybody’s package.  If anybody thinks they want to go, that’s that.”

“Upon my approval,” the mayor injected ironically.

Moving on to the next agenda item, Thrasher said that upgrade of Enville Pump Station was taken care of two or three months ago.

“Adamsville Golf, well we can’t take any action so there’s no reason to do that.”

The mayor then spoke up regarding the last item on the agenda: “And we’ve just discussed travel policy.  Do I hear a motion we adjourn?”

Thrasher replied, “Well you can’t…  We just need to make a statement that we have lost the quorum of the city commissioners for this meeting.  All business terminated at 8:10 p.m.”

And so it did.